Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Tiki Reveals Exactly Why Tyrone Tracy Keeps Fumbling Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Tyrone Tracy’s ball security is becoming a serious concern for the Giants, and Tiki Barber explains exactly what the running back is doing wrong. Tiki breaks down the technique he used to eliminate fumbling from his own game and why one mistake against an elite opponent can completely change a game. Evan Roberts and Tiki also wonder what John Harbaugh’s actions will reveal about Tracy’s role, especially with Najee Harris pushing for opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Yankees’ catching situation after Ali Sánchez appeared unaware the game had ended, plus a fascinating Jets hypothetical: would Josh Allen have failed in New York, and would Sam Darnold have developed much faster in Buffalo?

Giants-Rams Sparks a Wild Emotional Insurance Debate Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

The Giants’ matchup with the Rams turns into a hilarious fight over “emotional insurance” as Evan Roberts argues Shaun Morash should take Los Angeles in his knockout pool. The logic is simple: if the Giants pull the upset and start 2-0, Shaun will be too euphoric to care that his pool entry is dead. Shaun strongly disagrees, insisting there are smarter survivor options and no reason to risk thousands of dollars against his own team. The guys also look at the Knicks bringing recognizable veterans Bruce Brown and James Wiseman to training camp, plus Jacoby Brissett’s surprising run of passing production and why his career has made him an ideal veteran backup quarterback.

Steve Cohen’s Pete Alonso Celebration Sparks Mets Fury Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Steve Cohen standing and applauding Pete Alonso’s game-tying 300th career home run creates a heated debate over what the Mets owner was really celebrating. Evan Roberts is bothered less by the applause itself and more by the fact that Cohen could have kept Alonso, never made him an offer this offseason, then welcomed him back and cheered one of his biggest moments. Shaun Morash sees another problem: Cohen was applauding a home run that hurt his own team, which sends a strange message after years of owners insisting every game matters. Tiki Barber is less bothered, but the conversation turns to how Mets players might view the moment and whether Cohen’s handling of Alonso now feels contradictory.

Garrett Wilson Gets Exactly What Jets Fans Endured Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Garrett Wilson understands exactly what Jets fans have endured, and Evan Roberts loves that the star receiver knows how quickly New York will rally around a team that finally gives them something to believe in. Wilson’s comments about rewarding the fan base spark a bigger conversation about why Jets fans remain so passionate despite years of losing. That leads to a revealing contrast with former Jet Alijah Vera-Tucker, who admits the losing eventually became something players could grow numb to. Tiki Barber explains why changing that culture takes more than individual players, then breaks down why advanced football grades can be misleading without knowing each player’s exact assignment. Evan also makes a bold prediction that Elliott Ramos will deliver for the Yankees in the postseason.

Pete Alonso’s Yankee Stadium Comment Infuriates Evan Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field ends with a comment that rubs Evan Roberts the wrong way. After Alonso says New York feels like a homecoming whether he’s at Citi Field or Yankee Stadium, Evan argues that lumping the two ballparks together diminishes the love Mets fans just showed him. Tiki Barber sees it as a harmless, if awkward, remark as the debate over Alonso’s relationship with New York continues. The Yankees also have decisions to make with October approaching. With the AL East essentially gone, Evan and Tiki debate whether this is the time to experiment with Luis Garcia at second base and even give Anthony Volpe a look at third.

Aaron Judge Injury Creates a Yankees Lineup Crisis Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge’s lower-body injury could force the Yankees into a major postseason lineup shuffle. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge now needs to become the designated hitter, what that would mean for Ben Rice and Luis Garcia, and whether the Yankees can trust Garcia defensively at second base with October approaching. The concern goes beyond whether Judge will return. The Yankees need his bat, but protecting him in the field could create difficult decisions everywhere else. Plus, the conversation shifts to Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field and why the Mets’ failure to adequately replace him has made fans miss him even more.

Aaron Judge Injury Sparks Yankees’ Worst October Fear Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge’s latest injury scare has the Yankees facing an uncomfortable question just before the postseason. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how concerned fans should be after Judge left with a lower-body issue, with Evan believing the early signs suggest this is not a season-ending injury while Tiki warns that Judge has only recently returned and may not be fully ready for the grind. The bigger concern is October. With the AL East effectively gone, the Yankees need Judge healthy more than ever, and there’s no guarantee they’ll get an uncompromised version of their superstar. If the injury happened in the field, moving Judge to designated hitter could quickly become part of the postseason plan.

Episode 755 - Mets Lose to Mr. 300 Pete Alonso | 'Rico Brogna' Sep 17, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso came through with a big game tying home run in the 9th inning at Citi-Field. Unfortunately, this time he was wearing a Baltimore Orioles jersey. It also just so happen to be his 300th home run of his career. The Mets still had opportunities to win, but instead a three run in the park home run by Coby Mayo sealed the Mets fate. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Wednesday Full Show: Pete Alonso Gets a Curtain Call Sep 16, 2026

Show notes

A curtain call was given to Pete Alonso and Evan is unhappy with Pete. Plus Wink Martendale throws shade at Brian Daboll, and much more in an abbreviated show

Wednesday Full Show: Alonso Curtain Call OUTRAGE, Yankees’ Cole Dilemma & Jets Make History Sep 16, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s curtain call has Evan Roberts HEATED, and the debate over Mets fans cheering his game-tying homer turns into a showdown with Tiki and Shaun Morash. Did Alonso rub it in, or did Steve Cohen and David Stearns bring this embarrassment on themselves? Plus, Sean Manaea’s comments spark another argument over how players view frustrated fans. The Yankees face a major October decision: should Gerrit Cole start against the Red Sox despite his struggles against Boston? Meanwhile, the Jets’ historic drive fuels excitement about their offense, and the Giants prepare for a prime-time test against the Rams. Plus, Wink Martindale takes a shot at Brian Daboll while praising Jaxson Dart. 00:00 Alonso Curtain Call Fight 12:52 Manaea Fires Back 38:31 Yankees Division Hopes 49:50 Wink Takes a Shot 1:01:47 Jets Make History 1:10:19 Knicks Banner Night 1:19:42 Gerrit Cole Playoff Debate 1:33:32 Cohen’s Broken Promise 1:49:37 Giants Respect Debate 1:56:52 Jets Playoff Dreams #WFAN #EvanAndTiki #Mets #Yankees #Jets #Giants

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected