TopPodcast.com
Menu
  • Home
  • Top Charts
  • Top Networks
  • Top Apps
  • Top Independents
  • Top Podfluencers
  • Top Picks
    • Top Business Podcasts
    • Top True Crime Podcasts
    • Top Finance Podcasts
    • Top Comedy Podcasts
    • Top Music Podcasts
    • Top Womens Podcasts
    • Top Kids Podcasts
    • Top Sports Podcasts
    • Top News Podcasts
    • Top Tech Podcasts
    • Top Crypto Podcasts
    • Top Entrepreneurial Podcasts
    • Top Fantasy Sports Podcasts
    • Top Political Podcasts
    • Top Science Podcasts
    • Top Self Help Podcasts
    • Top Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Top Stocks Podcasts
  • Podcast News
  • About Us
  • Podcast Advertising
  • Contact
Not in our directory?
Add Show Here
Podcast Equipment
Center

toppodcastlogoOur TOPPODCAST Picks

  • Comedy
  • Crypto
  • Sports
  • News
  • Politics
  • True Crime
  • Business
  • Finance

Follow Us

toppodcastlogoStay Connected

    View Top 200 Chart
    Back to Rankings Page
    Christianity

    Gospel Tangents Podcast

    A 360-degree view of Mormonism. We interview the best Mormon scholars, scientists, and clergy from all restoration branches, including LDS, Community of Christ, Strangites, Bickertonites, Temple Lot, Remnant, etc.

    Advertise

    Copyright: © 2019 Gospel Tangents - All Rights Reserved

    • Apple Podcasts
    • Google Play
    • Spotify

    Latest Episodes:
    How Patriarchal Blessing Led Her to Helen Mar Kimball (Michelle Stone 3 of 7) Nov 14, 2026
    Show notes

    Road to Helen Mar Kimball

    Michelle Stone was supposed to be writing about Sarah Ann Whitney when she stumbled onto the patriarchal blessing of Helen Mar Kimball. Every time she sat down to work on Sarah Ann, she says, she felt something like a stupor of thought, and she took it as a sign to stop. So she went back to Sarah Ann’s blessing, written on unusual pink-bordered paper.

    The only other known document on that kind of paper is a poem Helen wrote to her mother, and that trail led Michelle to Helen’s own patriarchal blessing, dated May 28, 1843. That’s the month usually given for Helen’s marriage to Joseph Smith, yet Michelle says the blessing makes it “abundantly clear” that Helen was not married and had no plans to be. The blessing is in William Clayton’s handwriting and recorded in his journal, and Michelle calls it the earliest document we have for Helen. She wondered why it hadn’t been used, noting that Brian Hales’s collection of the sources leaves it out.

    https://youtu.be/i7VIxlE_NhQ

    Road to School

    Getting to that paper took a long road. Michelle had a full presidential scholarship at BYU and left in her final year to have her first baby, who is now 28. After some very hard years, and after taking her 132 Problems channel down, she felt she was supposed to go back to school. BYU’s options for returning students didn’t work out, so her husband suggested Utah Valley University. She called on the last day to enroll and was told there were no advising appointments for two weeks. Then, while she was still on the phone, someone canceled a 2:00 appointment.

    She met with an advisor, enrolled, and started class the next day. UVU accepted her credits (except religion), she needed only 30 to graduate, and she spent a full senior year in history. She graduated with a 4.0, summa cum laude, and between a scholarship and a grant she paid no tuition. Her advice to returning students: “Go to UVU, not BYU.”

    Why Pick Polygamy?

    Going back was terrifying and thrilling. Academic writing took some adjustment after podcasting, where she liked to build to a big reveal. But compared with the endless laundry, dishes and cooking of a big family, school felt like Christmas. Michelle is candid that as an overwhelmed young mom she used to pray for a housekeeper and think, “This is why we need polygamy.” Now she sees it differently: another wife brings more needs and more children, and “another woman does not need to be my servant.” Picture a 20-year-old moving into a 30-year-old woman’s home to care for her seven children, she says. “That’s horrible and unfair, right? And that’s what polygamy is.”

    Award Winning Article: Constructing Helen

    Her senior thesis, a historiography of how Helen’s story has been told, ran more than twice the 35 pages required and won the Lucille T. Stoddard Senior Thesis Award. It was later published in the Journal of Mormon Polygamy as “Constructing Helen: Absences, Ambiguities, & Adjustments.” To critics who dismissed it as just an undergraduate award, Michelle points to the Phi Alpha Theta regional conference at Weber State, where she presented a different paper and UVU won both the undergraduate and the overall best paper awards.

    In Part 4, coming Tuesday, Michelle explains what a historiography is, answers people who say she has an agenda, and I break some news about where she’s starting her PhD. Members can get the whole interview right now at patreon.com/gospeltangents. Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/
    Copyright © 2026
    Gospel Tangents
    All Rights Reserved

    Chapters

    0:00 Going Back to School
    1:16 Why She Took Her Channel Down
    4:12 Trying BYU Again
    6:13 “Why Don’t You Call UVU?”
    10:08 “Why Can’t I Have a Housekeeper?”
    11:40 4.0, Summa Cum Laude & a Full Scholarship
    13:50 Lucille T. Stoddard Award
    15:31 UVU at Phi Alpha Theta
    18:33 “Constructing Helen”
    19:58 Sarah Ann Whitney’s Pink-Bordered Blessing
    20:19 Helen’s May 1843 Patriarchal Blessing
    21:19 Can You Trust William Clayton?


    Surprising Emma Smith Polygamy Puzzle (Michelle Stone 2 of 7) Nov 12, 2026
    Show notes

    Emma Smith Polygamy Puzzle

    Michelle Stone didn’t expect one episode about Emma Smith to change her mind, but her deep dive into the Emma Smith polygamy sources did exactly that. In Part 1, Michelle explained how the Book of Mormon convinced her that polygamy was not God’s higher law. Her 132 Problems channel began there, with the scriptures. But scripture questions lead to history questions: what was happening when a revelation was given, and how reliable is the William Clayton affidavit? (Michelle and Cheryl Bruno wrote a paper on that affidavit for the Journal of Mormon Polygamy.) Then Michelle decided to do an episode on Emma.

    https://youtu.be/xR_xqMgUEN4

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Mormon Enigma

    She studied Emma the way she studies everything, sometimes 60 hours a week. She started with Mormon Enigma and Jennifer Reeder’s biography First, then read everything else she could find, including RLDS sources. Her conclusion: “Emma does not make sense.” Everyone who knew Emma praised her honesty and integrity, Michelle says, and yet once Emma denied that Joseph practiced polygamy, she became “the biggest liar in Mormonism.” Michelle doesn’t accept the usual explanations, that Emma was protecting her sons or the RLDS Church, without a source to back them up.

    Her connection to Emma is also personal. Michelle, a mother of 13, lost two children in a row during very hard years in 2020 and 2021. She remembers standing at the sink with one thought: “Emma made it. I can too.” Emma lost her first son, twins, an adopted twin, little Don Carlos and a stillborn son, and Michelle believes her own losses gave her some insight into Emma’s life. She already had a daughter named for Emma. “I don’t care that much about Joseph Smith,” she told me. “I care a lot about Emma Smith.” That’s why she plans to write her dissertation on Emma, though she adds that the more she studies, the more Joseph has risen in her estimation too.

    132 Problems/Death Threats

    Saying all this out loud came at a cost. Many former members had supported her channel while she argued that polygamy wasn’t of God. When she said she didn’t believe Joseph Smith practiced polygamy, Michelle says, that support disappeared immediately and “brought the haters out.” Some fundamentalists made sure she knew they still believed in blood atonement, and she went through a long stretch of death threats. Others, she says, have had revelations that she will be their wife. She is quick to add that many of the fundamentalists she knows are lovely people.

    The channel kept growing anyway. Michelle started it in February 2022, sure no one would watch, and found out she wasn’t the only polygamy geek. She calls section 132 “horrific” and says it’s time for it to leave our scriptures. She points to President Spencer W. Kimball ending the priesthood ban, influenced in part by Lester Bush’s article, as a model for how a church can change course. And she asks why we still tell the story of an angel with a sword threatening Joseph if he didn’t take teenage plural wives. When I asked whether that story is in the historical record, Michelle said it all comes down to the sources. She began by asking people to at least consider that Emma might be telling the truth. Now she wonders how the traditional account ever passed for settled history. “The field is white, ready to harvest,” she says.

    In Part 3, Michelle talks about the hard years that took her back to school at Utah Valley University, and the patriarchal blessing that led her from Sarah Ann Whitney to Helen Mar Kimball. Members can get the whole interview right now at patreon.com/gospeltangents. Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    Chapters

    0:00 Introduction
    1:12 From Scripture to Joseph Smith’s History
    2:04 Death Threats & Blood Atonement
    4:17 Researching Emma Smith/”Emma Does Not Make Sense”
    6:53 Support for the Channel Disappears
    8:11 It Was Emma, Not Joseph
    9:05 “Emma Made It. I Can Too.”
    11:45 “The Biggest Liar in Mormonism”?
    14:05 Growing the 132 Problems Channel
    16:39 Lester Bush & the Priesthood Ban
    17:15 An Angel with a Sword?
    17:48 Isn’t It in the Historical Record?

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved


    Forgotten Book of Mormon Polygamy Warnings (Michelle Stone 1 of 7) Nov 09, 2026
    Show notes

    Book of Mormon Polygamy?

    When Michelle Stone finally studied the Book of Mormon polygamy passages for herself, she was shocked by what she found. Michelle grew up believing plural marriage was God’s higher law, and now she calls the Book of Mormon “by far, far and away, the most anti-polygamy book of scriptures in the entire canon.” She is back on Gospel Tangents, three years after she first joined me to talk about her mother’s cousin, Mark Hofmann, and this time we start with her own story.

    https://youtu.be/ZXqZ2mNuj5Y

    Don’t miss our other conversations on the Hofmann murders & forgeries: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Righteous Polygamy?

    Michelle was raised to believe that Zion would be built when the Saints were righteous enough to live polygamy and the United Order. She even taught those ideas in homeschooling circles. Polygamy ran in her family: she says Joseph F. Smith called her great-grandfather to Mexico to take a second wife, and he married her in 1906, well after the 1890 Manifesto. As a young mom selling her mother’s music, Michelle found herself in the homes of fundamentalist families. Women from the Apostolic United Brethren explained to her that the principle and the church were like a mother and a father, separated for now but destined to come back together. With her family history, she says, that made perfect sense.

    Then she started reading the scriptures on her own. Michelle points to Jacob’s condemnation of David and Solomon, King Noah and his “many wives and concubines,” and Riplakish in the Book of Ether, and says the Book of Mormon “leaves no wiggle room.” She also notes that section 132, the one place in Latter-day Saint scripture that promotes polygamy, wasn’t added to the Doctrine and Covenants until 1876. That study became the heart of her Facebook group and, later, her 132 Problems channel.

    Fundamentalist Enemy?

    I asked whether this was a reaction against fundamentalism. Michelle says no: she simply wanted to know what was true. Still, some fundamentalists now see her as an enemy, which she finds sad, because she doesn’t see them that way. We compared her view with the old RLDS position that Joseph didn’t practice polygamy, but would have been wrong if he had, and with the Ericksons, who studied the same scriptures and reached the opposite conclusion.

    Michelle credits fundamentalists themselves for sharpening her thinking: the best advocates for plural marriage joined her group and made their strongest arguments. As she dug into the history, she came to believe that writers like Ogden Kraut largely repeated Orson Pratt’s nineteenth-century arguments. She walks through one favorite proof text, Isaiah 4:1, where “seven women shall take hold of one man,” and argues that it reads very differently once you remember the destruction described at the end of Isaiah 3.

    In Part 2, coming Wednesday, Michelle explains how studying Emma Smith changed her mind about Joseph Smith, and what happened to her channel when she said so out loud. Members can get the whole interview right now at patreon.com/gospeltangents. Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    0:00 Introduction
    1:21 Raised Believing Polygamy Was of God
    3:00 Post-Manifesto Polygamy in Her Family
    4:21 Fundamentalist Friends & the AUB
    5:27 Studying the Scriptures
    7:01 Pushing Against Fundamentalism?
    8:54 Section 132 Added in 1876
    10:36 King Noah & Riplakish
    13:35 RLDS Views
    15:06 The Ericksons
    17:13 Isaiah 4:1 & Ogden Kraut

    Don’t miss our previous conversation with Michelle and her sister Diane Smith!

    761: Reviewing Murder Among the Mormons (Michelle Stone/Diane Smith)
    760: Family Reactions to Mark Hofmann’s Injuries (Michelle Stone/Diane Smith)
    759: My Cousin Was a Serial Bomber (Michelle Stone/Diane Smith)

    You can also get a transcript of the previous interview: My Cousin Was a Serial Killer: Growing up with Mark Hofmann

    Don’t miss our other conversations on the Hofmann murders & forgeries: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved


    Heavenly Mothers, Second Anointings, & Church in Centennial Park (Tom Bennett 5 of 5) Nov 06, 2026
    Show notes

    Is Eve our Heavenly Mother? Tom Bennett of Centennial Park explains fundamentalist views on Heavenly Mothers, women and priesthood, and the second anointing. Check out our conversation…

    https://youtu.be/Pj8S6jzmCWo

    Don’t miss our other episodes about Centennial Park! https://gospeltangents.com/denominations/centennial-park/

    Copyright © 2025

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Except for book reviews, no content may be reproduced without written permission.

    Heavenly Mothers

    Mormon fundamentalists believe God has more than one wife. In our final conversation, Tom Bennett of Centennial Park explains his understanding of Heavenly Mothers and why he sees Eve as the mother of this world. He also explains how he believes women will receive the fullness of the priesthood, what the second anointing is, why Joseph Musser believed his excommunication couldn’t touch his authority, how marriage works when the woman receives the revelation, and what a visitor can expect at a Centennial Park church service.

    In our final conversation, Tom explained that God has more than one wife, but only one of them presides over this world: Eve. “Eve is a position like Elohim,” he told me. “It’s an office in the eternal realm of the priestesses of God.” In Tom’s understanding, the wives who preside over other worlds are Eves to those worlds.

    Tom said that fundamentalists spend a lot of time on these deeper doctrines. He pointed to the fundamentalist magazine Truth, which he said ran a sermon on Heavenly Motherhood and the eternal goddesses every Mother’s Day, and he read a quote from Joseph White Musser urging every man and woman to become “prophets and prophetesses.”

    That led us to women and the priesthood. In the LDS Church, women can’t hold the priesthood. Tom believes that women “eventually do and will hold the fullness of the patriarchal priesthood,” and he ties that to the second anointing, the ordinance that seals a couple’s calling and election. Joseph and Emma Smith received the first second anointing in 1843. Tom explained that it ordains a man a king and priest, and a woman a queen and priestess, and that it seals their exaltation unless they shed innocent blood or deny the Holy Ghost.

    He also explained why that matters for fundamentalist history: Joseph Musser received his second anointing in 1899, so in Musser’s view his 1921 excommunication couldn’t take away his authority. I asked whether that’s really any different from being “saved” in a Baptist church. Tom, a former Baptist himself, said that’s a great question, and he gave his answer on grace and works.

    We also talked about courtship. Centennial Park doesn’t do underage marriages, Tom said, and there’s no dating in the usual sense. A young woman seeks a revelation about whom she should marry and takes it to the Priesthood Council, which then approaches the man. Tom said the National Geographic series Polygamy USA is an accurate picture of how this works, and that the people in it are still members. He also said Centennial Park doesn’t excommunicate. People who leave can still come home for dinner.

    Finally, Tom described church life. Centennial Park has congregations in Centennial Park and in South Salt Lake, with priesthood leaders traveling between them. There’s no Primary and no passing of the sacrament during the service. Families hold Sunday School and bless the sacrament at home, and the meeting itself features a choir Tom compares to “a little Tabernacle Choir.” Speakers, men and women alike, are called up by the Spirit with no prepared talks. I attended one of those meetings myself, and Tom insists anyone is welcome, as long as they don’t treat it as a novelty.

    This wraps up our five-part series with Tom Bennett. We covered his journey from Protestant to Polygamy, whether fundamentalists see the LDS Church as the “one true church,” why women choose polygamy, and how Centennial Park views race and the priesthood. Don’t miss our other episodes about Centennial Park at https://gospeltangents.com/denominations/centennial-park/.

    Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    Chapters

    0:00 Heavenly Mothers
    3:02 Women & Priesthood
    4:13 Calling & Election Made Sure
    9:25 Courtship & Marriage
    12:31 Polygamy in the Media
    14:41 Church Services
    18:22 Community Life

    Copyright © 2025

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Except for book reviews, no content may be reproduced without written permission.


    Hidden Temple Theology in the Book of Mormon? Nov 02, 2026
    Show notes

    Is there a hidden temple theology in the Book of Mormon temple theology waiting beneath the 1830 text? That question, sparked by my friend Boyd in an online forum, turned into a three-part answer, and this is the final installment. While preparing, an AI tool handed me a word I had to look up: palimpsest, a manuscript scraped clean and written over, where the earlier text still shows through faintly. It turned out to be the perfect frame for the debate.

    https://youtu.be/b2hHdOXPDRA

    Temple Theology in the Book of Mormon

    On one side are Val Larsen, Dave Butler (who writes on the temple as D. John Butler) and Don Bradley. Dave believes temple language appears in the very first verse, where Nephi says he was taught “the mysteries of God,” a phrase that in the ancient world pointed to initiatory rites. He reads the prison story in Helaman 5 as a four-stage temple drama: an outer court, a circle of fire like sacred robes, a guide named Aminadab, and a voice through the veil. Building on Jack Welch, he sees the Sermon on the Mount the same way. Val connects Lehi’s tree of life to the Divine Mother and argues that the veil once worn by women in the prayer circle placed them in her position. Don points to the brother of Jared speaking through a veil, and to an 1830 interview in which Joseph Smith Sr. reportedly said the plates bore Masonic symbols, years before Joseph joined the Masons in Nauvoo.

    On the other side is historian Jonathan Stapley, author of Holiness to the Lord. Jonathan cautions against what he calls the teleological fallacy: reading highly developed 20th-century temple ideas back into an 1830 book. In his developmental view, the Nauvoo endowment grew out of Joseph’s 1842 Masonic initiation and the urgent need to bind families together before his death.

    The forum did not let me off easy. Paul argued that the either/or framing is itself the mistake, though he leaned toward Stapley. A former Latter-day Saint explained that the Book of Mormon’s view of God, more Trinitarian than Utah theology, was part of his move to the Community of Christ. Val suggested the real divide is between a dispensational view, where the gospel is revealed, lost and restored, and an evolutionary one. New Testament scholar Chris Thomas even shared an actual palimpsest, the Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus, and observed that readers who already know the modern temple tend to be the ones who find it in the text. Paul also shared the story of how his wife’s conch-shell sketch shaped the Community of Christ temple in Independence.

    Is the temple a restored ancient blueprint or a revelation that grew line upon line? Watch the full forum and decide which layer you see.

    Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.


    Greg Prince Interview: Full 2017 Conversation, Released for the First Time Oct 31, 2026
    Show notes

    This Greg Prince interview is a throwback to 2017, and for the first time the entire conversation is available in one piece. On September 27, 2017, historian Greg Prince was in Salt Lake City to deliver the Sterling McMurrin Lecture at the Salt Lake City Public Library, and before his talk he sat down with me for a long and candid conversation. We originally released it in seven parts.

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Greg: https://gospeltangents.com/people/greg-prince

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Full Greg Prince Interview

    Greg is a biomedical researcher by profession, but he is also one of the most careful historians in Mormon studies. He wrote Power From on High: The Development of Mormon Priesthood (1995), David O. McKay and the Rise of Modern Mormonism (2005), and Leonard Arrington and the Writing of Mormon History (2016). When we talked, he was finishing the book that became Gay Rights and the Mormon Church (2019).

    LDS Church and its Gay Members

    We start with that research. Greg explains that the word “homosexuality” first appeared in the Church’s General Handbook of Instructions in 1968, the year before the Stonewall riots. From there he traces how policy developed over the next half century. We also discuss the November 2015 policy on children of gay parents. Greg says members of the Quorum of the Twelve told him they learned of it only two days before it leaked to the public. He argues that denying an infant a name and a blessing is a punishment, whatever the intent. The Church reversed that policy in 2019, after this conversation was recorded.

    Four Leadership Vacuums

    Greg co-wrote an article in Dialogue titled “Gerontocracy and the Future of Mormonism.” He describes four periods when a church president’s health left a gap at the top: David O. McKay in the late 1960s, Spencer W. Kimball, Ezra Taft Benson, and, at the time we spoke, Thomas S. Monson. Greg believes major decisions were made by others during each of these periods, and he explains why he calls it “not ideal governance.” President Monson died a few months after this interview, in January 2018.

    Priesthood, Word of Wisdom, & a Pepsi man

    We also dig into the early development of priesthood offices, and how Joseph Smith’s understanding of authority grew over time. Greg offers a naturalistic reading of the Word of Wisdom, which he sees as reflecting the temperance ideas of 1833. He describes it as moving through three phases, from loosely observed advice to a requirement. Along the way he tells one of my favorite stories: a theater publicist was told President McKay drank Coca-Cola, but one of McKay’s secretaries remembered a refrigerator shelf full of Pepsi. Finally, we look at when and why the Church began ordaining young men to the Aaronic Priesthood, a practice Greg traces to the early 1900s.

    Hear it all in one place!

    These conversations first ran as seven separate episodes. This release puts the whole interview together in the order we recorded it, so you can hear how one topic led to the next. It’s a rare chance to spend more than an hour and a half with a historian who has spent decades in the archives.

    If you enjoy it, please consider supporting Gospel Tangents at https://patreon.com/GospelTangents. Your support helps us bring you more conversations like this one.

    Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    Sources:

    • Gregory A. Prince bio, Dialogue
    • Gay Rights and the Mormon Church, Mormon History Association
    • Power From on High, Signature Books

    Chapters

    0:00 Introduction
    0:56 History of LDS Policy Toward Gays
    20:41 The 4 LDS Leadership Vacuums: What Happened?
    33:38 Ailing Church Leaders: “Not Ideal Governance”
    50:13 Early LDS Priesthood: Similar to Ancient Christianity?
    1:08:44 Naturalistic Explanation for Word of Wisdom?
    1:24:30 When Did LDS Start Ordaining Youth?
    1:32:25 “There Is Nothing in LDS Policy That Justifies Whacking Infants”


    Raising Kids in Polygamy & Reason Fundamentalists Stay Quiet Oct 31, 2026
    Show notes

    Raising Kids in Polygamy

    Raising kids in polygamy comes with a hard truth: many children raised in plural families walk away as adults. Some join the LDS Church, some leave religion altogether. So what do plural families hope for their own kids? In the final part of my interview with Joshua, Charlotte and Melissa Erickson of Lehi, Utah, we talk about their hopes for their children, a new fundamentalist fellowship Joshua leads, and why so many fundamentalists still won’t talk to outsiders.

    https://youtu.be/Ur4R3vtJSvo

    Don’t miss our other conversations on Mormon fundamentalism: https://gospeltangents.com/denominations/fundamentalim/

    Good Spouses First

    Should the Erickson children practice plural marriage? Charlotte’s answer was simple: “If they want to.” She chose polygamy and finds it worth it, but she doesn’t teach her children that it is required for heaven. “I don’t like the teaching that it has to somehow be white knuckled through because it’s a box to check to get into heaven,” she said. Melissa put her goal another way: she wants to raise sons who are such good husbands that more than one woman would want to marry them. Pointing to passages in the Book of Mormon and Doctrine and Covenants about taking the same spirit into the next life, she believes an unhappy marriage won’t magically become heaven after death. Her rule for her children: “If polygamy happens, then that’s great. If not, that’s fine too, but you must be a good spouse.”

    Keeping Kids in the Faith

    For Charlotte, “the faith” doesn’t mean a particular fundamentalist group. It means faith in God and the scriptures, including the full Latter-day Saint canon. She’d be fine if her children joined a group, but sad if they became atheists. One strategy the family uses is to make the biblical holidays Jesus celebrated a big deal. Their children count down to the next feast as soon as one ends (“except for Shavuot,” Charlotte joked). She sees these as holidays for all the tribes of Israel, not just the Jews.

    Mormon Legacy Ministries

    Joshua serves as bishop of Mormon Legacy Ministries, a fellowship that holds a hybrid in-person and Zoom sacrament meeting on the second and fourth Saturdays. Why Saturday? So people who belong to other groups can attend without missing their own Sunday meetings. There is also a women’s group on Tuesdays and a Thursday class, with schedules and Zoom links at mormonlegacy.org. Joshua says the ministry doesn’t want to be a church: it performs no baptisms, ordinations or marriages, but it can refer people to those who will. He describes it as a fellowship and referral service.

    Why Fundamentalists Stay Private

    Why are so many fundamentalists insular? Melissa, whose own ancestors were Catholic before joining the LDS Church, points to generational trauma. Neighbors turned in plural families, grandfathers went to prison or had to disavow their wives, and plural wives were introduced as “aunts.” In Utah, polygamy remained a felony until 2020, apart from a brief window after a federal judge struck down part of the law in the Kody Brown case, a ruling later overturned on appeal. Today it is an infraction with a fine of up to $750. “I ain’t paying,” Melissa laughed. But after watching children taken from their parents in Texas, she says, it’s fair to give fundamentalists space when they aren’t willing to talk.

    Wrapping Up the Series

    That closes our four-part conversation with the Ericksons. We covered their move from the LDS Church to fundamentalism and the Zarahemla Foundation, Restoration scripture and priesthood authority, and patriarchal polygamy, female priesthood blessings and Black polygamists. Next up is Justin Francom, from the Missouri group that built a fundamentalist temple.

    Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

    Chapters

    00:00 Should Polygamous Kids Practice Polygamy?
    01:48 Charlotte: Not a Box to Check for Heaven
    03:18 Melissa: Raise Good Spouses First
    05:40 Helping Children Stay in the Faith
    06:30 Biblical Holidays as a Family Strategy
    07:39 Mormon Legacy Ministries
    08:20 Why Sacrament Meeting Is on Saturday
    09:47 Weekly Schedule & the 1977 Block Schedule
    11:04 Joshua’s Role as Bishop
    12:15 A Fellowship and Referral Service, Not a Church
    13:08 Why Fundamentalists Stay Private
    14:58 Utah Bigamy Law: Felony to Infraction


    Why Mark Skousen Was Called into Dallin Oaks BYU Office Oct 26, 2026
    Show notes

    Dallin Oaks BYU: Why Mark Skousen Was Called into His Office

    Dallin Oaks BYU was a formidable figure, and economist Mark Skousen remembers what happened when a controversial student newspaper editorial brought him face-to-face with the university president.

    In the final installment of our four-part Gospel Tangents interview, Mark shares some remarkable stories from his years at Brigham Young University, including a confrontation with Dallin H. Oaks, his experiences in student journalism, and his unlikely home teaching partnership with historian Richard Bushman.

    It’s a fascinating glimpse into BYU history, academic freedom, and the personalities who shaped modern Mormonism.

    https://youtu.be/OnJC86ppc58

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Dallin Oaks BYU: “Don’t Ever Do It Again!”

    Imagine being a young BYU student involved with the campus newspaper and finding yourself summoned to the university president’s office.

    That’s exactly what happened to Mark Skousen.

    Mark recalls a controversial editorial that caught the attention of President Dallin H. Oaks.

    The message Mark remembers receiving was unmistakable:

    “Don’t ever do it again!”

    What was so controversial about the editorial? Why did Oaks intervene personally? And what does the incident reveal about the relationship between student journalism and university leadership?

    Mark tells the story in our interview.

    Home Teaching with Richard Bushman

    One of the more unexpected revelations involves historian Richard Bushman, best known to many Latter-day Saints for his biography Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling.

    Long before Bushman became one of Mormonism’s most prominent historians, he and Mark Skousen shared a distinctly Mormon responsibility: home teaching.

    What was it like to serve alongside a future leading historian of Joseph Smith?

    Mark shares his memories of Bushman and other influential figures he encountered during his BYU years.

    Why Did BYU Take Control of Its Student Newspaper?

    The conversation also explores a larger controversy involving BYU’s student newspaper, the Daily Universe.

    Student newspapers can provide an important forum for debate, criticism, and independent thinking. But what happens when student editors publish material that university administrators find objectionable?

    Mark reflects on the tensions surrounding student journalism at BYU and the eventual shift toward greater faculty oversight.

    Was that a necessary safeguard for a religious university, or did it come at the expense of student independence?

    It’s a question that remains relevant to discussions of academic freedom today.

    From Jeffrey R. Holland to General Conference

    Mark also recalls taking a Book of Mormon class from Jeffrey R. Holland and shares other stories about his encounters with prominent Latter-day Saint figures.

    And there’s a surprising connection to the April 2009 LDS General Conference: a letter Mark wrote was quoted during the conference.

    These personal experiences provide a different perspective on people who later became widely recognized leaders, scholars, and educators.

    Watch the Final Gospel Tangents Preview

    We’ve spent the first three episodes exploring Mark Skousen’s relationship with Uncle Cleon, his views on economics, the John Birch Society, and Joseph Smith’s economic experiments.

    Now, in Part 4, we turn to the people and controversies that shaped Mark’s years at BYU.

    What really happened in Dallin Oaks’s office? And what can Mark’s experiences teach us about academic freedom at a religious university?

    Watch the teaser and join us for the conclusion of this four-part Gospel Tangents interview.

    Want to hear about upcoming interviews, new episodes, and occasional exclusive content? Subscribe to the free Gospel Tangents newsletter.

    What Do You Think?

    • Should a university president personally intervene when a student newspaper publishes a controversial editorial?
    • How much editorial independence should students have at a religious university?
    • Are religious universities different from secular universities when it comes to academic freedom?
    • Which of Mark’s stories about prominent Latter-day Saint figures surprised you most?

    Leave a comment! I’d love to hear your perspective on BYU history, student journalism, and the balance between institutional identity and intellectual independence.

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved


    Was Joseph Smith a Socialist? Oct 23, 2026
    Show notes

    Was Joseph Smith a socialist? Economist Mark Skousen was surprised—and more than a little irritated—when he discovered that a BYU economics professor had classified the founder of Mormonism as a utopian socialist. But when I challenged Mark about Joseph Smith’s economic teachings, his answer was more complicated than a simple yes or no.

    https://youtu.be/J9AVMBliFvo

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    In Part 3 of our four-part Gospel Tangents interview, Mark Skousen examines the economics of early Mormonism, including the law of consecration, the United Order, private property, and tithing. We also discuss Adam Smith, Karl Marx, John Maynard Keynes, and whether Joseph Smith’s economic experiments were closer to socialism or capitalism.

    And Mark offers a surprising criticism of Joseph Smith’s plans for building Zion.

    Was Joseph Smith a Socialist? Mark Skousen Responds

    The question began with a poster at Brigham Young University.

    Mark recalls that economist Val Lamson had created a chart showing different schools of economic thought. To Mark’s astonishment, Joseph Smith appeared among the utopian socialists.

    Mark strongly objected.

    However, he acknowledged that Joseph Smith briefly experimented with economic arrangements that could be described as utopian socialism.

    Early Latter-day Saints sought to eliminate poverty and create a community in which members shared their resources. But according to Mark, Joseph Smith eventually moved toward an economic system that preserved private property and individual stewardship.

    So where does Joseph Smith fit economically?

    Mark suggests that communitarian may be a better description than socialist.

    He points to the work of historian Leonard Arrington and argues that Joseph Smith wanted a cooperative religious society without eliminating individual responsibility.

    But that raises another question.

    If the early Saints were trying to build Zion, why didn’t their economic system last?

    Why Did the United Order Fail?

    One of the most interesting parts of our conversation concerns Mark’s explanation for the failure of the United Order.

    Under early consecration arrangements, members contributed their property and received stewardships intended to meet their needs. Surplus resources were supposed to support the Church and assist others.

    Mark argues that this arrangement created an economic problem.

    If people were expected to contribute all their surplus, what incentive did they have to produce more than they needed?

    He compares that arrangement to a 100% marginal tax rate.

    Mark also notes that many early Church members were poor. There simply wasn’t enough surplus wealth to sustain the system as envisioned.

    He contrasts these experiments with tithing, which allows individuals to retain most of their income while contributing a portion to the Church.

    From Mark’s perspective, tithing creates a better balance between supporting a religious community and encouraging individual initiative.

    Of course, historians and economists may disagree about whether incentives alone explain the difficulties of the United Order. But Mark’s interpretation raises important questions about the practical challenges of communal religious economies.

    Was the United Order Really Socialism?

    Mark also discusses a distinction emphasized by LDS leader Marion G. Romney: the United Order and socialism were not necessarily the same thing.

    One important difference, according to Romney, involved private property and voluntary consecration.

    Mark argues that Joseph Smith’s stewardship system preserved an important role for private ownership, even while encouraging members to devote their resources to the common good.

    We also discuss the scriptural ideal of having no rich or poor among the people, as described in Fourth Nephi and the New Testament book of Acts.

    Was Joseph Smith trying to establish an entirely new economic system?

    Or was he adapting biblical principles to the practical needs of a growing religious community?

    Mark believes Joseph Smith was searching for a middle ground.

    Is Tithing a Form of Capitalism?

    This may be the most surprising question of the interview.

    When I asked whether tithing was an Adam Smith principle, Mark argued that it was much closer to Smith’s philosophy than to centralized economic planning.

    His reasoning is straightforward.

    Under tithing, members contribute 10% while retaining control over the rest of their resources. They can save, invest, establish businesses, support charitable causes, or make other financial decisions.

    Mark believes that arrangement encourages productivity while still providing resources for shared religious purposes.

    He contrasts it with a system in which Church leaders would need to evaluate each family’s finances, businesses, and economic decisions.

    Imagine your bishop having to determine how much money you should earn, what investments you should make, or how your business should operate.

    Mark argues that such a system would be impractical.

    His conclusion is that tithing provides a more sustainable economic foundation than the early communal experiments.

    Adam Smith, Keynes, and Marx: Three Competing Economic Visions

    Before turning to Joseph Smith, I asked Mark to explain some basic differences between major economic schools.

    Mark organizes economic history around three influential thinkers:

    • Adam Smith: Associated with markets, limited government, private enterprise, and economic liberty.
    • John Maynard Keynes: Associated with government intervention to manage economic downturns and broader macroeconomic policy.
    • Karl Marx: Associated with the critique of capitalism and the replacement of private ownership of productive resources.

    Mark clearly favors Adam Smith’s approach.

    But the comparison becomes especially interesting when applied to early Mormonism.

    Joseph Smith encouraged generosity and cooperation, yet he also established individual stewardships and taught principles of personal responsibility.

    Does that make him a socialist, a capitalist, or something else entirely?

    Perhaps our modern political labels don’t fit the religious and economic experiments of the 1830s particularly well.

    Mark Skousen Criticizes Joseph Smith’s City of Zion

    Mark’s criticisms aren’t limited to the United Order.

    We also discuss Joseph Smith’s proposed City of Zion, with its grid layout and central complex of twenty-four houses of the Lord.

    Mark isn’t impressed with the uniformity of the design.

    He argues that cities need individuality, variety, and a sense of personality rather than rigid planning.

    I bring up David Hall’s NewVistas project, which attempted to develop a modern community inspired by Joseph Smith’s city-planning ideas in Vermont.

    The discussion raises an intriguing issue: How much planning is necessary to build an ideal community, and when does planning become too restrictive?

    It’s another example of Mark applying economic ideas to subjects that Latter-day Saints usually approach from a religious or historical perspective.

    “Teach Them Correct Principles”

    One of Mark’s favorite statements attributed to Joseph Smith is:

    “I teach them correct principles, and they govern themselves.”

    Mark sees this as a powerful expression of individual liberty.

    In his interpretation, Joseph Smith wanted people to learn principles such as honesty, thrift, hard work, and responsibility—and then make their own decisions.

    That approach fits Mark’s broader economic philosophy.

    But it also raises an interesting historical question: How do we reconcile individual self-government with the collective responsibilities envisioned in the law of consecration?

    The tension between personal freedom and communal obligation remains relevant to Latter-day Saint discussions of economics today.

    What Can We Learn from Mormon Economic History?

    Whether or not you agree with Mark Skousen’s conclusions, this conversation offers an unusual perspective on Joseph Smith’s economic experiments.

    Rather than discussing the United Order only as a theological ideal, Mark examines the incentives, property arrangements, and practical difficulties involved.

    He challenges the idea that Joseph Smith can be neatly classified as a socialist, explains why he believes tithing was more successful than communal consecration, and questions aspects of Joseph Smith’s plans for Zion.

    It’s a provocative discussion at the intersection of Mormon history, economics, and theology.

    Watch Part 3 of my four-part Gospel Tangents interview with Mark Skousen, and let me know what you think.

    Questions for Discussion

    1. Was Joseph Smith a socialist, a capitalist, or something that doesn’t fit either label?
    2. Did the United Order fail because of economic incentives, or were other historical factors more important?
    3. Does tithing represent a successful adaptation of the law of consecration?
    4. Would Joseph Smith’s City of Zion have been a desirable place to live?
    5. Can a religious community successfully balance private property with the goal of eliminating poverty?

    I’d love to hear your perspective in the comments—especially if you think Mark’s economic interpretation overlooks important historical or theological considerations.

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    0:00 Introduction: The Big Three in Economics
    1:20 Adam Smith, Keynes and Marx
    4:50 How BYU Economics Changed
    5:49 Was Joseph Smith a Utopian Socialist?
    7:17 Why the United Order Failed
    9:34 Was Joseph Smith a Communitarian?
    11:21 Stewardship and Correct Principles
    13:58 Joseph Smith’s City of Zion
    15:04 Is Tithing an Adam Smith Principle?
    17:53 Church Welfare vs. Government Welfare


    Was Eisenhower Soviet Agent? Mark Skousen Challenges Uncle Cleon (Mark Skousen 2 of 4) Oct 20, 2026
    Show notes

    Was Eisenhower Soviet agent? That extraordinary accusation came from John Birch Society founder Robert Welch, who believed President Dwight D. Eisenhower was secretly serving Communist interests. But economist Mark Skousen, nephew of the famous conservative author W. Cleon Skousen, thinks the accusation was outrageous.

    https://youtu.be/5Hol7hUZExc

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    Mark explains why he rejected the John Birch Society’s allegations, where he disagreed with his uncle, and how a surprising conversation about Adam Smith changed his understanding of economics.

    We also revisit the controversial BYU spy ring, Ezra Taft Benson’s relationship with Ernest Wilkinson, and the importance of academic freedom.

    Was Eisenhower Soviet Agent Secretly Helping the Communists?

    During the Cold War, some American conservatives became convinced that President Eisenhower wasn’t doing enough to stop Soviet expansion.

    Robert Welch, founder of the John Birch Society, went much further. In his book The Politician, he accused Eisenhower of being an agent of the Communist conspiracy.

    Why would anyone make such an extraordinary claim?

    Mark explains that Eisenhower repeatedly avoided direct confrontation with the Soviet Union, including during international crises such as the Hungarian Revolution. Critics interpreted his restraint as evidence that he was deliberately allowing communism to spread.

    But Mark sees Eisenhower’s strategy differently.

    He argues that Eisenhower understood the Soviet economic system was fundamentally flawed and believed it could eventually collapse without risking a nuclear war.

    Rather than seeing Eisenhower as a traitor, Mark gives him high marks for his presidency.

    Mark’s rejection of Welch’s accusation is particularly interesting because his uncle Cleon Skousen was closely associated with the same conservative political movement.

    Uncle Cleon and the John Birch Society

    W. Cleon Skousen became one of America’s best-known anti-communist authors through books such as The Naked Communist and The Naked Capitalist.

    But how closely was he connected to the John Birch Society?

    Mark explains that Cleon defended the organization and even wrote a pamphlet titled The Communist Attack on the John Birch Society.

    However, Mark says Cleon never officially joined the organization and eventually experienced a falling-out with it.

    Mark himself never became a member.

    He believed the society’s accusations against Eisenhower went far beyond legitimate concerns about Communist infiltration.

    This raises an intriguing question: How could two members of the same family, both committed to free-market economics and opposed to communism, reach such different conclusions?

    The Naked Communist vs. The Naked Capitalist

    Mark’s disagreements with Uncle Cleon extended beyond the John Birch Society.

    He strongly admired The Naked Communist, believing it offered an important warning about the dangers of communism.

    But he was much less impressed with The Naked Capitalist.

    One reason was Cleon’s portrayal of powerful business figures such as David Rockefeller.

    Mark had personally interviewed Rockefeller while working for Forbes and didn’t see him as the sinister figure portrayed in some anti-communist accounts.

    Although Mark disagreed with Rockefeller’s support for larger government, he didn’t believe that made him part of a sinister conspiracy.

    It’s a revealing distinction: Mark could appreciate his uncle’s contributions while rejecting some of his more controversial conclusions.

    But there was another disagreement in which Uncle Cleon unexpectedly changed Mark’s mind.

    Was Adam Smith Inspired by God?

    While writing his history of economic thought, The Making of Modern Economics, Mark initially adopted economist Murray Rothbard’s critical interpretation of Adam Smith.

    He wrote a chapter portraying Smith in a largely negative light.

    Then he visited Uncle Cleon.

    Mark handed him the chapter and asked whether he was on the right track.

    Without even reading it, Cleon put his arm around Mark and told him that Adam Smith’s doctrine of the invisible hand was inspired by God.

    Mark was stunned.

    Whom should he believe—his respected professional mentor, Murray Rothbard, or his wise old Uncle Cleon?

    Instead of simply accepting either opinion, Mark decided to investigate for himself.

    He read all 1,000 pages of Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations.

    And when he finished, he concluded that Uncle Cleon was right.

    Mark rewrote his chapter, transformed the structure of his book, and ultimately dedicated it to Cleon.

    It’s one of my favorite stories from the interview because it demonstrates how disagreement can lead to serious investigation and a genuine change of mind.

    Ezra Taft Benson, Ernest Wilkinson, and the BYU Spy Ring

    Our conversation also returns to a controversial episode from Mark’s student days at Brigham Young University.

    During Ernest Wilkinson’s administration, students were recruited to monitor professors whose political and economic views concerned conservative university figures.

    Mark discusses Wilkinson’s close relationship with Ezra Taft Benson and their connections with the Foundation for Economic Education.

    Did Benson encourage the monitoring effort? Was Wilkinson responsible? And what did the students actually discover?

    Mark discusses what he remembers, while acknowledging that he cannot establish exactly who initiated the effort.

    He also reflects on his own participation.

    Looking back, Mark believes the students were naive. He says he would not participate in such an effort today.

    Interestingly, he doesn’t believe the episode resulted in professors being fired, although he acknowledges the controversy that followed when the monitoring became known.

    Why Academic Freedom Matters

    Perhaps the most unexpected part of the interview is Mark’s defense of intellectual diversity.

    He recalls a conversation with Nobel Prize-winning economist Milton Friedman about whether free-market economists should dominate university economics departments.

    Friedman opposed that approach, arguing that universities should expose students to competing viewpoints.

    Mark agrees.

    He discusses the importance of intellectual diversity at BYU and contrasts his experiences teaching at Columbia University and Chapman University.

    For Mark, a university should be a place where students encounter ideas they disagree with—not merely a place where everyone reinforces the same worldview.

    That principle also helps explain his complicated relationship with Uncle Cleon.

    He admired his uncle without agreeing with him on everything.

    Can We Admire Someone Without Agreeing with Everything They Say?

    What makes this interview especially interesting is that Mark Skousen doesn’t fit neatly into the political categories we often use.

    He can praise The Naked Communist while criticizing The Naked Capitalist.

    He can admire Uncle Cleon while rejecting the John Birch Society’s accusations against Eisenhower.

    And he can defend free-market economics while insisting that universities should welcome competing perspectives.

    Perhaps the most important lesson is that intellectual independence requires more than disagreeing with our opponents. Sometimes it means questioning the people we admire most.

    Watch Part 2 of our four-part Gospel Tangents interview with economist Mark Skousen to hear these stories in his own words.

    What Do You Think?

    1. Why do you think Robert Welch and other conservatives became suspicious of President Eisenhower?
    2. Was Mark right to reject the John Birch Society’s accusations?
    3. Do you find Cleon’s claim that Adam Smith’s invisible hand was inspired by God persuasive?
    4. Should religious universities encourage professors to teach competing political and economic viewpoints?
    5. Is it possible to admire someone deeply while rejecting some of their most important ideas?

    Share your thoughts in the comments. I’d especially like to hear how you think we should evaluate controversial historical figures whose ideas continue to influence Latter-day Saints today.

    Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen

    Copyright © 2026

    Gospel Tangents

    All Rights Reserved

    0:00 The Naked Communist vs. The Naked Capitalist
    3:58 Adam Smith Inspired of God?
    8:37 Ezra Taft Benson, Wilkinson and FEE
    11:44 Why Mark Wasn’t a Bircher
    12:02 Robert Welch and Eisenhower
    14:16 Cleon and the John Birch Society
    15:51 Political Diversity and Academic Freedom
    20:02 Fallout from the BYU Spy Ring
    21:18 Academic Freedom at Columbia and Chapman


    1 2 3 22 Next

    Related Podcasts

    Joel Osteen Podcast

    1

    Joel Osteen Podcast Christianity
    Joel Osteen Podcast

    2

    Joel Osteen Podcast Christianity
    The Bible For Normal People

    3

    The Bible For Normal People Christianity
    The Liturgists Podcast

    4

    The Liturgists Podcast Christianity
    Firestarters

    5

    Firestarters Christianity
    Elevation with Steven Furtick

    6

    Elevation with Steven Furtick Christianity
    footer-logo

    Contact Us

    Toll Free: 844-670-7747

    Links

    • Home
    • Top Charts
    • Networks
    • Apps
    • Independents Podcasts
    • Podcast Advertising
    • Podcast News
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Analytics & Insights

    Stay Connected

      Privacy, Terms of Use & Our Code of Ethics Protecting Content Creators Copyrights