Mystery Inc

*/ ?>

Latest Episodes:

The Tombstone Thunderbird Feb 24, 2026

Show notes

157: The Tombstone Thunderbird
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Abduction of Nancy Guthrie Feb 17, 2026

Show notes

|---|---|---|| Nancy Guthrie is 84 years old | VERIFIED | Born January 27, 1942 -- multiple sources including Wikipedia, NBC News, Fox News || Mother of NBC Today Show co-anchor Savannah Guthrie | VERIFIED | NBC News, Fox News, ABC News, multiple outlets || Lived in same home for ~50 years | VERIFIED | Tucson.com profile, NBC News || Dropped off by son-in-law after family dinner | VERIFIED | NBC News timeline, Fox News timeline || Doorbell camera disconnected at 1:47 AM | VERIFIED | WFLA timeline, NBC News, NPR || Pacemaker monitoring app disconnected at 2:28 AM | VERIFIED | WFLA timeline, NBC News, multiple outlets || Spent 17 years at University of Arizona (1990-2007) | VERIFIED | Tucson.com profile, NBC News || Created Center Stage and Med Camp programs | VERIFIED | Tucson.com, Men's Journal profile || Husband Charles died of heart attack in Mexico in 1988 | VERIFIED | Parade, The List, Hello Magazine, multiple outlets || Charles was a mining engineer | VERIFIED | Multiple sources including Tucson.com, Parade || Suspect described as male, 5'9"-5'10" | VERIFIED | FBI release, Fox News, CNN, NBC News || Ozark Trail Hiker Pack backpack identified | VERIFIED | FBI release, Fox 10 Phoenix, TV Insider (noted as 25-liter in FBI description) || Doubled vinyl gloves sealed at wrists | VERIFIED | FBI images, CBS News analysis, NBC News || Flashlight held in mouth | VERIFIED | FBI video release, multiple outlets || Blood on porch confirmed as Nancy's DNA | VERIFIED | Fox News, NBC News, forensic expert Dr. Michael Baden analysis || Droplet patterns consistent with nose/mouth/face bleeding | VERIFIED | Dr. Michael Baden analysis via Fox News, Yahoo News || Google Nest footage recovered from backend systems despite no subscription | VERIFIED | NBC News Tech, NPR, CNN Business, Tom's Guide, Fortune || $6 million Bitcoin ransom demand | VERIFIED | TMZ (original recipient), Fortune, Fox News || Ransom demand authenticity unconfirmed by FBI | VERIFIED | ABC News, Fortune, multiple outlets || Derrick Callella (42) arrested for hoax ransom | VERIFIED | ABC7 LA, Parade, Daily Breeze -- from Hawthorne, CA (not Torrance as initially reported) || FBI reward raised to $100,000 | VERIFIED | ABC7, Hollywood Reporter, CNN, FBI release || Pima County Sheriff leads with FBI assistance | VERIFIED | Multiple outlets; tension between agencies reported by NewsNation, TMZ || Glove sent to private lab in Florida for DNA | VERIFIED | NewsNation, Fox News, CNN -- Sheriff Nanos confirmed Florida lab |
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Where It All Began Feb 10, 2026

Show notes

Zoinks! The gang is going back to where it all started.
Three years ago, two brothers sat down in front of a microphone with nothing but a shared love of mysteries and a beat-up Tesla they called the Mystery Machine. Episode 1 was raw, unpolished, and absolutely chaotic—and now it's been remastered for a whole new generation of mystery lovers to experience.
This special throwback episode takes us deep into the Appalachian Mountains, where locals have whispered for generations about things that live in the caves. Not bears. Not mountain lions. Something else entirely. The witnesses describe creatures that shouldn't exist, sounds that echo from underground passages, and encounters that left hardened outdoorsmen refusing to return to certain hollows. What's lurking in those ancient cave systems? The gang dives into the folklore, the sightings, and the geological oddities that might explain—or deepen—the mystery.
But that's only half of this wild ride.
The episode takes a sharp turn into true crime territory with the disturbing case of Jared Fogle, the former Subway spokesperson whose carefully constructed public image hid something far darker. This isn't just a retelling of headlines. One of the hosts reveals a personal encounter with Fogle before the world knew what he really was—a moment that hits differently knowing what we know now.
This remastered version cleans up the audio quality while preserving everything that made the original Episode 1 special: the unscripted energy, the genuine reactions, and the chemistry between Shane and Josh that would become the foundation of The Haunted Bunker. It's a time capsule and a celebration rolled into one.
Whether you've been with the gang since day one or you're discovering us for the first time, this episode shows exactly what The Haunted Bunker is all about—strange creatures, disturbing crimes, personal stories, and two brothers who aren't afraid to go wherever the mystery leads.
The trail leads back to 2022, but the questions remain unanswered.
**What you'll hear in this episode:**- Chilling accounts of cave-dwelling creatures in Appalachia- The full Jared Fogle story with a firsthand encounter- The original Episode 1 chemistry, now remastered- Why this episode launched three years of mystery exploration
---
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

154 Unmasked: The Bridgewater Triangle Feb 03, 2026

Show notes

What's up, gang!Pull up a chair in the bunker—we're going off-script tonight. After recording our Bridgewater Triangle episode, something clicked, and we decided to try an experiment: what happens when the skeptic and the believer trade places?Shane attempts to make the case FOR the paranormal. Jinkies, it's harder than he expected. The arguments have emotional weight. He has to actively work to stay skeptical in his normal life.Josh plays devil's advocate and discovers that being the skeptic is exhausting. You have to explain everything. No mystery is allowed. It feels like being the fun police.We dig into the arguments that actually made us pause—the concentration problem, the historical trauma theory, why named witnesses matter. And we get vulnerable about what it would actually take to change our minds.Equal parts philosophical and hilarious—exactly what happens when we stop researching and start really talking.Thanks for being part of the Inner Circle, gang. Your support keeps the bunker lights on.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Bridgewater Triangle Feb 03, 2026

Show notes

The Wampanoag called it Hockomock—"place where spirits dwell." They named it that twelve thousand years before anyone else noticed something was wrong with this swamp.Tonight we descend into the Bridgewater Triangle, a 200-square-mile region in southeastern Massachusetts where Bigfoot stalks the wetlands, UFOs hover over highways, and the ghost of an 80-year-old war captain still guards the rock where he surrendered three centuries ago.In 1978, Joseph DeAndrade walked into Hockomock Swamp and walked out describing a seven-foot creature covered in hair. He wasn't the first. He wouldn't be the last. Drivers on Route 44 still report picking up a red-haired hitchhiker who climbs into their backseat and vanishes. Visitors to Anawan Rock see phantom campfires flickering where a Wampanoag warrior gave up sacred wampum belts before his execution.King Philip's War soaked this ground in blood. The Freetown State Forest hid genuine horrors in the 1980s. And cryptozoologist Loren Coleman drew a triangle around all of it, connecting the dots of fifty years of documented strangeness.Maybe it's swamp gas. Maybe it's bears. Maybe it's the power of suggestion.Or maybe the Wampanoag knew exactly what they were talking about when they named this place.Some mysteries aren't meant to be solved. They're meant to be felt.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Voice That Vanished: Hollywood's Darkest Secret Jan 27, 2026

Show notes

What's up, gang? This week, Josh takes the wheel for one of the most heartbreaking mysteries in Hollywood history—the tragic story of Judith Barsi.You probably know her voice even if you don't recognize her name. At just ten years old, Judith had already appeared in over 70 commercials and landed iconic voice roles that still resonate with audiences today. She was the voice behind Ducky in The Land Before Time and Anne-Marie in All Dogs Go to Heaven—characters whose optimistic catchphrases like "Yep! Yep! Yep!" masked a devastating reality happening off-screen.Josh dives deep into what made Judith so special in the industry, why directors fought to cast her despite her small stature, and the warning signs that everyone seemed to miss. The gang also discusses similar cases of young stars whose bright lights were extinguished too soon, including Jonathan Brandis and Aaron Carter.But it's not all heavy stuff—Shane and Josh also catch up on winter weather survival stories (including that infamous rice cake incident from their youth), family updates about a new baby girl, and their thoughts on period dramas getting historical details hilariously wrong.Join us as we remember a voice that touched millions, and explore why Hollywood's youngest stars often face its darkest shadows.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Lead Masks of Vintem Hill | Brazil 1966 Jan 20, 2026

Show notes

Two men in suits. Two homemade lead masks. One cryptic note. And a mystery that's haunted Brazil for nearly sixty years.In August 1966, a teenager flying a kite on a hillside outside Rio de Janeiro stumbled onto a scene that would become one of South America's most baffling unsolved cases. Two electronics technicians—Manoel Pereira da Cruz and Miguel José Viana—lay dead on the grass, positioned side by side like they'd simply fallen asleep. But they weren't sleeping. And the crude lead masks covering their eyes weren't for rest.Jinkies—wait until you hear what was in their pockets.A handwritten note with specific instructions. References to ingesting capsules at precise times. And the chilling phrase: "Await signal. Mask."The gang investigates what these two "scientific spiritualists" were actually doing on that remote hillside. Both men had lied to their families about where they were going. Both had been conducting experiments combining electronics with supernatural practices. And both died reaching for something—whether spirits, extraterrestrials, or something else entirely—that required lead shielding and careful preparation.What killed them? The most frustrating part: we may never know. Brazilian authorities in 1966 never performed a toxicology test. Two men found dead with a note explicitly mentioning capsules, and no one thought to check what those capsules contained. The case was closed as "undetermined."Like, what if someone gave them those capsules knowing exactly what would happen?Shane, Josh, and Kim explore every theory—from a spiritual experiment gone wrong to UFO contact (witnesses reported strange orange lights over the hill that night) to murder by a mysterious female contact who purchased the water bottle found at the scene but was never investigated. The trail leads through 1960s Brazilian spiritualism, amateur electronics experiments, and a community of believers who thought they could contact beings from other dimensions.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Salish Sea Feet | 21 Sneakers, No Bodies Jan 06, 2026

