Love Marry Kill

Kim and David Camm - Part 1 Oct 28, 2024

On September 28, 2000, David Camm returned home from a night of playing basketball with friends to find his wife and two young children brutally murdered. Despite his 10-year career as an Indiana State Trooper, suspicion quickly fell upon him due in part to a botched investigation of the crime scene. What followed is an unbelievable 13-year legal battle as David fought to prove his innocence.
Hear both parts today on Patreon.
Today's snack: Cucumber salad
Sources:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mv8z13kqzZY 3D YouTube channel interview w/ David Camm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jvXn6CahJ0 Charles Boney interview
Glatt, John. (2007) One Deadly Night: A State Trooper, Triple Homicide and a Search for Justice. St. Martin's Publishing Group (St. Martin's True Crime Library). Kindle Edition.
Dunn, Gary (2022) Their Bloody Lies and Persecution of David Camm. Peppertree Press. Kindle Edition
https://www.newspapers.com/image/180690220/?match=1&terms=David%20Camm
https://www.newspapers.com/image/107494903/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/107975437/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/108007486/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/127385359/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/127386549/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/127412799/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/127419548/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/126701976/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/search/results/?date-end=2024&date-start=2006&keyword=%22David+Camm%22&publication-ids=384&region=us-in&sort=paper-date-asc
https://www.newspapers.com/image/126704604/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/126711225/?match=1&terms=%22David%20Camm%22
https://www.newspapers.com/image/180656777/?terms=David%20Camm
https://www.newspapers.com/image/759492629/?terms=david%20camm
https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/pages/casedetail.aspx?caseid=4291
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/9379960/amos_h-lockhart#view-photo=19266744
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/murder-on-lockhart-road/
https://www.southbendtribune.com/story/news/2014/08/24/slain-womans-parents-drop-wrongful-death-sui/46603033/
https://www.wave3.com/story/3010548/boney-says-he-has-alibi-for-night-camm-family-was-killed/
https://www.indystar.com/story/news/crime/2013/09/12/david-camm-confessed-to-murders-while-getting-tattooed-former-inmate-says-/2806371/
https://www.wdrb.com/news/david-camm-awarded-more-than-5-million-in-settlements-of-wrongful-arrest-lawsuits/article_4faaf19e-c661-11ec-a8c5-3be24717f459.html

Marlene and Michael Warren Oct 21, 2024

On a quiet May 1990 morning in the upscale village of Wellington, Florida, Marlene Warren answered her front door to a brightly dressed clown bearing flowers and balloons. The clown calmly pulled out a gun and fatally shot Marlene from point blank range. Why would anyone want to kill Marlene? It would take decades to unravel this bizarre mystery.
Today's snack: Thinsters Key Lime Pie
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/LoveMarryKill
Sources:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/florida-killer-clown-case-sheila-keen-warren-marlene-warren-murder-48-hours/
ABC 20/20, S45 E29, The Case of the Killer Clown
Snapped, S33 E19, Sheila Keen Warren
48 Hours, Murder by Clown, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEpzQtnz9y0
Felonious Florida, The Killer Clown of Wellington
Zeman, David. “Masked clown bore flowers, gifts – and a gun.” The Miami Herald, May 27, 1990, p. A1.
Rozsa, Lori. “No motive in clown shooting.” The Miami Herald, May 30, 1990, p. B1.
Kozlowski, Ron. “Murder involving clown well-planned, police say.” The Palm Beach Post, May 30, 1990, p. B1.
Rozsa, Lori. “Clown-killing probe investigates link between auto firm, stolen car.” The Miami Herald, Jun 2, 1990, p. A1.
Kozlowski, Ron. “Police inspect victim’s phone records in clown slaying.” The Palm Beach Post, Jun 6, 1990, p. A1.
Ross Albers, Rebecca. “Racketeering, auto theft charges filed.” The Miami Herald, Oct 27, 1990, p. 2B.
Somerville, Sean. “Woman couldn’t be killer clown, kin say.” The Palm Beach Post, Nov 11, 1990, p. 1A.
Rozsa, Lori. “Slaying began 8-month ordeal, says ‘clown murder’ suspect.” The Miami Herald, Feb 3, 1991, p. 1A.
Caputo, Marc. “Errors found in sheriff’s evidence procedures.” The Palm Beach Post, Feb 16, 2000, p. 1B.
Duret, Daphne, et al. “Documents give deepest look yet at 1990 case.” The Palm Beach Post, Apr 14, 2018, p. 1A.
Freeman, Marc. “Husband of killer clown suspect: Cops ‘had nothing before, have nothing now’.” Florida Sun Sentinel, May 12, 2019, p. B1.
Freeman, Marc. “Clown suspect says she can’t afford defense.” Florida Sun Sentinel, Nov 9, 2019, p. A1.

Jennifer and Michael Blagg - Part 2 Oct 14, 2024

By all accounts, Jennifer and Michael Blagg were the perfect couple and the envy of their friends. Michael had a great job and was devoted to his wife and adorable 6-year-old daughter, Abby. But when Michael came home from work on November 13, 2001, to find his wife and daughter missing and bloodstains in the bedroom, his world was shattered. What unfolded in the coming months was a shocking story of a man leading two lives, one public and one private. Begging the question, can you ever really know anyone?
Support us on Patreon.
Today's snacks: Canyon Poppers and Caramelized onion dip

Jennifer and Michael Blagg - Part 1 Oct 07, 2024

By all accounts, Jennifer and Michael Blagg were the perfect couple and the envy of their friends. Michael had a great job and was devoted to his wife and adorable 6-year-old daughter, Abby. But when Michael came home from work on November 13, 2001, to find his wife and daughter missing and bloodstains in the bedroom, his world was shattered. What unfolded in the coming months was a shocking story of a man leading two lives, one public and one private. Begging the question, can you ever really know anyone?
Support on on Patreon and listen to both parts today.
Today's snack:
Rocky Mountain Avalance Bars (no-bake)
4 (24 oz )cups white chocolate chips
3/4 (6.6 oz) cup peanut butter
3 cups rice krispies
3 cups mini marshmallows
1/2 cup crushed pretzels
1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
-------------------------------------------

Place semi-sweet chocolate chips in the freezer for at least 15 minutes.
Line a 9 x11 pan with parchment paper.
Melt peanut butter and white chocolate chips in the microwave for 90 seconds at 50% power, stir, and repeat for another 90 seconds, at 50% power. Stir until smooth.
Stir in pretzels, mini marshmallows, rice krispies, and semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Pour into the prepared pan and press down firmly. Sprinkle lightly with flaked salt, if desired. Refrigerate until firm, about 1 hour.
Note: Every microwave is different; white chocolate can seize quickly, so use caution, and start slowly.

Sources:

Francis, Eric. (2008). Taken From Home: A Father, a Dark Secret, and a Brutal Murder. St. Martin’s Paperbacks.
Scott, Robert. (2014). Killer Dad. Pinnacle Books.
https://www.cbsnews.com/video/dark-side-of-the-mesa-1/ 48 Hours
fredhutch.org/en/news/center-news/2018/07/endometriosis-linke
d-to-childhood-abuse.html
https://pluto.tv/us/on-demand/series/61247028d343140013d47185/season/19/episode/61259a4cd24f5e00135eb982
https://people.com/crime/juror-marilyn-charlesworth-sued-for-overturned-murder-conviction/
https://www.peacocktv.com/watch/playback/vod/GMO_00000000393628_01/e4b2258c-90c7-35d0-a545-387bcefb55f6
https://www.visitgrandjunction.com/plan-your-visit/about-grand-junction/
https://www.gjsentinel.com/county-suicide-rate-higher-than-state-national-averages-study-finds/article_11e96bda-2d6a-11ee-a2a3-273ec7080fcf.html
https://www.9news.com/article/news/local/michael-blagg-trial/i-was-under-a-lot-of-stress-michael-blagg-addresses-behavior-after-wifes-murder/73-532626109

Kari and Matt Baker - Part 3 of 3 Sep 30, 2024

Matt and Kari Baker seemed like the perfect couple with the perfect family. Living near Waco, Texas, Matt was a Baptist minister and Kari was a third grade teacher. They were raising two beautiful daughters, Kensi and Grace. But Kari’s family and friends knew that she had struggled. Seven years earlier, she and Matt had lost another daughter, Kassidy, soon after her first birthday. When Kari died in April 2006, her death was quickly ruled a suicide. But, Kari’s family and friends had a hard time accepting that conclusion. They saw someone who was a fighter and would do anything to be there for her daughters. They were determined to find out the truth, no matter how long it would take or how difficult it would be.
Today's snack: Hostess Meltamors
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Kari and Matt Baker - Part 2 of 3 Sep 23, 2024

Matt and Kari Baker seemed like the perfect couple with the perfect family. Living near Waco, Texas, Matt was a Baptist minister and Kari was a third grade teacher. They were raising two beautiful daughters, Kensi and Grace. But Kari’s family and friends knew that she had struggled. Seven years earlier, she and Matt had lost another daughter, Kassidy, soon after her first birthday. When Kari died in April 2006, her death was quickly ruled a suicide. But, Kari’s family and friends had a hard time accepting that conclusion. They saw someone who was a fighter and would do anything to be there for her daughters. They were determined to find out the truth, no matter how long it would take or how difficult it would be.
Today's snacks: Lay's West Indies Hot n' Sweet Chilli Chips, Masala Murukku, and Britannia Little Hearts
Listen to all three parts on Patreon now.

Kari and Matt Baker - Part 1 of 3 Sep 16, 2024

Matt and Kari Baker seemed like the perfect couple with the perfect family. Living near Waco, Texas, Matt was a Baptist minister and Kari was a third grade teacher. They were raising two beautiful daughters, Kensi and Grace. But Kari’s family and friends knew that she had struggled. Seven years earlier, she and Matt had lost another daughter, Kassidy, soon after her first birthday. When Kari died in April 2006, her death was quickly ruled a suicide. But, Kari’s family and friends had a hard time accepting that conclusion. They saw someone who was a fighter and would do anything to be there for her daughters. They were determined to find out the truth, no matter how long it would take or how difficult it would be.
Today’s snacks: Julio’s Corn Tortilla Chips, Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa, and Velveeta Queso con Salsa Cheese Dip
Listen to all three parts today on Patreon.
Sources:

https://www.tdcaa.com/journal/the-murdering-minister/
https://www.courttv.com/trials/tx-v-baker-2010/
Deadly little secrets : the minister, his mistress, and a heartless Texas murder, by Casey, Kathryn
https://www.texasmonthly.com/true-crime/the-valley-of-the-shadow-of-death/
https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/witness-for-the-prosecution/
20/20, The Preacher’s Hidden Life
48 Hours, S24 E6, Dirty Little Secrets
Prosecuting Evil With Kelly Siegler, S1 E6, The Mask of God
https://www.cbsnews.com/video/extra-matt-baker-talks-to-48-hours-2/
https://memorials.oakcrestwaco.com/book-of-memories/2161993/baker-kari/obituary.php
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0379073800003935
https://dontevengetstarted.blogspot.com/
https://wacotrib.com/read-the-complete-arrest-warrant-for-matt-baker/article_3729ddae-b7e5-5451-809a-a84814ada393.html

MaryJane and Christian Longo - Part 2 Sep 09, 2024

Christian Longo, 19, married his wife MaryJane, 26, in 1993 in Ann Arbor, Michigan. The couple had three children in rapid succession, Zachery, Sadie, and Madison. Chris was the sole breadwinner in the family and after his business, Final Touch Construction Cleaning, began to fail, he struggled to keep his family afloat and soon turned to a life of crime to make ends meet writing counterfeit checks. The family was in dire straits financially and had alienated all of their friends and family through Chris’ lies and deception.
They decided to head to the Oregon coast for a fresh start but soon Chris and MaryJane were out of money and options.On December 19, 2002, the body of Zachery Longo, 4, was found floating in the water. Soon after, his sister’s body was found in the same waters; later two suitcases were found containing the bodies of MaryJane and Madison.Days later, Christian Longo fled the country for Cancun Mexico.
Support us on Patreon.
Today's snack: Starburst

MaryJane and Christian Longo - Part 1 Sep 02, 2024

Christian Longo, 19, married his wife MaryJane, 26, in 1993 in Ann Arbor, Michigan. The couple had three children in rapid succession, Zachery, Sadie, and Madison. Chris was the sole breadwinner in the family and after his business, Final Touch Construction Cleaning, began to fail, he struggled to keep his family afloat and soon turned to a life of crime to make ends meet writing counterfeit checks. The family was in dire straits financially and had alienated all of their friends and family through Chris’ lies and deception.
They decided to head to the Oregon coast for a fresh start but soon Chris and MaryJane were out of money and options. On December 19, 2002, the body of Zachery Longo, 4, was found floating in the water. Soon after, his sister’s body was found in the same waters; later two suitcases were found containing the bodies of MaryJane and Madison. Days later, Christian Longo fled the country for Cancun Mexico.
Listen to both parts now on Patreon.com/LoveMarryKill
Today's snack: Dutch oven popcorn made with clarified butter and M&M's.
Sources:

Molly Watson and James Addie Aug 26, 2024

Molly Watson was about to get married to the love of her life, James Addie, and she couldn’t have been happier. The two had been together for almost seven years before Molly finally popped the question and James said yes. But Molly would not live to see the big day. Two days before the wedding she was found dead, with a single bullet through the back of her head, on a desolate dirt road in rural Monroe County, Missouri. The investigation into her death would uncover secrets that would forever change the lives of everyone in James’ and Molly’s orbit.
Support us on Patreon.
Today’s snacks: Cabot Seriously Sharp Popcorn and Crunchmaster Rice Poppers
Sources:

https://www.investigationdiscovery.com/crimefeed/murder/a-missouri-woman-was-killed-by-her-married-fiance-2-days-before-their-wedding
Evil Lives Here: Shadows of Death, S3 E2, A Double Life
20/20 S44 E10, I Now Pronounce You Dead
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8c4N85Qz9_w&list=PLMD8umRLJkKwZH-AF8VgBFcBH3ms01T_o&index=1
https://abc17news.b-cdn.net/abc17news.com/2022/07/84656-Appellants-Brief.pdf
https://www.courttv.com/trials/mo-v-addie-2021/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYUeTLdk6fU

Linda and Tom Kolman Aug 19, 2024

Linda and Tom Kolman, married 10 years, were going through a rough patch when Gilberto Nunez, a local dentist, entered their lives. Gil quickly became a close friend to both, weaving himself into their daily lives. In November 2011, Tom was found dead in his car outside of his gym, initially it was believed he suffered a heart attack. However, as the investigation unfolded, a shocking, sordid relationship was exposed.
Today's snacks: The Whole Shabang potato chips
Support us on Patreon.
Sources:

Amy and Brian Fanion Aug 12, 2024

Amy and Brian Fanion were pillars of the Westfield, Massachusetts community. Married for over 30 years, active in their church, Amy was a beloved stay-at-home mom and Brian a well-respected police detective. When Brian called 911 shortly after noon on May 8th, 2018 to say that Amy had shot herself in the head, no one who knew the couple well doubted his story. But as investigators delved into the evidence, a different picture started to emerge. Was it possible that this highly regarded police officer killed his wife in a premeditated, cold-blooded manner?
Today's snack: Cheetos Goût Fromage
Support us on Patreon
Sources:

Karen Read and John O'Keefe - Part 3 of 3 Aug 05, 2024

The Karen Read murder trial has captivated the country. Karen is accused of hitting her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe, in anger after a night of drinking with friends with her Lexus SUV when she dropped him off at a friend’s house, just after midnight on January 29, 2022 as a blizzard slammed the town of Canton, Massachusetts. After the alleged incident, Karen left the scene of the crime. Her defense made the bold claim that the Massachusetts State Police and the Canton Police Department conspired to cover up John’s murder to protect two law enforcement agents, Brian Higgins and Brian Albert and Brian’s 17-year-old nephew Colin Albert. They argued that the trio beat John and left him in the snow to die by planting evidence and coaching witnesses.
Today's snacks: Fonzies and Amica Chips - Anello Pizza
Support us on Patreon.
See part 1 show notes for list of sources and links.

Karen Read and John O'Keefe - Part 2 of 3 Jul 29, 2024

The Karen Read murder trial has captivated the country. Karen is accused of hitting her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe, in anger after a night of drinking with friends with her Lexus SUV when she dropped him off at a friend’s house, just after midnight on January 29, 2022 as a blizzard slammed the town of Canton, Massachusetts. After the alleged incident, Karen left the scene of the crime. Her defense made the bold claim that the Massachusetts State Police and the Canton Police Department conspired to cover up John’s murder to protect two law enforcement agents, Brian Higgins and Brian Albert and Brian’s 17-year-old nephew Colin Albert. They argued that the trio beat John and left him in the snow to die by planting evidence and coaching witnesses.
Today's snacks: Cheetos Sticks Palitos and Salamini Piccante
Listen to all three parts now by joining us on Patreon.

Karen Read and John O'Keefe - Part 1 of 3 Jul 22, 2024

The Karen Read murder trial has captivated the country. Karen is accused of hitting her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe, in anger after a night of drinking with friends with her Lexus SUV when she dropped him off at a friend’s house, just after midnight on January 29, 2022 as a blizzard slammed the town of Canton, Massachusetts. After the alleged incident, Karen left the scene of the crime. Her defense made the bold claim that the Massachusetts State Police and the Canton Police Department conspired to cover up John’s murder to protect two law enforcement agents, Brian Higgins and Brian Albert, and Brian’s 17-year-old nephew Colin Albert. They argued that the trio beat John and left him in the snow to die by planting evidence and coaching witnesses.
Today's snacks: Kinder Joy, Baiocchi Pistacchio, Nutella Biscuits
Listen to all three parts now: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Sources:

The Piketon Massacre - Part 2 Jul 15, 2024

In April 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were found shot and killed in cold blood in the small community of Piketon, Ohio. The killings were targeted and methodically carried out at four different crime scenes, leaving behind very little evidence. It would become one of the most complicated and lengthy investigations in Ohio history. The question on everyone’s mind: Who would mercilessly kill an entire family in cold blood?
Today’s snacks: Sun Snacks Torreznos, Lava Cheese, Omnom Chocolate Lakkrís + Sea Salt, Rjóma Kúlur
Support us on Patreon.

The Piketon Massacre - Part 1 Jul 08, 2024

In April 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were found shot and killed in cold blood in the small community of Piketon, Ohio. The killings were targeted and methodically carried out at four different crime scenes, leaving behind very little evidence. It would become one of the most complicated and lengthy investigations in Ohio history. The question on everyone’s mind: Who would mercilessly kill an entire family in cold blood?
Today’s snack: Skyline Chili
Join us on Patreon to hear both parts now, ad-free.
Sources:

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre, Peacock TV
The Piketon Massacre podcast
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZ7bVwytJTc
Knight, Cameron. “911 calls help reveal horror of family tragedy.” The Marion Star, Apr 24, 2016, p. A1.
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2016/04/25/exclusive-we-aint-no-revenge-our-hearts-pike-co-family-says/83517330/
Sweigart, Josh and Bennish, Steve. “So many ‘whys’: Ohio authorities begin work to find out who is responsible for largest mass killing in U.S. this year.” Dayton Daily News, May 1, 2016, p. 1.
BieryGolick, Keith and Fugleberg, Jeremy. “Mourners’ wish: ‘Fly high Rhodens’.” Cincinnati Enquirer, May 3, 2016, p. A5.
BieryGolick, Keith and Fugleberg, Jeremy. “‘Beyond devastation’: Six victims of April 22 shootings remembered at funeral.” Chillicothe Gazette, May 4, 2016, p. A1.
Zachariah, Holly. “Rhoden family is tired of waiting in the dark after Pike County murders.” The Journal News, Hamilton, Ohio, Jun 27, 2016, p. 14.
Zachariah, Holly and Smola, Jennifer. “Pain still fresh year after killings.” Akron Beacon Journal, Apr 18, 2017, p. B3.
Ison, Jona and Londberg, Max. “Jake Wagner pleads not guilty: Ordered held without bond on 23 charges related to 2016 Rhoden family killings.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Nov 28, 2018, p. A4.
https://www.wcpo.com/news/crime/charges-against-fredericka-wagner-dismissed-in-rhoden-family-massacre
Londberg, Max and Brookbank, Sarah. “Pike Co. sheriff pleads not guilty in 16 criminal charges.” Chillicothe Gazette, Jul 3, 2019, p. A1.
https://www.wlwt.com/article/rita-newcomb-charged-in-pike-county-homicide-case-avoids-returning-to-jail/28849160
Zachariah, Holly. “Grandmother in Rhoden coverup takes plea deal: Felony charges against Newcomb were dropped.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Dec 4, 2019, p. A8.
Mitchell, Madeline. “Rhoden massacre at 4 years and counting: Coronavirus may further delay fall murder trials.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Apr 22, 2020, p. A4.
Reutter, Justin. “Suspended Pike County sheriff pleads guilty to theft in office.” The Newark Advocate, Sep 25, 2020, p. A3.
https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/state/2021/04/22/jake-wagner-rhoden-family-homicides-pike-county-ohio-pleads-guilty/7333052002/
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2021/09/10/legal-analyst-30-year-sentence-conspirator-pike-county-slayings-fair/8281747002/
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/crime/2021/09/16/rhoden-family-murders-billy-wagner-appear-court-thursday/8351330002/
Zachariah, Holly. “Will the Rhoden family finally see a resolution?” Chillicothe Gazette, Jan 2, 2022, p. A3.
https://www.wcpo.com/news/pike-county-massacre/pike-county-murder-trial-opening-statements-start-first-trial-for-2016-massacre
https://sciotovalleyguardian.com/2022/09/12/day-1-what-you-need-to-know-about-the-first-day-of-the-rhoden-homicide-trial/
https://www.fox19.com/2022/10/26/pike-county-jury-sees-photos-murder-weapons-hidden-cement-filled-buckets/?outputType=amp
Newberry, Patricia Gallagher. “‘Snipers on a hill’: In Pike County, Jake Wagner admits to 5 of 8 Rhoden family killings.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Oct 26, 2022, p. A1.
Newberry, Patricia Gallagher. “Wagners distrusted the justice system, George Wagner IV’s mother testifies.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Nov 3, 2022, p. A4.
Gambrell, Mandy. “Pike County trial defendant George Wagner IV testifies.” Dayton Daily News, Nov 17, 2022, p. B4.
Bischoff, Laura. “DeWine: Truth is found in Pike County massacre.” Cincinnati Enquirer, Dec 2, 2022, p. A4.
https://www.wlwt.com/article/ohio-pike-county-rhoden-massacre-breakdown/41521453
Newberry, Patricia Gallagher. “Wagner IV gets life without parole for Pike County murders.” The Times Recorder, Zanesville, Ohio, Dec 21, 2022, p. A1.
Newberry, Patricia Gallagher. “Survivors of family massacre seek the Wagners’ riches: Pike wrongful death suit likely to target land.” Akron Beacon Journal, Aug 9, 2023, p. A7.

Susan and Josh Powell - Part 3 Jul 01, 2024

Susan Powell was last seen on December 6, 2009. She and her husband of 8 years, Josh Powell, lived in West Valley City, Utah. In recent years their marriage had been strained due to financial issues and Josh’s detachment from his marriage. When the Powell’s two young sons, Charlie, 4, and Braden, 2, didn’t show up at daycare and Susan didn’t show up at work, their friends and family were instantly worried. Hours later, Josh was reached on his cell phone. He said he’d left at 1 am and taken his sons camping despite the cold and snowy conditions while Susan stayed home. Josh assumed she went to work. Police interviewed Josh but he was evasive and unhelpful. However, he was not arrested. What followed was a frustrating years-long investigation, a creepy obsession, an ugly custody dispute, and a tragic end.
Today's snack: Snappers Brownie and Caramel Cluster
Support us by becoming a patron.

Susan and Josh Powell - Part 2 Jun 24, 2024

Susan Powell was last seen on December 6, 2009. She and her husband of 8 years, Josh Powell, lived in West Valley City, Utah. In recent years their marriage had been strained due to financial issues and Josh’s detachment from his marriage. When the Powell’s two young sons, Charlie, 4, and Braden, 2, didn’t show up at daycare and Susan didn’t show up at work, their friends and family were instantly worried. Hours later, Josh was reached on his cell phone. He said he’d left at 1 am and taken his sons camping despite the cold and snowy conditions while Susan stayed home. Josh assumed she went to work. Police interviewed Josh but he was evasive and unhelpful. However, he was not arrested. What followed was a frustrating years-long investigation, a creepy obsession, an ugly custody dispute, and a tragic end.
Today's snack: Ore-Ida Fast Food Fries and Fry Sauce
Listen to part 3 today by joining us on Patreon.

Susan and Josh Powell - Part 1 Jun 17, 2024

Susan Powell was last seen on December 6, 2009. She and her husband of 8 years, Josh Powell, lived in West Valley City, Utah. In recent years their marriage had been strained due to financial issues and Josh’s detachment from his marriage. When the Powell’s two young sons, Charlie, 4, and Braden, 2, didn’t show up at daycare and Susan didn’t show up at work, their friends and family were instantly worried. Hours later, Josh was reached on his cell phone. He said he’d left at 1 am and taken his sons camping despite the cold and snowy conditions while Susan stayed home. Josh assumed she went to work. Police interviewed Josh but he was evasive and unhelpful. However, he was not arrested. What followed was a frustrating years-long investigation, a creepy obsession, an ugly custody dispute, and a tragic end.
Today's snack: Cream cheese pancakes
Join us on Patreon to hear all three parts of this episode today.
Sources:

Anne Scripps and Scott Douglas Jun 10, 2024

An heiress to the Scripps newspaper fortune, Anne Scripps had a privileged upbringing. When her first marriage ended in divorce she quickly met and married a new man, a house painter named Scott Douglas who was nine years younger than Anne. All Anne wanted was the simple life of a suburban housewife, doting on her children and giving them the warmth and love that she didn’t receive in her own childhood. But her new marriage quickly turned into a nightmare, with a tragic outcome that would reverberate for years to come.
Today's snack: Easy homemade biscuits
Subscribe on Patreon for early, ad-free access and a monthly bonus episode.
Sources:

https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5chme0
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3047747/Scripps-newspaper-heiress-24-saw-socialite-mother-hacked-death-claw-hammer-father-released-prison-drugs-telling-judge-lost-family-friends-pets-hope-future.html
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6033219/Scripps-heiress-Tori-Scripps-Carmody-arrested-stealing-adoptive-moms-car.html
https://nymag.com/news/features/63034/
https://www.crimelibrary.org/notorious_murders/family/anne_scripps/1.html
Mangaliman, J. (1994, April 1). Cops: Case closed. Heiress’ husband jumped off bridge. Newsday, Page A4-5.
Agus, C. (1994, Feb 6). Heiress tried to disinherit husband. Newsday, Page 4.
Agus, C. (1994, Feb 24). The heiress & the house painter. Newsday, Page 68-70.
Collins, T. (1994, Oct 12). Claim barred to slain wife’s estate. Newsday (Nassau Edition), Page A20.
https://people.com/archive/heiress-to-misfortune-vol-41-no-5/

Allison and Gerard Baden-Clay - Part 2 Jun 03, 2024

Early on the morning of April 20th, 2012, Gerard Baden-Clay called to report his wife Allison missing. He said she had gone out for a walk and hadn’t returned. When the police showed up to take a report, they were immediately put on high alert because of two distinct scratches running down Gerard’s cheek, which he claimed to be the result of a shaving accident. Soon, the entire state of Queensland, Australia would be captivated by Allison’s story, with countless volunteers joining the search. As details of Gerard’s secret life, affairs, and business struggles emerged, suspicion quickly turned to him. But would there be enough evidence for justice to be served?
Give to the Allison Baden-Clay Foundation
Support us on Patreon
Today's snacks: Beignets and Aunt Sally's Creole Pralines

Allison and Gerard Baden-Clay - Part 1 May 27, 2024

Early on the morning of April 20th, 2012, Gerard Baden-Clay called to report his wife Allison missing. He said she had gone out for a walk and hadn’t returned. When the police showed up to take a report, they were immediately put on high alert because of two distinct scratches running down Gerard’s cheek, which he claimed to be the result of a shaving accident. Soon, the entire state of Queensland, Australia would be captivated by Allison’s story, with countless volunteers joining the search. As details of Gerard’s secret life, affairs, and business struggles emerged, suspicion quickly turned to him. But would there be enough evidence for justice to be served?
Listen to both parts now, ad-free, on Patreon.
Today's snacks: Vegemite toast, Tim Tams, and Violet Crumble
Sources:

Shanna Gardner and Jared Bridegan May 20, 2024

On February 16, 2022, 33-year-old Jared Bridegan was gunned down while his two-year-old daughter watched in horror from the backseat of their car. Jared and his ex-wife, Shanna Gardner, heiress to the Stampin’ Up fortune, had gone through a long and brutal custody battle but they had both recently remarried. The attack was brutal and well-planned. Jared’s murder went unsolved for a year until three shocking arrests were made, including Jared’s ex-wife and new husband.
We also discuss missing person Sara Ebersole who went missing from Reddick, Florida in March 2023.
Donate to the Bridegan Foundation or to the Bridegan family legal fund.
Support us on Patreon
Today's snacks: Chester's Puffcorn and Chomps Original Beef Sticks
Sources:

Shanti Cooper-Tronnes and David Tronnes May 13, 2024

Shanti Cooper fell in love with David Tronnes after meeting in 2013 on Match.com. After a whirlwind romance, David and Shanti moved in together. First into a rented house and later into a beautiful, historic home in Orlando, Florida that David had purchased. A major home renovation ensued but countless delays resulted in the couple being displaced from their home for over 2 years. An opportunity to appear on the show “Zombie House Flipping” surfaced. David saw this as a chance to finish their home renovation. But just as things were looking up for the couple, Shanti was found dead in their small apartment on April 24, 2018. David claimed a slip-and-fall accident must have caused her death but the crime scene told a different story.
Support us on Patreon
Sources:

The Staudte Family May 12, 2024

Join us for this special Mother's Day bonus episode, with a surprise guest host.
In 2012, the Staudte family suffered two devastating losses within five months. When a third family member fell ill soon after, suspicions were raised. An anonymous phone call to the police resulted in a shocking investigation that tore the family apart forever.
Today's snack: Depression era peanut butter bread
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Sources:

Mary and Bill Yoder - Part 2 May 06, 2024

Everyone who knew her said that 60 year old Mary Yoder was one of the most energetic, vibrant, and healthy people you could imagine. In July of 2015, she became suddenly violently ill, and two days later she passed away. The medical examiner’s investigation raised more questions than answers, with every avenue they explored resulting in a dead end. As investigators gradually unraveled the mystery, relationships would be tested and families torn apart.
Support us on Patreon.
Today's snack: https://natashaskitchen.com/buffalo-wings-recipe/

Mica and John-Paul Miller May 05, 2024

UPDATED: May 7, 2024 (updated segment starts after the 40 minute mark)
In this bonus episode, we discuss the recent news about the death of 30 year old Mica Miller from South Carolina. Mica was estranged from her controversial pastor husband, John-Paul Miller, and had recently filed for divorce. John-Paul Miller bizarrely announced his wife’s death after delivering a sermon to his congregation, claiming that she died by suicide and commenting on her mental health issues. Mica’s friends and family don’t believe that Mica died by suicide, and several have commented about her struggle to separate from both her husband and his church.
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Fundraiser to help Mica's family seek justice: https://www.gofundme.com/f/justiceformica
Sources:

Mary and Bill Yoder - Part 1 Apr 29, 2024

Everyone who knew her said that 60 year old Mary Yoder was one of the most energetic, vibrant, and healthy people you could imagine. In July of 2015, she became suddenly violently ill, and two days later she passed away. The medical examiner’s investigation raised more questions than answers, with every avenue they explored resulting in a dead end. As investigators gradually unraveled the mystery, relationships would be tested and families torn apart.
Listen to both parts, ad-free on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Today's snack: https://www.irishcentral.com/culture/food-drink/irish-crisp-sandwich
Sources:

Diane Downs - Part 2 Apr 22, 2024

On the night of May 19, 1983, Diane Downs and her three children, Christie, 8, Cheryl, 7, and Danny, 3, were shot on a rural road outside of Springfield, Oregon. Cheryl died from her injuries. Christie and Danny were gravely injured. Diane suffered non-life threatening wounds to her left arm. She claimed a bushy-haired stranger had shot them. A man-hunt came up empty for the shooter. Suspicion quickly landed on Diane partly because of her lack of emotion. She had a history of messy affairs and entanglements -- most recently with a married man named Knick Knickerbocker. Diane and Knick met at the post office where they both worked. Knick had been in love with Diane but was adamant that he had no interest in being a father.
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Diane Downs - Part 1 Apr 15, 2024

On the night of May 19, 1983, Diane Downs and her three children, Christie, 8, Cheryl, 7, and Danny, 3, were shot on a rural road outside of Springfield, Oregon. Cheryl died from her injuries. Christie and Danny were gravely injured. Diane suffered non-life threatening wounds to her left arm. She claimed a bushy-haired stranger had shot them. A man-hunt came up empty for the shooter. Suspicion quickly landed on Diane partly because of her lack of emotion. She had a history of messy affairs and entanglements -- most recently with a married man named Knick Knickerbocker. Diane and Knick met at the post office where they both worked. Knick had been in love with Diane but was adamant that he had no interest in being a father.
Listen to both parts now, ad-free on Patreon.
Sources:

Sheri and Chris Coleman - Part 2 Apr 08, 2024

Sheri Coleman, 31, and her two sons, Garrett, 11, and Gavin, 9, were found brutally murdered in their home in Columbia, Illinois on the morning of May 5, 2009. Chris Coleman, 32, Sheri’s husband and the boys father, worked as televangelist Joyce Meyer’s head of security. He’d been receiving threatening messages from an unknown source warning him his family would be killed if he didn’t quit his job with the ministry. As the investigation unfolded, investigators learned that Chris Coleman was having an extramarital affair with his wife’s high school best friend, Tara. Was Chris’ family murdered by an unknown intruder or was it an elaborately planned scheme to start a new life?
Support us on Patreon.

Sheri and Chris Coleman - Part 1 Apr 01, 2024

Sheri Coleman, 31, and her two sons, Garrett, 11, and Gavin, 9, were found brutally murdered in their home in Columbia, Illinois on the morning of May 5, 2009. Chris Coleman, 32, Sheri’s husband and the boys father, worked as televangelist Joyce Meyer’s head of security. He’d been receiving threatening messages from an unknown source warning him his family would be killed if he didn’t quit his job with the ministry. As the investigation unfolded, investigators learned that Chris Coleman was having an extramarital affair with his wife’s high school best friend, Tara. Was Chris’ family murdered by an unknown intruder or was it an elaborately planned scheme to start a new life?
Get ad-free access to part 2 now by joining us on Patreon.
Sources:

One Last Kiss: The True Story of a Minister's Bodyguard, His Beautiful Mistress, and a Brutal Triple Homicide (Kindle Edition) by Michael W. Cuneo (Author) 2012, St. Martins True Crime
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK549867/#:~:text=Rigor%20mortis%20appears%20approximately%202,after%20death)%20and%20then%20disappears.
https://www.ksdk.com/article/news/judge-dismisses-joyce-meyer-lawsuit-tied-to-coleman-murder-case/63-416053029
https://fox2now.com/news/fox-files/whats-happened-to-the-coleman-memorial-money/
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/36949526/sheri_ann-coleman
https://www.newspapers.com/image/151603538/?terms=%22Chris%20Coleman%22&match=1
https://www.stlmag.com/A-Family-Erased-The-Chris-Coleman-Story/
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/man-accused-of-killing-family-texts-girlfriend-from-wifes-funeral/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQ7EH3Hpyp4
https://www.newspapers.com/image/139232117/?terms=Joyce%20Meyer%20Ministries&match=1
https://yen.com.gh/facts-lifehacks/biographies/205517-chris-coleman-coleman-family-murders-what-happened-today/

Catherine and Andrew Suh, and the murder of Robert O’Dubaine Mar 25, 2024

On September 25th, 1993, 31-year-old nightclub owner Robert O’Dubaine was shot and killed in cold blood in the garage of his Chicago home. Investigators first believed it to be a random carjacking, but as they delved deeper they realized this was a targeted killing. As they uncovered more about Robert’s relationship with his girlfriend, Catherine Suh, and her brother Andrew, a picture emerged of past sins and a sense of family duty that ultimately led to Robert’s demise.
Join us on Patreon for early, ad-free access and bonus episodes.
Sources:

https://www.oxygen.com/killer-siblings/crime-news/catherine-suh-manipulates-brother-andrew-into-killing-robert-odubane
https://www.oxygen.com/killer-siblings/season-2/episode-3/suhs
https://heavy.com/news/catherine-suh-today/
Hilkevitch, J. (1993, November 13). Student’s bond with sister linked to ambush slaying. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-5.
Wilson, T. (1995, September 28). Poof! Death plot woman disappears. Chicago Tribune, Page 2-2.
Martin, A. (1996, March 9). Fugitive’s life on run fizzles in Honolulu. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-1.
Martin, A. (1996, March 31). Fugitive ‘goddess’ led a life of fraud, lies – and murder. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-1.
Kaiser, R. (1998, May 14). 100-year prison term grim end to golden life. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-1.
Goldsborough, B. (1998, September 20). Past is prologue. Chicago Tribune, Page 16-5.
Gutowski, C. (2017, July 12). Inmate’s supporters urge clemency. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-8.
Gutowski, C. (2024, January 27). Man in ‘93 ‘black widow’ murder case released. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-1.
Gutowski, C. (2023, September 6). ‘Black widow’ murderer seeking early release. Chicago Tribune, Page 1-1.
https://digitaledition.chicagotribune.com/tribune/article_popover.aspx?guid=7d062082-46d9-4351-a5d6-a81bc9edd96b
https://heavy.com/news/robert-odubaine-murder/
https://thecinemaholic.com/robert-odubaine-murder-how-did-he-die-who-killed-him/
Dateline: Season 29, Episode 51, Twisted Loyalty
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca7-09-03946/pdf/USCOURTS-ca7-09-03946-0.pdf
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/148463125/robert-w.-o'dubaine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjwZtm0Fkus
https://archive.org/details/MSNBCW_20111203_220000_The_House_of_Suh/start/3540/end/3600

Sharon Lynn Douglas Fuller Nelson Harrelson Mar 18, 2024

There was something about Sharon Lynn Douglas Fuller Nelson Harrelson that men couldn’t resist. From her first husband to her last, no man left Sharon willingly. Once a pastor’s wife, Sharon was consumed by sex, money and power and would do anything to obtain it but inevitably this black widow’s actions would catch up with her.
Get early, ad-free access plus bonus episodes on Patreon.
Source: Olsen, Gregg. American Black Widow: The Shocking True Story of a Preacher's Wife Turned Killer (also called Bitch on Wheels) 1998

Florence and Jean-Claude Romand Mar 11, 2024

Jean-Claude Romand seemed to have the perfect life. He was a well-respected researcher at the World Health Organization. He and his wife Florence had two beautiful children, a lovely home, and a close circle of friends. However, his entire adult life was built on a foundation of lies that all came crashing down on a horrible day in January of 1993. Everyone was suddenly asking the question, who was Jean-Claude Romand?
Support us on Patreon.
Sources:

Belinda and David Temple - Part 2 Mar 04, 2024

David Temple, a standout athlete in high school and college hailing from Katy, Texas, tied the knot with Belinda Lucas in 1992. Initially, they seemed like the ideal couple—both attractive and passionate about sports. However, beneath the surface, David's forceful and controlling nature began to overshadow Belinda's once vibrant and happy spirit. Amidst the challenges, David engaged in an extramarital affair with a fellow teacher during Belinda's second pregnancy. In January 1999, David discovered Belinda shot dead in their walk-in closet. In part two of two, we discuss how suspicion quickly fell on David, although the case wasn’t a slam dunk case for prosecutors. Listen today to hear how this heart-wrenching story ends.
Support us on Patreon.

Belinda and David Temple - Part 1 Feb 26, 2024

David Temple, a standout athlete in high school and college hailing from Katy, Texas, tied the knot with Belinda Lucas in 1992. Initially, they seemed like the ideal couple—both attractive and passionate about sports. However, beneath the surface, David's forceful and controlling nature began to overshadow Belinda's once vibrant and happy spirit. Amidst the challenges, David engaged in an extramarital affair with a fellow teacher during Belinda's second pregnancy. In January 1999, David discovered Belinda shot dead in their walk-in closet. In the first part of this two-part series, we delve into the childhoods of Belinda and David, along with their early years as a couple, leading up to the fateful day of January 11, 1999.
Get access to both parts now, with early, ad-free access on Patreon.

Faith and Gregory Green Feb 19, 2024

The first time Faith Harris saw Gregory Green was at her father’s church in Detroit, when she was just 14 years old. One day, he wasn’t there anymore, but he reappeared in church 17 years later, by which time Faith was a single mom of two. Faith knew he had been to prison, but didn’t know exactly why. They started a romance and had two children together, but Gregory’s increasingly erratic behavior would ultimately lead to an inconceivable and horrifying tragedy.
We also discuss missing person Kay-Alana Turner who has been missing from Tomball, Texas since 3/10/23.
Support us on Patreon.
Sources:

Bonus episode: Broken Hearts Collaboration Feb 14, 2024

In this special Valentine's Day bonus episode, we teamed up with some friends to bring you seven short stories of love gone horribly wrong. We hope you enjoy it! Special thanks to Christie and Melissa from Buried Motives for organizing.
Episode line-up:

Frances and Tony Toto, by Love Marry Kill
The murder of Badria Hassan, by A Million Other Choices
Marilyn and Sam Sheppard, by Enmeshed
Dalia and Mike Dippolito, by Crimes, Killers, Cults and Beer
Sarah Boone and Jorge Torres, by Music City 911
Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo, by Podcast by Proxy
Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, and Dave Kroupa, by Buried Motives

The Tan Family Feb 12, 2024

Charlie Tan, a sophomore at Cornell University, was charged with second-degree murder in the 2015 shooting death of his father, Jim Tan. The prosecution argued it was a cold-blooded, premeditated killing, while Charlie claimed he was protecting his mother after years of domestic abuse. The trial ended in a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict, leading to the dismissal of charges against Charlie, but there’s much more to the story.
Support us on Patreon for $5/month and get early, ad-free access and bonus episodes.
Sources:

The many wives of Drew Peterson - Part 2 Feb 05, 2024

Stacy Peterson, 23, was last seen on Sunday morning, October 28, 2007, in Bolingbrook, Illinois by her 53-year-old husband Drew Peterson. Drew, a police sergeant, was a 29-year veteran of the Bolingbrook Police Department. Stacy planned to meet her sister and a friend to paint a rental house. She never showed up; no one was able to locate her all day. Her husband claimed he’d talked to Stacy, his fourth wife, around 9 p.m. when she told him she was leaving him and their four children for another man. No one, not any of Stacy’s friends or family, believed this claim.
The investigation into Stacy’s disappearance soon led police to reconsider the mysterious death of Drew’s third wife, Kathleen Savio, who had died under suspicious circumstances in a bathtub three years earlier. In part two of two, we discuss Stacy's disappearance and the renewed investigation into Kathleen's death.
Support us on Patreon.

The many wives of Drew Peterson - Part 1 Jan 29, 2024

Stacy Peterson, 23, was last seen on Sunday morning, October 28, 2007, in Bolingbrook, Illinois by her 53-year-old husband Drew Peterson. Drew, a police sergeant, was a 29-year veteran of the Bolingbrook Police Department. Stacy planned to meet her sister and a friend to paint a rental house. She never showed up; no one was able to locate her all day. Her husband claimed he’d talked to Stacy, his fourth wife, around 9 p.m. when she told him she was leaving him and their four children for another man. No one, not any of Stacy’s friends or family, believed this claim.
The investigation into Stacy’s disappearance soon led police to reconsider the mysterious death of Drew’s third wife, Kathleen Savio, who had died under suspicious circumstances in a bathtub three years earlier. In part one of two, we discuss Drew’s background, his four wives, and Kathleen’s untimely death in 2004.
Listen to parts 1 and 2 now, ad-free on Patreon.
Sources:

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 3 Jan 22, 2024

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In part three of this three-part episode, we talk about the investigation, the trial, the owl theory, and the aftermath.
Support us on Patreon
Todd Peterson video mentioned near the end of the episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2NI15RZN8wM

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 2 Jan 15, 2024

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In part two of this three-part episode, we talk about the crime scene and the autopsy results.
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 1 Jan 08, 2024

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in a bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In part one of this three-part episode, we talk about Michael's background, his first marriage, the death of Elizabeth Ratliff, and Kathleen's background.
Get access to parts 2 and 3 now on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Sources:

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 3 Jan 01, 2024

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ashore resulting in Scott’s arrest, trial, and eventual conviction. In the next three episodes, we attempt to reserve judgment and present evidence for and against Scott Peterson.
Support this podcast: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 2 Dec 25, 2023

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ashore resulting in Scott’s arrest, trial, and eventual conviction. In the next three episodes, we attempt to reserve judgment and present evidence for and against Scott Peterson.
Get early, ad-free access: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 1 Dec 18, 2023

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ashore resulting in Scott’s arrest, trial, and eventual conviction. In the next three episodes, we attempt to reserve judgment and present evidence for and against Scott Peterson.
Get early, ad-free access on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill

Deadly Love Triangle: Moriah Wilson, Colin Strickland and Kaitlin Armstrong Dec 11, 2023

Moriah “Mo” Wilson, 25, was the breakout star in the world of gravel cycling before she was brutally murdered in Austin, Texas on May 11, 2022. Colin Strickland, Mo’s former love interest, was the last person to see her alive but traffic cameras confirmed he was not near her at the time of her death. Suspicion quickly fell upon Colin’s long-suffering girlfriend, Kaitlin Armstrong, when a neighbor’s doorbell camera captured an image of her vehicle at the scene of the crime. Before Kaitlin could be charged, she fled the country and led US Marshals on an international chase.
Support us on Patreon.
Sources:

Jennifer and Fotis Dulos Dec 04, 2023

In the peaceful town of New Canaan, Connecticut, Jennifer Dulos dropped off her five kids at school on May 24th, 2019 just like any other day, but then she vanished without a trace. Investigators quickly turned their attention to Jennifer’s estranged husband, Fotis Dulos. Their messy divorce had been dragging on for almost two years, and Jennifer had said she was afraid of Fotis. But was he responsible for her disappearance? And if so, what happened, and where was she?
Support us on Patreon
Sources:

The Mysterious Death of Robert Wone Nov 27, 2023

On the night of August 2, 2006, Robert Wone, 32, an attorney in Washington D.C., worked late into the night. Rather than taking a train home to the suburbs, he crashed for the night with his college friend, Joseph Price. He was found dead one hour and 19 minutes later from three abdominal stab wounds. The inhabitants of the house claimed an intruder stabbed Robert but there was no evidence supporting this theory. I promise, you won’t be able to forget this story for days and weeks to come…this is the story of the mysterious murder of Robert Wone.
Support us on Patreon: https://patreon.com/lovemarrykill
Sources:

Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, and Dave Kroupa - Part 2 Nov 20, 2023

In the summer of 2012, Dave Kroupa of Omaha, Nebraska was getting back into the dating scene after the end of a long-term relationship. He was looking for something casual and fun, but instead he ended up being part of a deadly love triangle involving two women - Liz Golyar and Cari Farver. But who was the stalker and who was the victim? It would take investigators years to unravel the mystery in this story of love, jealousy and obsession.
Buy Love Marry Kill merch (offer ends 11/21/2023)
Support us on Patreon
Sources:

A Tangled Web, by Leslie Rule
Dateline season 26, episode 1, Scorned
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l55FRpIk30E
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ne-supreme-court/1962008.html
https://farverscholarship.org/
https://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/police-develop-ruse-liz-golyar-admit-killing-cari-74549312
https://www.perlego.com/book/3509844/the-cereal-killer-chronicles-of-battle-creek-pdf

Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, and Dave Kroupa - Part 1 Nov 13, 2023

In the summer of 2012, Dave Kroupa of Omaha, Nebraska was getting back into the dating scene after the end of a long-term relationship. He was looking for something casual and fun, but instead he ended up being part of a deadly love triangle involving two women - Liz Golyar and Cari Farver. But who was the stalker and who was the victim? It would take investigators years to unravel the mystery in this story of love, jealousy and obsession.
Buy Love Marry Kill merch (offer ends 11/21/2023)
Support us on Patreon
Sources:

A Tangled Web, by Leslie Rule
Dateline season 26, episode 1, Scorned
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l55FRpIk30E
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ne-supreme-court/1962008.html
https://farverscholarship.org/
https://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/police-develop-ruse-liz-golyar-admit-killing-cari-74549312
https://www.perlego.com/book/3509844/the-cereal-killer-chronicles-of-battle-creek-pdf

Judi Buenoano Nov 06, 2023

Born Anna Lou Welty in 1943, Judi Buenoano had many names and many lovers over her 54 years. Men in Judi’s life had a way of suffering a tragic fate when their affairs fizzled out; her husband, boyfriend, and even her son all died by her hand, which earned her the title “Black Widow”. A fourth man survived an attempt on his life which led to Judi’s ultimate demise and eventual execution in 1998.
Sources:

Recipe: https://www.eatingbirdfood.com/date-bark/#wprm-recipe-container-129659

Jennifer and Sarah Hart Oct 30, 2023

Jennifer and Sarah Hart, a same-sex, white couple living in Minnesota adopted 6 black and mixed-race children from Texas. That would be a challenge for most people, but Jen and Sarah made it look easy. Jen’s social media was full of beautiful pictures of their children in nature, political rallies, protests, and musical festivals. They seemed like the perfect modern family until reports of child abuse and neglect mounted and Child Protective Services (CPS) was called in 3 different states as the Harts moved to evade authorities. The tragic story ended on March 26, 2018, when Jen and Sarah decided to drive off a cliff in Northern California, forever affecting those who loved Markis, Hannah, Devonte, Jeremiah, Abigail, and Ciera so dearly.
Support this podcast.
Sources:

Erika and BJ Sifrit and the murders of Geney Crutchley and Joshua Ford - Part 2 Oct 23, 2023

Joshua Ford and his girlfriend Martha “Geney” Crutchley were looking forward to a Memorial Day 2002 weekend filled with sun and fun in the resort town of Ocean City, Maryland. Unfortunately for them a random encounter with another couple, BJ and Erika Sifrit, turned into a real-life horror movie. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation and subsequent trials.
Support the show: patreon.com/LoveMarryKill

Erika and BJ Sifrit and the murders of Geney Crutchley and Joshua Ford - Part 1 Oct 16, 2023

Joshua Ford and his girlfriend Martha “Geney” Crutchley were looking forward to a Memorial Day 2002 weekend filled with sun and fun in the resort town of Ocean City, Maryland. Unfortunately for them a random encounter with another couple, BJ and Erika Sifrit, turned into a real-life horror movie. In part one, we discuss the background of the victims and the killers, and the events of May 25th, 2002.
Also featured is the story of Kennedy Walton, a 26 year old woman from St. Louis who vanished in March of 2022 and has not been seen since.
Support the show: patreon.com/LoveMarryKill
Sources:

Crystal Rogers and Brooks Houck Oct 09, 2023

Crystal Rogers, mother to 5 children, disappeared on July 3, 2015, from the home she shared with her boyfriend, Brooks Houck, in Bardstown, Kentucky. When Brooks woke up on the morning of July 4, Crystal was gone and her car was missing. He wasn’t worried, he assumed she spent the night with a friend after they had a disagreement. Her family, however, were very worried and have been searching for her for over 8 years. Bardstown, Kentucky has had a series of baffling, unsolved murders over the past 10 years…could they all be linked?
Sources:

Bianca and Larry Rudolph Oct 02, 2023

Bianca Rudolph, 56, and her husband, Larry, 61, a successful dentist, were hunters, specifically big game hunters, traveling the world to add to their trophies. Bianca died in 2016, in Zambia, after she’d been on safari hoping to add a leopard to her collection. Larry said her fatal gunshot was accidentally self-inflicted, but a 5-year FBI investigation put that into question.
Sources:

Lynlee and Ben Renick - Part 2 Sep 25, 2023

In the world of snake breeding, Ben Renick was a rock star, known worldwide among the rare reptile and snake community. By 2017, Ben was 29 years old and had thousands of valuable snakes, including a 200 pound anaconda. On June 8th, 2017, Ben’s wife Lynlee came home to find him dead on the floor of his snake facility. Investigators initially thought a killer snake was on the loose. It was not a snake, but someone equally cold blooded who shot Ben eight times in the back.

Lynlee and Ben Renick - Part 1 Sep 18, 2023

In the world of snake breeding, Ben Renick was a rock star, known worldwide among the rare reptile and snake community. By 2017, Ben was 29 years old and had thousands of valuable snakes, including a 200 pound anaconda. On June 8th, 2017, Ben’s wife Lynlee came home to find him dead on the floor of his snake facility. Investigators initially thought a killer snake was on the loose. It was not a snake, but someone equally cold blooded who shot Ben eight times in the back.
Sources:

Peter Madsen and the Disappearance of Kim Wall Sep 11, 2023

Peter Madsen, 47, a self-proclaimed inventrapeneur independently built 3 submarines and a rocket. He was well known in his home country of Denmark for his inventions and eccentric personality. His first rocket launch was just days away when his entire life unraveled on August 10, 2017, after he invited award-winning freelance journalist Kim Wall, 30 aboard his submarine for an interview. Kim, a social justice warrior, traveled the world conducting her “shoe leather” style of journalism and was known for her intriguing and sometimes quirky style of journalism. She had pursued an interview with Madsen for months and jumped at the opportunity to come aboard his submarine. Only one of them returned.
Sources:

https://www.foxnews.com/world/who-is-peter-madsen-the-danish-inventor-charged-with-murdering-kim-wall
https://www.wired.com/story/final-terrible-voyage-nautilus/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRdb_NB7uG4
https://www.max.com/shows/undercurrent-the-disappearance-of-kim-wall/9e2b2ddb-6867-41b5-bb87-f807d26625ac
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9X93IA1ieVE
https://thecinemaholic.com/where-are-kim-walls-parents-now/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dOGDq2Yw5E
https://forums.digitalspy.com/discussion/2400522/the-investigation-bbc2-pace/p3
https://www.weekendavisen.dk/2018-19/samfund/kim-walls-kaereste-hun-var-levende
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-54018795
https://thecinemaholic.com/where-is-peter-madsens-ex-wife-jenny-curpen-now/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/12/my-friend-kim-wall-journalist
https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/peter-madsen-guilty-verdict-leaves-lingering-questions-and-pain
https://www.rememberingkimwall.com/tributes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJZPtMjmXsU
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/17/danish-law-to-outlaw-life-sentence-prisoners-starting-new-romances-peter-madsen
https://www.vice.com/en/article/5dpqgb/the-story-of-kim-walls-murder-but-not-as-you-know-it
https://www.wnyc.org/story/crumbling-leaking-radioactive-dome-pacific/
https://www.amazon.com/Silenced-Voice-Life-Journalist-Wall-ebook/dp/B07WG88JPQ/ref=sr_1_3?crid=1BB62U18U37OM&keywords=kim+wall+book&qid=1693872146&sprefix=kimball+book%2Caps%2C131&sr=8-3

Emily Noble and Matheau Moore Sep 04, 2023

People that knew Emily Noble well described her as kind and generous, always willing to help out a friend in need, even someone she didn’t know very well. After celebrating her 52nd birthday in May 2020 with her husband Matheau Moore, Emily went missing. It would be four months before her body was found hanging in the woods not far from Matt and Emily’s home. It looked like a suicide, but investigators concluded that Moore killed his wife and staged the scene. What would a jury think after hearing the evidence?
Sources:

The Vanished podcast: https://www.thevanishedpodcast.com/episodes/2020/9/21/episode-246-emily-noble
Moore speaks after the trial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k23MZafC6Vg
911 call: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NWTsrbnnNKw
Playlist with all trial videos: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoW1SIeAWaWa2n9cemn3-jBeLlq0uNHtw
Police interview of Moore: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EVLaD2G44M&list=PLoW1SIeAWaWa2n9cemn3-jBeLlq0uNHtw&index=11
Documentary - The Disappearance of Emily Noble: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rnqzgm-kuqM
Potentially Criminal - Livestream Q&A with Matheau Moore and juror #8: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oWr02QVZCM
Book by Matheau Moore: https://www.amazon.com/Emily-Staged-Suicide-Matheau-Moore-ebook/dp/B0BSVPMXY1
Emily’s Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/em.noble.33
Research report on hanging and thyroid cartilage: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/290290246_Fracture_of_the_thyroid_cartilage_and_incomplete_hanging_Case_report_and_review_of_the_literature
Autopsy report: https://www.nbc4i.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2021/06/Emily-Noble-Autopsy-Report.pdf
https://www.oxygen.com/crime-news/matheau-moore-found-not-guilty-of-murdering-wife-emily-noble
https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/local/2021/06/17/westerville-police-make-announcement-emily-noble-case/7727871002/
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/ohio/moore-juror-i-just-will-never-believe-he-killed-his-wife/530-00a14afd-a770-4a2f-aee6-15ae240788ec
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/crime/matheau-moore-trial-verdict-death-of-wife-emily-noble/530-3a4c074d-a2c4-4262-b433-9ce3f6394656
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/emily-nobles-husband-arrested-charged-with-her-murder/530-99d18dac-bfb2-4ac7-8464-015cbc075c28
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/matheau-moores-ex-wife-talks-about-death-of-emily-noble/530-a7711cb9-246b-44b8-aad0-08c84446af1c

Tina and Gabe Watson - Part 2 Aug 28, 2023

Tina and Gabe Watson, both 26, were married for just 11 days when she died in a tragic scuba diving incident while exploring the Great Barrier Reef in Queensland, Australia on October 22, 2003 on the couple's honeymoon. While Tina had recently taken up scuba diving, her husband was a trained rescue diver yet he wasn’t able to rescue her. Suspicion quickly landed on Gabe after it was learned he had asked Tina to change her life insurance policy to the maximum payout and change the beneficiary to him, prior to the wedding. Was this motive enough to murder his new wife? Listen to part two of this heartbreaking story that had two countries demanding justice for the new bride.

Tina and Gabe Watson - Part 1 Aug 21, 2023

Tina and Gabe Watson, both 26, were married for just 11 days when she died in a tragic scuba diving incident while exploring the Great Barrier Reef in Queensland, Australia on October 22, 2003 on the couple's honeymoon. While Tina had recently taken up scuba diving, her husband was a trained rescue diver yet he wasn’t able to rescue her. Suspicion quickly landed on Gabe after it was learned he had asked Tina to change her life insurance policy to the maximum payout and change the beneficiary to him, prior to the wedding. Was this motive enough to murder his new wife? Listen to this heartbreaking story that had two countries demanding justice for the new bride. Sources:

Kouri and Eric Richins Aug 14, 2023

On May 4, 2022, Eric Richins was found dead by his wife of 9 years, Kouri Richins. The young, successful couple were parents to three sons and owners of two businesses. Kouri released a children’s book about grief a year later called, “Are You With Me?” Weeks later she was arrested for poisoning her husband with a Moscow mule allegedly laced with fentanyl. The investigation into Eric’s death exposed years of financial crimes committed by Kouri against her husband. Is she guilty of killing her husband? Listen to this sad story of a dedicated and loving father taken too soon and tell us what you think. Sources:

Tara and Stephen Grant Aug 07, 2023

Tara Grant was a successful executive and mother of two young children when her husband, Stephen Grant, killed her in February of 2007 after she returned home to Michigan from a business trip. Stephen lied and said that Tara had left him after a fight. For the next two weeks, police searched for Tara while Stephen spoke constantly to the media, until finally a break in the case led to a shocking discovery and justice for Tara. Sources:

Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka (The Ken and Barbie killers) - Part 2 Jul 31, 2023

Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka, a Canadian couple, were dubbed the Ken and Barbie killers by the media because they were both attractive and blonde. They committed several horrifying crimes in the late 1980s and early 1990s, including the murder of Karla’s sister, Tammy. Their attractive and seemingly normal appearance masked their depravity as they engaged in a spree of kidnappings, sexual assaults, and murders, primarily targeting young women. The case gained significant media attention due to the brutality of their crimes, Karla's controversial plea deal, and the shocking revelation that she had been a willing participant in the heinous acts alongside her husband. The "Barbie killers" case remains one of Canada's most notorious and disturbing criminal sagas.

Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka (The Ken and Barbie killers) - Part 1 Jul 24, 2023

Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka, a Canadian couple, were dubbed the Ken and Barbie killers by the media because they were both attractive and blonde. They committed several horrifying crimes in the late 1980s and early 1990s, including the murder of Karla’s sister, Tammy. Their attractive and seemingly normal appearance masked their depravity as they engaged in a spree of kidnappings, sexual assaults, and murders, primarily targeting young women. The case gained significant media attention due to the brutality of their crimes, Karla's controversial plea deal, and the shocking revelation that she had been a willing participant in the heinous acts alongside her husband. The "Barbie killers" case remains one of Canada's most notorious and disturbing criminal sagas. Sources:

Erin and Jon Corwin - Part 2 Jul 17, 2023

Erin Corwin was just nineteen when she vanished on June 28, 2014. She had told her husband, Marine corporal Jon Corwin, that she was going to nearby Joshua Tree National Park that day for some “me time” and to scout out locations for her mom’s upcoming visit. Sadly, she never returned. In part two of this heartbreaking case, we discuss the investigation, the search for Erin, the trial and the aftermath.

Erin and Jon Corwin - Part 1 Jul 10, 2023

Erin Corwin was just nineteen when she vanished on June 28, 2014. She had told her husband, Marine corporal Jon Corwin, that she was going to nearby Joshua Tree National Park that day for some “me time” and to scout out locations for her mom’s upcoming visit. Sadly, she never returned. In part one of this two part episode, we describe the events leading up to Erin’s disappearance. Sources:

Suzanne and Barry Morphew Jul 03, 2023

Suzanne Morphew, 49, was a beautiful wife and mother who vanished without a trace on Mother’s Day 2020. Her husband, Barry, and two daughters were out of town, so Suzanne went on a bike ride. Her bike was later discovered down a rocky ravine, but no signs of Suzanne. On the surface, the Morphews had the perfect life, recently relocating to Colorado and living in their $1.5 million dream home. Soon however the investigation revealed many cracks in the Morphew’s marriage and investigators homed in on Barry Morphew, realizing he was not the perfect husband he claimed to be. Sources:

Diane and Tex McIver Jun 26, 2023

Diane McIver, a vibrant, accomplished, and wealthy woman of 63, was shot and killed in 2016 in Atlanta, Georgia. There is no mystery about how Diane died - the gun was held by her 73 year old husband Tex McIver. The only question is whether Tex pulled the trigger intentionally to solve his money troubles, or whether it was just a tragic accident. Listen today and let us know what you think! Sources:

Ellen Greenberg Jun 23, 2023

Ellen Greenberg, 27, was a beautiful, newly engaged first grade teacher who died on January 26, 2011 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Her death was initially ruled a homicide but changed to suicide weeks later. The investigation was botched by police and evidence was likely destroyed. Evidence supports Ellen’s death being both a homicide and a suicide but her family is sure she did not commit suicide. Listen to this baffling case today, on what would be Ellen’s 40th birthday, and decide for yourself. Please sign the petition to get Ellen’s case a new ruling so the investigation can be reopened: https://www.change.org/p/justice-for-ellen-rae-greenberg-justiceforellen?redirect=false Sources:

Nancy and Dan Brophy Jun 19, 2023

Portland, Oregon chef instructor Dan Brophy was found murdered on June 2, 2018 at the Oregon Culinary Institute by his students. Who would kill this kind 63 year old man who was well-loved and helped so many? His beloved wife and romance writer Nancy Brophy had written an essay called, “How to Murder Your Husband” years earlier…was that foreshadowing or an unfortunate coincidence?

Randi and Brian Trimble Jun 12, 2023

Newlywed Randi Trimble was brutally stabbed 27 times in her garage by a man who lurked in the shadows wearing all black. Her husband had a solid alibi. Who was this man that would kill such a kind, beautiful young woman with a promising future? Little did Randi know that her seemingly loving husband, Brian Trimble, and his friend, Blaine Norris, had been plotting her death for months to collect her life insurance to fund their horror film, “Through Hike: A Ghost Story." Listen now to this real life horror story of narcissism, greed, and ambition. Sources:

Brenda Schaefer and Mel Ignatow - Part 2 Jun 05, 2023

Brenda Schaefer, a beautiful 36 year old from Louisville Kentucky, went missing in September of 1988. Her car was found abandoned and vandalized early on a Sunday morning, but Brenda was nowhere to be found. Mel Ignatow, Brenda’s one-time fiancé, was an immediate suspect, but there was no direct evidence implicating him and no body. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss Mel's trial and the aftermath. Sources:

Double Jeopardy, book by Bob Hill from 1995
Dark Heart, Iron Hand - Getting Away With Murder, MSNBC 2011
https://www.wave3.com/story/8932145/ignatows-son-reacts-to-his-fathers-death/

Special Report: Artificial Intelligence and Crime Jun 01, 2023

Artificial Intelligence is advancing at an amazing rate. In this special bonus episode, we take a step back from our usual true crime stories to discuss AI as it relates to the world of crime. How is AI helping law enforcement? How is it helping criminals? What new forms of crime are we likely to see enabled by AI? And what is the existential threat posed by AI to humanity and what efforts are underway to avoid catastrophe? Sources:

Brenda Schaefer and Mel Ignatow - Part 1 May 29, 2023

Brenda Schaefer, a beautiful 36 year old from Louisville Kentucky, went missing in September of 1988. Her car was found abandoned and vandalized early on a Sunday morning, but Brenda was nowhere to be found. Mel Ignatow, Brenda’s one-time fiancé, was an immediate suspect, but there was no direct evidence implicating him and no body. In part one of this two-part episode, we discuss Brenda’s background, Brenda and Mel’s relationship, and the investigation into her disappearance. Sources:

Double Jeopardy, book by Bob Hill from 1995
Dark Heart, Iron Hand - Getting Away With Murder, MSNBC 2011
https://www.wave3.com/story/8932145/ignatows-son-reacts-to-his-fathers-death/

Susan and Felix Polk - Part 2 May 22, 2023

In part two of this two part episode, Tina tells the story of Susan Bolling and Felix Polk, who first met when she was 15 and he was 39. In this episode we talk about what led to Felix’s murder and the crazy trial where Susan defended herself. Will Susan be able to convince the jury the murder was self defense? We also discuss the murder of Pamela Vitale and the connection to Ed Gein.

Susan and Felix Polk - Part 1 May 15, 2023

In part one of this two part episode, Tina tells the story of Susan Bolling and Felix Polk, who first met when she was 15 and he was 39. Felix was Susan’s psychotherapist who took advantage of his position and began an inappropriate sexual relationship with her. They later married and had 3 sons together before Felix was murdered by Susan in 2002. Was it self defense or cold blooded murder? Listen to this disturbing tale of psychotherapy gone wrong and intense grooming. We also discuss the satanic panic of the 1980’s and the McMartin Preschool Scandal. Sources:

Honey and Barry Sherman - Part 2 May 08, 2023

Barry and Honey Sherman, a wealthy and philanthropic couple, were killed in December of 2017 at their home in Toronto. The circumstances of their death were bizarre and mysterious. Barry and Honey were loved by a lot of people, but they also had enemies who hated them both. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the suspects, possible motives, and the legacy of Barry and Honey Sherman.

The Week in Crime May 05, 2023

In this bonus episode, we summarize several cases in the news, including the killing of six people in Oklahoma by convicted sex offender Jesse McFadden, the murder of Dr. Devon Hoover in Detroit, and the parole hearing of Leo Schofield.

Honey and Barry Sherman - Part 1 May 01, 2023

Barry and Honey Sherman, an incredibly wealthy and philanthropic couple, were killed in December of 2017 at their home in Toronto. The circumstances of their death were bizarre and mysterious. Barry and Honey were loved by a lot of people, but they also had enemies who hated them both. In part one of this two-part episode, we share Barry’s and Honey’s background, the crime scene, and the beginnings of the investigation.

Lizzie Borden Apr 24, 2023

This week we go back in time to 1892 in Fall River Massachusetts and try to solve the most famous unsolved crime in American history, the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden. Did Lizzie Borden kill her parents in cold blood to gain access to the family fortune or was she an innocent Sunday school teacher and the real murderer evaded capture? You might think you know the whole story but we dive deep into this mystery and uncover some interesting facts and theories.

Angela and James Craig Apr 17, 2023

In this week's episode, Tina tells the story of Angela and James Craig. Angela Pray Craig, 43, was an active, vibrant wife and mother to six children in Aurora, Colorado. Her husband, James, was a dentist with a busy practice. In March 2023, Angela was hospitalized 3 times. Doctors didn’t know what was causing her severe headaches, low blood pressure and disorientation. James had previously drugged Angela but insisted that he had not drugged her this time. Aa Angela’s health rapidly declined, an employee of the dental practice opened a package that had been delivered to the office containing potassium cyanide. Did James poison his devoted wife, causing her untimely death? We also discuss the latest news in the Shanquella Robinson case.

Nancy and Frank Howard Apr 11, 2023

With her husband Frank out of town on business, 53 year old Nancy Howard was arriving home after picking up some takeout when she was accosted in her garage. The assailant took Nancy’s purse and shot her in the head. Was it a burglary gone wrong, or something more? Tune in for one of our craziest stories yet as we unravel the tale of Nancy and Frank Howard.

Patricia Kimmi Apr 03, 2023

Pat Kimmi was a beloved mother of 4 and grandmother to 12 who went missing in November, 2009. She had recently divorced her abusive husband after 38 years of marriage. Her disappearance devastated her family and community who searched for her for weeks. They found clues along way, but it would take months for her body to be found. Who could have murdered this sweet lady? Was her husband involved? The answer might surprise you.

April and Rick Roehl Apr 01, 2023

Rick Roehl and his wife April seemed to have it all - money, a perfect family, and a beautiful home. Rick was handsome and charming, while people said that April would light up a room. When April vanished without a trace, Rick claimed he would never hurt her, and that he would never give up trying to find her. Police were not fooled however. Tune in for our most shocking and tragic episode so far!

Elisa and Larry McNabney - Part 2 Mar 27, 2023

Larry McNabney was a successful, well-known lawyer, who seemingly vanished from the face of the earth on September 11th, 2001. Rumors began to swirl about Larry's wife Elisa and her young assistant Sarah Dutra, but it would take months for the mystery of Larry's disappearance to unravel. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation into Larry's whereabouts and reveal what really happened to Larry McNabney.

Elisa and Larry McNabney - Part 1 Mar 20, 2023

Larry McNabney was a successful, well-known lawyer, who seemingly vanished from the face of the earth on September 11th, 2001. Rumors began to swirl about Larry's wife Elisa and her young assistant Sarah Dutra, but it would take months for the mystery of Larry's disappearance to unravel. In part one of this two-part episode, we discuss Larry's background and the circumstances around his disappearance.

Shanquella Robinson Mar 13, 2023

Shanquella Robinson, 25, went to Cabo, Mexico with friends for a luxurious getaway in October, 2022. She did not survive the weekend. There were conflicting reports about what caused her death but a shocking cell phone video revealed that Shanquella suffered a brutal beating by one of the women she considered a friend. Shanquella’s friends and family are still waiting for justice to be served. This story will leave you shocked and heartbroken. #justiceforshanquellarobinson

Recent Cases in the News - Abby Choi and Constance Marten Mar 08, 2023

In this bonus episode, we cover two cases in the news. First, the recent death of Abby Choi, a 28 year old socialite and influencer who was killed and dismembered by her ex-husband and in-laws in a devastating instance of greed. Second, we discuss wealthy aristocrat Constance Marten and her boyfriend Mark Gordon, whose disappearance along with their newborn baby in early January sparked a massive search in the UK.

John Miles Sharpe (The Mornington Monster) Mar 06, 2023

John Miles Sharpe of Mornington, Australia brutally murdered his pregnant wife and 15 month old daughter in 2004 using a speargun. He disposed of their bodies and lied to police about their whereabouts for months. How long did his lies hold up and how was he caught? Listen today to find out about the horrible murders of The Mornington Monster.

Alex Murdaugh Mar 05, 2023

In this bonus episode we discuss our feelings on the Murdaugh trial and the many victims of Alex, and we answer some listener questions about the case. Many thanks to listeners who sent in questions!

John List - Part 2 Feb 27, 2023

In this episode we discuss a true crime classic, John Emil List. On November 9, 1971, John List murdered his wife, three children and his mother before he disappeared without a trace. He became one of the FBI’s most wanted men, evading capture for 18 years. In part 2/2, we talk about how John List became Bob Clark. He was able to change his name but not his quirky personality, which ultimately led to his capture. We also go down a D.B. Cooper rabbit hole and revel in some amazing detective work.

John List - Part 1 Feb 20, 2023

In this episode we discuss a true crime classic, John Emil List. On November 9, 1971, John List murdered his wife, three children and his mother before he disappeared without a trace. He became one of the FBI’s most wanted men and evaded capture for 18 years. In part one of this two-part episode, we talk about John’s upbringing in Michigan, the early years of his married life and how things began to fall apart after the Lists purchased the mansion known as Breeze Knoll in Westfield, New Jersey.

Susan and John Hamilton Feb 13, 2023

Valentine’s Day is traditionally a day for flowers, candy, and romance. But sadly for Susan Hamilton, Valentine’s Day of 2001 would be the day she was savagely beaten and killed. Her husband, Dr. John Hamilton, came back to their Oklahoma City home after performing two surgeries that morning to find her lying on the floor of the bathroom with blood everywhere. Who would have killed Susan, and why?

Shele and Rod Covlin - Part 2 Feb 06, 2023

As 2009 drew to a close, 47 year old Shele Covlin had a lot going for her. Her career was going well, she had two beautiful kids, and a family that loved her. Sadly, Shele did not live to see the New Year. Was her death a tragic accident or did her estranged husband Rod kill her? In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation into Shele's death, and Rod's appalling schemes to get at her money.

Debbie Collier Feb 02, 2023

Debbie Collier was a 59 year old beloved mother who died under mysterious circumstances in September, 2022. Her last communication was a cryptic Venmo message to her daughter, Amanda, which led to much suspicion, speculation and confusion about her death. In this bonus episode, we discuss the circumstances around Debbie's mysterious death and whether it was suicide or foul play.

Shele and Rod Covlin - Part 1 Jan 30, 2023

As 2009 drew to a close, 47 year old Shele Covlin had a lot going for her. Her career was going well, she had two beautiful kids, and a family that loved her. Sadly, Shele did not live to see the New Year. Was her death a tragic accident or did her estranged husband Rod kill her? In part one of this two-part episode, we discuss Shele and Rod’s background and the circumstances surrounding her death.

Kelly and Jason Cochran, and the Murder of Chris Regan - Part 2 Jan 23, 2023

In October 2014, Chris Regan was looking forward to a fresh start with a move from northern Michigan to Asheville, North Carolina, but then he disappeared without a trace. Evidence led police to married couple Jason and Kelly Cochran, but they couldn't piece together exactly what happened. Did Jason kill Chris out of jealousy, or was Kelly the mastermind? In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the "marriage pact" between Kelly and Jason, the possible motives, and the aftermath.

Ana and Brian Walshe Update Jan 19, 2023

[Note: If you haven’t listened to our earlier episode on this case, start there!] In today’s bonus episode we talk about the arraignment hearing for Brian Walshe and the affidavit from the prosecutor. We discuss the new evidence found as well as Brian’s damning google searches. Follow us on social media for any breaking news. Thanks for you support.

Kelly and Jason Cochran, and the Murder of Chris Regan - Part 1 Jan 16, 2023

In October 2014, Chris Regan was looking forward to a fresh start with a move from northern Michigan to Asheville, North Carolina, but then he disappeared without a trace. Evidence led police to married couple Jason and Kelly Cochran, but they couldn't piece together exactly what happened. Did Jason kill Chris out of jealousy, or was Kelly the mastermind? In part one of this two-part episode, we explore Chris's disappearance and the search for clues.

Ana and Brian Walshe Jan 12, 2023

Ana Walshe, a smart, successful and beautiful mother of three young boys, was last seen in the early hours of January 1, 2023. Her husband claims she left for for a work trip to DC but there are no records of her on a flight. Brian, a rather shady person, was arrested on 1/8/2023 for misleading police in their investigation. Blood and a knife were found in his basement as well as other possibly related items at a nearby dump. We hope Ana is found safely soon.

Shanann and Chris Watts - Part 2 Jan 09, 2023

In part two of the Chris and Shanann Watts case, we discuss the brutal murders, the possible motivation and the shocking events that led up to the arrest and imprisonment of Chris Watts. Warning: This episode includes content that may be disturbing for young and/or sensitive listeners.

Shanann and Chris Watts - Part 1 Jan 02, 2023

Chris and Shanann Watts were married for six years with two adorable daughters, Bella and CeCe, and a son on the way. In part one of this devastating story we talk about the early years of the Watts marriage and what could have led to the tragic events that unfolded on August 13, 2008.

Rebecca Zahau - Part 2 Dec 26, 2022

In 2011, Rebecca Zahau was found dead at her boyfriend's mansion in Coronado, California. In part two of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina discuss the various theories surrounding her mysterious death. Was it a suicide, or was someone out for revenge?

Bruce Pardo and the Covina Massacre Dec 23, 2022

On Christmas Eve 2008, “Santa” came to Covina, California and unleashed a fury upon the Ortega family, killing 9 of their beloved family members. In this bonus episode we talk about Bruce Pardo and his horrible crime that left a beautiful family shattered.

Rebecca Zahau - Part 1 Dec 19, 2022

In 2011, Rebecca Zahau was found dead at her boyfriend's mansion in Coronado, California. In part one of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina explore the baffling circumstances around Rebecca's death, and the tragic accident that preceded it just two days earlier. Was her death a suicide, or was someone out for revenge?

The Sodder Children Dec 15, 2022

On Christmas Eve, 1945, the Sodder family of Fayetteville, West Virginia experienced a tragedy that would haunt them for years to come. After a mysterious fire destroyed their home, five of the ten Sodder children were nowhere to be found. Did they perish in the fire, or were they kidnapped?

Judi and Brian Eftenoff Dec 12, 2022

Brian and Judi Eftenoff were an attractive couple who lived life in the fast lane. They seemed to have it all until Judi’s life abruptly ended by a cocaine overdose in September, 1999. Brian was not known to be the best guy but is it possible he murdered his beautiful wife, Judi, by forcing cocaine down her throat?

Sarah and Ryan Widmer - Part 2 Dec 05, 2022

Did 24 year old Sarah Widmer die after falling asleep in the bathtub or did her husband, Ryan, murder her and stage the scene? In part two of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina discuss the aftermath of Ryan's trial and theories about Sarah's mysterious death.

Sarah and Ryan Widmer - Part 1 Nov 28, 2022

Did 24 year old Sarah Widmer die after falling asleep in the bathtub or did her husband, Ryan, murder her and stage the scene? Listen to part one of this baffling, intriguing case today.

The Skelton Brothers Nov 23, 2022

Brothers Andrew, Alexander and Tanner Skelton were last seen on Thanksgiving Day, November 25, 2010, and then they vanished without a trace. Did their father kill them or did he relocate them with an underground community to keep them away from their mother? Wishing our listeners a very Happy Thanksgiving!

Jane and Bob Bashara - Part 2 Nov 21, 2022

When Jane Bashara turned up dead in 2012, everyone assumed it was random Detroit violence. However, her husband Bob's secret BDSM lifestyle soon came to light, casting suspicion on him. In part two of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina discuss the investigation into Jane's murder, the media frenzy and the circus of a trial.

Jane and Bob Bashara - Part 1 Nov 14, 2022

When Jane Bashara turned up dead in 2012, everyone assumed it was random Detroit violence. However, her husband Bob's secret BDSM lifestyle soon came to light, casting suspicion on him. In part one of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina discuss the crime, Bob Bashara's secret life, and the plot to kill Jane.

Frances and Tony Toto Nov 10, 2022

In this bonus mini-episode, Tina and Rich talk about the case of Frances and Tony Toto. Frances attempted to kill Tony in five different ways…was she successful? The movie starring Kevin Kline and Tracey Ullman “I Love You to Death” is based on the Toto’s story.

George Joseph Smith - The Bathtub Murders Nov 07, 2022

This week, Tina and Rich go back in time and across the pond to discuss the case of George Joseph Smith and The Bathtub Murders. George was a conman, bigamist and murderer. We also talk about Bernard Spillsbury, known as the father of forensic science, and the challenges of police investigations before the invention of modern techniques.

Chanin and Clay Starbuck - Part 2 Oct 31, 2022

When Chanin Starbuck was found brutally murdered in December of 2011 in Deer Park, Washington, suspicion quickly turned to her ex-husband Clay. But Chanin also had an active online dating life, with mystery men texting and even visiting her house the day she was killed. In part two of this two-part episode, Rich and Tina talk about the DNA evidence, the discovery of an important 911 call, the trial, and the aftermath.

Chanin and Clay Starbuck - Part 1 Oct 24, 2022

When Chanin Starbuck was found brutally murdered in December of 2011 in Deer Park, Washington, suspicion quickly turned to her ex-husband Clay. But Chanin also had an active online dating life, with mystery men texting and even visiting her house the day she was killed. In part one of this two-parter, Rich and Tina talk about the crime, the suspects, and take a deep-dive into Clay and Chanin's relationship.

Jeffrey and Colette MacDonald - Part 2 Oct 17, 2022

Jeffrey MacDonald was accused of killing his pregnant wife Colette and two young daughters in 1970 but claims they were actually killed by a band of hippies inspired by the Manson family murders. The best selling book and blockbuster film "Fatal Vision" are based on the MacDonald murders. In part two of this two-part episode, Tina and Rich discuss Jeffrey's life after the murders, the many trials and appeals, and Freddy Kassab's change of heart.

Jeffrey and Colette MacDonald - Part 1 Oct 10, 2022

Jeffrey MacDonald was accused of killing his pregnant wife Colette and two young daughters in 1970 but claims they were actually killed by a band of hippies inspired by the Manson family murders. The best selling book and blockbuster film “Fatal Vision” are based on the MacDonald murders. In part one of this two-part episode, Tina and Rich discuss Jeffrey and Colette's background, the crime, and the evidence.

Barbara and Russell Stager Oct 01, 2022

In their inaugural episode, Tina and Rich discuss marriage, working together, and the case of Barbara and Russell Stager. In 1988, Russell was shot and killed in Durham, North Carolina. His wife Barbara claimed that Russ kept a gun under his pillow for safety and what resulted was a tragic accident, but Barbara's past soon caught up with her.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected