Show notes
The College Football Playoff committee delivered a major surprise, and Iowa fans are not happy. Emery Songer, Andrew Downs, and Trent Condon break down the latest CFP rankings, question the logic behind Ohio State and Oregon jumping Iowa, and debate whether the committee's evaluation system is fundamentally flawed.
Why does Ohio State get credit for scheduling and losing to Texas? Why aren't Oregon's losses to Illinois and Oklahoma State hurting the Ducks more? And how can teams with worse records in the same conference be ranked ahead of Iowa? The guys dig into the committee's mysterious pod system, the lack of transparency around its decisions, and the growing influence of conference and brand reputation.
The conversation also looks beyond Iowa at the SEC's representation in the rankings, the Big 12 playoff picture, and what a 24-team playoff could mean for the sport. With Iowa still having a path, the guys discuss the results that could help the Hawkeyes, including Nebraska's matchup with Ohio State and other key games around the country.
Plus, the crew makes its Week 12 picks, including Iowa at Illinois, Iowa State at UCF, Ohio State at Nebraska, Michigan at Maryland, Texas Tech at Baylor, Miami against Virginia Tech, and Utah at TCU.
Presented by Bud Light.
00:00:00 Show Open
00:03:05 The CFP Committee's Latest Rankings Spark Outrage
00:06:33 Iowa Should Have Been Ranked Higher
00:08:13 The Committee's Pod System and Its Flaws
00:10:05 Is Conference Reputation Hurting College Football?
00:11:50 Ohio State, Oregon and the Committee's Double Standards
00:14:20 Oregon's Bad Losses and Iowa's Résumé
00:15:08 Why the CFP Committee Needs to Explain Its Formula
00:16:29 Would an Iowa Win Over Minnesota Have Changed Anything?
00:18:02 Is Iowa Being Penalized for Its Playing Style?
00:23:00 The Big 12's Playoff Hopes and Conference Chaos
00:28:00 Conference Realignment and the Future of College Football
00:32:00 What Iowa Needs to Happen Over the Final Two Weeks
00:40:00 Why a 24-Team Playoff Could Be Better for the Sport
00:43:00 Week 12 Games and Predictions
00:45:00 Iowa State at UCF: Can the Cyclones Get Bowl Eligible?
00:48:00 Nebraska vs. Ohio State: Hawkeye Fans Need a Favor
00:51:00 Iowa at Illinois: Can the Hawkeyes Keep Winning?
00:54:00 Ohio State at Nebraska and the Big Ten Race
00:57:00 Michigan's Coaching Situation and the Maryland Matchup
01:01:00 Texas Tech at Baylor and the Big 12 Race
01:04:00 Miami vs. Virginia Tech: Could the Hokies Pull an Upset?
01:06:24 Utah at TCU: A Potential Big 12 Trap Game
01:09:05 Iowa Wild Wild Card Games of the Week
01:09:50 Pucks and Paws: Dogs at the Iowa Wild Game
01:14:03 Could Michigan State Help Iowa's Playoff Hopes?
01:15:28 Virginia Tech at Miami: Another Potential Upset
01:18:37 Indiana at Washington: A Big Ten Game to Watch
01:19:37 Closing Thoughts
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices