Host Steve “Murph” Murphy (retired DEA Agent, featured in NARCOS on Netflix) takes you inside the most intense and fascinating true crime stories in the world. Real life tales from the most notorious cases everyone knows and some you’ve probably never heard of (until now) from those who broke the law and those who were sworn to enforce it. Murph asks the questions and gets into the true stories from the real life players in the biggest, baddest, most dangerous game of all — the Game of Crimes.
194: Part 1 – Karla Castellanos – US Border Patrol agent protecting our borders and saving lives!!
Apr 28, 2025
Show notes
Murph sits down with Karla Castellanos, a dedicated U.S. Border Patrol agent with four years of boots-on-the-ground experience protecting America’s border. Karla shares her true crime journey into law enforcement, offering an inside look at the Border Patrol Academy, the grueling training process, and what it truly means to serve and protect—often alone in the harsh desert. Discover real-life stories from the frontlines, including human trafficking cases, border apprehensions, and the daily risks agents face. Karla opens up about the mental and physical challenges of patrolling solo, the value of teamwork, and the trust built between partners—including her K9 partner. This episode is packed with gripping, emotional, and heroic tales from the field.
193: Part 2, Colton Seale - Fort Hood, Boston bombing, and interrogation secrets
Apr 22, 2025
Show notes
Retired FBI Special Agent Colton Seale reveals his behind-the-scenes experiences from some of America's most high-profile investigations, including the Fort Hood shooting and the Boston Marathon bombing. Colton shares his journey transitioning to the elite High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG), where he mastered advanced interrogation techniques to extract critical intelligence. Discover how Colton's passion for truth led him to found Pyxis Academy, where he now trains professionals in investigative interviewing — skills that are vital not just for law enforcement, but also for corporate success.
193: Part 1, Colton Seale - FBI agent specializing in counter-terrorism
Apr 21, 2025
Show notes
Murph sits down with retired FBI Special Agent Colton Seale, a true American patriot and hero. Colton shares his unique journey into law enforcement, from his early days to facing the raw realities of crime in Alaska — including human trafficking, indigenous issues, and survival in extreme conditions. Hear exclusive stories about Colton’s time living in a castle in Spain, his rodeo adventures, and his work on the elite FBI Fly Team specializing in counterterrorism. This gripping conversation dives deep into the Osama bin Laden raid, advanced interrogation techniques, and how relationship-building is critical in modern law enforcement operations.
192: Part 2, Justin Klitch – Health, Heroic Policing, and Entrepreneurship
Apr 15, 2025
Show notes
Justin Klitch opens up about his law enforcement journey, sharing the emotional toll that high-stress situations, particularly drug-related incidents, can have on officers and their communities. From witnessing the devastating effects of addiction on families to dealing with the aftermath of a life-changing accident, Justin speaks candidly about his struggles with mental health and substance use. He stresses the critical importance of mental health awareness within law enforcement and first responders and encourages others to seek help when needed. Justin also recounts gripping true crime stories, including a high-stakes police chase, a heroic life-saving traffic stop involving an abused child, and the challenges of handling complex homicide investigations. As a former law enforcement officer, Justin also discusses the role of leadership in policing and the camaraderie among officers. Justin shares his transition from law enforcement to entrepreneurship with his soap company, designed to support first responders and veterans.
192: Part 1, Justin Klitch – US Coast Guard to Idaho State Police
Apr 14, 2025
Show notes
Join Murph as he welcomes Justin Klitsch, a seasoned US Coast Guard veteran and an active Trooper with the Idaho State Police, for a deep dive into the world of law enforcement. Justin shares captivating stories from small-town policing, offering a humorous perspective on the unique challenges faced by officers in rural areas. Hear about Justin's upbringing in a law enforcement family and his impactful transition from the Coast Guard to the Idaho State Police. The episode also touches on the emotional and professional effects of 9/11 on law enforcement, the critical role of leadership in policing, and the vital importance of family support throughout a law enforcement career. Murph and Justin discuss personal anecdotes from their experiences, highlighting the bonds formed during police training, the highs and lows of working in the field, and the tight-knit relationships that form within the law enforcement community.
191: Part 2, Matthew Klein’s True Crime Journey with the NYPD
Apr 08, 2025
Show notes
Former NYPD forensic artist Matthew Klein shares his incredible journey from military service to becoming one of the city's top police sketch artists. Matthew dives deep into the process of becoming a forensic artist, including the challenging art of sketching suspects from memory and how technology has transformed forensic art. One of his most notable cases, the Brooklyn slasher, is discussed in detail, showcasing how his sketches helped law enforcement track down dangerous criminals. Klein also reflects on the evolution of his career, the impact of his artwork, and his transition into the world of pop art and animation.
191: Part 1, Matthew Klein – US Army Combat Vet, NYPD Detective Forensic Sketch Artist
Apr 07, 2025
Show notes
Murph welcomes retired NYPD officer Matthew Klein. They dive into Klein's extraordinary journey, from growing up on Long Island to joining the US Army post-9/11. Klein shares his gripping story of military service during the Iraq War, where he earned a Purple Heart for his bravery and recounts the emotional challenges of combat. With a blend of humor and sincerity, Klein also opens up about his transition to the NYPD, the camaraderie of law enforcement, and the tough realities of life in uniform.
190: Randy Sutton: LVMPD - Idealism, Disillusioned, Abandoned
Mar 31, 2025
Show notes
Discover the gripping journey of Randy Sutton, a legendary law enforcement officer who spent decades serving and protecting. Sutton takes us from his childhood dream of becoming a police officer to his transformative experiences with the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department. He shares raw, emotional stories of heroism, survival, and the harsh realities of policing — from confronting life-threatening situations to the unforgettable moment he saved a baby’s life during a gang shooting. Learn how these experiences led Sutton to create The Wounded Blue, a critical support system for injured officers, emphasizing the importance of mental health and emotional resilience.
189: Part 2: Ryan Tillman – Viral Cop’s Fight for Authenticity, Community, and Future in Politics
Mar 25, 2025
Show notes
Ryan Tillman, a dedicated law enforcement officer and mentor, shares his powerful journey of authenticity, community engagement, and leadership. From facing backlash over a viral dance video to inspiring change within the profession, Ryan opens up about the challenges of being a cop in today’s world. He discusses the critical role of trust in policing, the dangers of peer pressure in law enforcement, and the life-altering decisions officers must make in high-stress situations. As a mentor, Ryan dives into the impact of guiding youth, particularly in tough environments, and the essential role of community responsibility in raising the next generation. He emphasizes love, respect, and the power of strong parenting in shaping young lives. In a surprising twist, Ryan reveals his aspirations to run for Governor of California, advocating for common-sense leadership and real change.
189: Part 1: Ryan Tillman – Chino Police, Bridging the Gap: Policing, Community, and Viral Fame
Mar 24, 2025
Show notes
Murph welcomes Ryan Tillman—police officer, social media influencer, and founder of Breaking Barriers United—to dive deep into the realities of law enforcement, community relations, and true crime. Ryan shares his journey from doubting a career in policing to becoming a key advocate for better communication and trust between police and the public. Hear hilarious criminal stories, insider perspectives on police training, use of force, and leadership, and Ryan’s personal struggles and triumphs. He opens up about the impact of Michael Brown’s death on his policing philosophy, how he handled backlash from his viral dance video, and the lessons learned as a school resource officer.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