Show notes

Jinkies—since 2007, at least twenty-one human feet have washed ashore along the coastlines of British Columbia and Washington State. All of them still wearing athletic shoes. No bodies. No explanations. Just feet.In this episode, Shane, Josh, and Kim investigate one of the strangest forensic mysteries of the 21st century. The gang traces the trail from that first disturbing discovery on Jedediah Island—when a twelve-year-old girl found a Size 12 Adidas sneaker that was far too heavy—through seventeen years of shocking discoveries that had the world convinced a serial killer was stalking the Pacific Northwest.The theories ran wild. A drug cartel dumping bodies. A government cover-up. "The Sneaker Killer" targeting victims by their footwear. The 2004 Asian tsunami somehow depositing remains twelve thousand miles away. Someone even planted a hoax—an animal paw stuffed into a sneaker—desperate to feed the frenzy.But the truth? It might be even more unsettling than fiction.Forensic science eventually provided an explanation that nobody expected. Modern athletic shoes—with their lightweight EVA foam and air pockets—float. When bodies decompose in cold water, the ankle joint naturally separates within days to weeks. Before the 1970s, leather shoes would have kept these feet on the ocean floor forever. But Nike Air technology turned human feet into messages from the dead, carried by currents that all flow toward shore.The BC Coroners Service has been categorical: no evidence of foul play in any of the discoveries. No tool marks. No cutting. Every identified victim matches a documented suicide, drowning accident, or natural death.And yet... not every case fits neatly into that explanation. Antonio Neill was twenty-two when he disappeared from Everett, Washington in December 2016. His boot—with his foot still inside—washed up on Jetty Island two years later. His mother recognized it immediately. The Snohomish County Sheriff's Office still has his case open. Still classified as suspicious.Of those twenty-one feet, approximately six remain unidentified. Six families who don't know what happened to their loved ones. Six names attached to cold cases that may never be closed.Some mysteries have explanations. Others have closure. This one offers something rarer—a reminder that the ocean keeps its secrets, but sometimes gives something back.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Tomte: Scandinavian Spirits That Came Before Santa Dec 30, 2025

Show notes

Long before Santa Claus squeezed down chimneys with bags of presents, Scandinavian families knew something else watched over their homes during the darkest nights of winter—something small, ancient, and very particular about its porridge.The MysteryIn the folklore of Sweden, Norway, Denmark, and Finland, the Tomte (or Nisse, depending on where you're from) has been guarding homesteads for centuries. These diminutive spirits—typically described as elderly men the size of young children with long white beards and red caps—were believed to protect families, tend to livestock, and bring abundance to farms that earned their respect.But the Tomte's help came with conditions. They demanded cleanliness, proper treatment of animals, and one non-negotiable offering: a bowl of Christmas porridge with butter on top, left out on Yule. Forget the butter? The consequences could be severe—from mischievous pranks like tying cows' tails together to outright catastrophe for the farm's fortune.What We ExploreJosh Waters takes Shane deep into the world of these fascinating household spirits, exploring their origins in pre-Christian Norse tradition and their surprising connection to modern Christmas customs. You'll discover why the Tomte is considered an ancestral guardian, what happens when you hide the butter under the porridge (spoiler: don't), and how these ancient spirits evolved into the gift-giving Jultomte and Julenisse we recognize today.Plus: An extended conversation about the brothers' favorite Christmas treats and Josh's meticulous eating rituals that have to be heard to be believed.Sources & Further Reading

Wikipedia: Nisse (folklore) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nisse_(folklore)
Ingebretsen's Nordic Marketplace: Legend of the Nisse and Tomte - https://ingebretsens-blog.com/legend-of-the-nisse-and-tomte/

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

The Greenbrier Ghost: America's Only Murder Solved by Spirit Testimony Dec 23, 2025

Show notes

Alright gang, buckle up—because this case gets weird.In January 1897, a young bride named Zona Heaster Shue was found dead in her rural West Virginia home. The local doctor took one look and said "heart trouble." Her husband Erasmus—who went by "Trout," which should've been everyone's first red flag—played the grieving widower perfectly. Case closed, right?Not so fast.Zona's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, wasn't buying it. Something about her new son-in-law just didn't sit right. So she did what any determined mother would do: she prayed for answers. For four straight weeks. And then, according to her actual sworn testimony in an actual courtroom, her daughter's ghost showed up. Four nights in a row. With receipts.The spirit allegedly revealed that Trout had flown into a rage because dinner didn't include meat—and snapped her neck over it.Now here's where it gets really interesting. Mary Jane took these ghostly details to prosecutor John Alfred Preston, and somehow convinced him to dig deeper. Literally. When they exhumed Zona's body, the autopsy found exactly what the ghost described: broken neck, crushed windpipe, finger marks on the throat.Trout Shue was arrested, and what followed was one of the most bizarre trials in American legal history—the only known murder case where spectral testimony helped secure a conviction.Jinkies.Sources & Further Reading:West Virginia Encyclopedia - Greenbrier GhostGreenbrier County Tourism - The Greenbrier GhostHistorical Marker Database - Greenbrier Ghost
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected