The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Carton Slams Nate Burleson's Suit Shorts as a "Clown Show" Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton critiques Nate Burleson's wardrobe choice on CBS, labeling the suit shorts a "clown show" intended to grab attention. A debate follows between Carton and Chris McMonigle regarding the geographic differences between England and the United Kingdom before they pivot to NFL quarterback evaluations.

(00:01:47) Burleson Wardrobe Critique

(00:05:43) UK Geography Debate

(00:08:44) NFL Quarterback Analysis

Big Mac Claims Jerry Seinfeld Isn’t a Top 10 Stand-Up Comedian Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Carton and Big Mac analyze the Giants' keys to victory against the Rams, emphasizing the importance of a dominant ground game. They also critique Lamar Jackson’s late-game interception in the Ravens' loss to the Saints and debate Jerry Seinfeld's legacy as a stand-up comedian.

(00:01:00) Giants vs. Rams Preview

(00:05:06) Ravens and Lamar Jackson Critique

(00:10:34) Seinfeld Stand-Up Comedy Debate

Yankees Edge? Nor'easter Could Disrupt Red Sox Seeding Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

This Carton Show discussion explores how a looming Nor'easter might force the Red Sox into a doubleheader, potentially giving the Yankees an advantage in the postseason. They also analyze the Jets' fourth-quarter collapse and debate the merits of various diet sodas.

(00:01:00) Presley Gerber Passing

(00:02:25) Nor'easter Impacts MLB Seeding

(00:06:05) Diet Soda Debate

(00:08:32) Jets' Fourth-Quarter Collapse

(00:13:24) Catchphrases And Endorsements

Frank Reich's Play-Calling Under Fire After Jets' Late Collapse Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Analysis of the New York Jets centers on the disconnect between a strong defense and questionable offensive play-calling. They debate the logic behind using shotgun formations in short-yardage situations while evaluating Geno Smith's performance under center. The discussion concludes with a look at upcoming point spreads for Week 3 matchups involving the Lions and Dolphins.

(00:01:01) Jets Defensive Performance

(00:03:24) Geno Smith Assessment

(00:06:14) Shotgun Formation Debate

(00:11:17) Week 3 Betting Lines

Aaron Rodgers Critiques Jets Coaching After Frustrating Loss Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Rodgers faces criticism for his passive-aggressive leadership style after publicly questioning the coaching staff's play-calling following a Jets defeat. The discussion also covers late-game mismanagement by the coaching staff and a preview of the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Rams.

(00:01:22) Rodgers Critiques Jets Coaching

(00:04:37) Jets Fan Sharing Misery

(00:06:45) Jets Strategy Failures

(00:11:53) Youth Football Coaching Issues

(00:15:11) Giants vs. Rams Preview

Craig and Big Mac Blast Aaron Glenn After Inexplicable Jets Loss Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Jets' recent struggles, specifically targeting the coaching of Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich. They also discuss Geno Smith's cautious playstyle and address controversial comments made by reporter Ralph Vacchiano.

(00:01:01) Jets Coaching Critique

(00:05:19) Geno Smith Debate

(00:09:22) Vacchiano Tweet Controversy

Craig and C-Mac Blast Jets' Coaching Malpractice in Brutal Loss Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Craig and C-Mac dissect the New York Jets' recent loss, focusing on the glaring lack of communication between the coaching staff. They criticize the decision-making regarding clock management and the aggressive vs. conservative play-calling in critical moments. The discussion also touches on the team's overtime strategy and the impact of these recurring issues on the locker room morale.

(00:01:10) Jets Loss Analysis

(00:03:21) Clock Management Failures

(00:05:44) Overtime Strategy Debate

(00:09:51) Fan Reaction Segment

(00:13:03) Coaching Communication Issues

CRAIG CARTON BLASTS AARON GLENN: “HE COST US A W!” | Jets’ Brutal Loss to Packers Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the Carton Show by breaking down the New York Jets’ crushing overtime loss to the Green Bay Packers — and Craig is putting the blame squarely on the coaching staff.

Best of the NFL on WFAN: Could Giants and Jets start 2-0? Sep 19, 2026

Show notes

Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to give his take on Jaxson Dart making the leap in year two after a promising Week 1 performance. Plus, Evan Roberts says fans should embrace the optimism from Week 1 and believe that both New York teams could be on the rise. The Evan and Tiki crew wonder if Tyrone Tracy's job is at risk if he struggles again in Week 2, while Gio believes both the Giants and Jets are catching their Week 2 opponents at just the right time.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Pete Alonso returns Sep 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso returned to Queens this week, and it brought about PLENTY of debates. Gio says Alonso hitting his 300th career home run to tie the game in the ninth for the Orioles, and getting a curtain call as a visiting player afterward, cemented 2026 as the most embarrassing season in Mets history. Plus, KFC Barstool called in to Boomer and Gio to rip Sean Manaea for criticizing Mets fans for calling for that curtain call. Tiki Barber called out Manaea as well, while Evan sounded off on Alonso for taking the curtain call. On The Carton Show, Craig and C-Mac debate how David Stearns must feel about Alonso's return, and how it might impact Steve Cohen's thought process about the future.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected