Evan & Tiki

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Kyle Tucker out, Bo Bichette in Jan 17, 2026

This week's Mets highlights include all the reactions to Kyle Tucker signing with the Dodgers, and what it could mean for the future of baseball. Plus, instant reactions to New York's pivot of signing Bo Bichette to a three-year deal.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Harbaugh-Mania Jan 17, 2026

The Giants and John Harbaugh are close to finalizing a deal to make him their new head coach and Boomer & Gio are ecstatic for the franchise. Plus, Boomer & Gio on the behind-the-scenes action on how the Giants wined and dined Harbaugh (17:51); Evan & Tiki on why Harbaugh is a franchise-altering moment (25:49); Craig Carton and C-Mac have differing reactions to Harbaugh (43:38); C-Mac and Craig on why this hire feels different (1:09:03); Evan and Tiki on what it says about the Giants that Harbaugh chose them (1:24:44).

Kyle Tucker Signs With the LA Dodgers | 'WFAN Daily With Pete Hoffman' Jan 16, 2026

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): 4 years and $240 million dollars. The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Friday Full Show: The Mets Lose Tucker, Add Bichette, and a Rangers Letter Jan 16, 2026

A Football Friday is filled with a Mets roller coaster that starts sad, got happy with Bichette signing in show. Plus the Rangers warnt heir fans again.

Hour 1: Dodgers Don’t Miss, Mets Don’t Pivot | Evan’s Tucker Meltdown & MLB Conspiracy Jan 16, 2026

Tiki tries to keep it calm, Evan absolutely does not. Kyle Tucker is officially a Dodger, and the anger is not just about losing the player, it’s about how the Mets ended up stuck with no clear direction again. Evan breaks down why the Mets’ offer was real, why being “close” never matters against L.A., and how the Dodgers treat the luxury tax like pocket change. The conversation quickly turns into a full Mets identity crisis. No Pete Alonso, no obvious pivot, and spring training right around the corner. Calls pour in debating whether Tucker could survive New York, why stars keep choosing the Dodgers, and how the Mets are supposed to compete with Philly and Atlanta. Plus Evan drops a full conspiracy theory on Rob Manfred, MLB, and why the Dodgers dominating the sport might be exactly what the league wants.

Hour 2: Mets Pivot Season: Short-Term Cash, Long-Term Chaos Jan 16, 2026

With Kyle Tucker off the board, the Mets are staring into the void and Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is not a realistic “panic buy,” even with rumors of the Yankees sitting around five years and $160M. If the Mets wouldn’t go long for Tucker or Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras? Then the debate turns into the uncomfortable part: what’s the actual pivot? Evan pitches a wild, short-term, mega-AAV idea for Bo Bichette that’s basically a Tucker-style offer to blow him away, get an opt-out, and take another swing at free agency before 30. The problem: where does he play, and how much run prevention are you willing to sacrifice to get a real bat? Tiki pushes back on the defensive domino effect, the “versatility” trap, and the weekly second-guessing Mets fans would live through. The guys kick around the alternatives (including a one-year Eugenio Suárez power play), plus why pitching still has to be the priority no matter what. And of course, the segment ends with the same challenge: if you hate the plan, tell us a better one.

Hour 3: BREAKING Mets Sign Bo Bichette, Evan Takes a Victory Lap Jan 16, 2026

The show comes to a screeching halt with legitimate breaking news as the Mets land Bo Bichette on a three-year, $126 million deal, and Evan immediately reminds everyone he called the pivot before it happened. Evan and Tiki react in real time to the signing, the massive AAV, the opt-out structure, and what this move says about how David Stearns is operating in the market. They break down where Bichette fits defensively, why third base appears to be the early plan, and how much offensive ground this actually recovers after losing Pete Alonso and Kyle Tucker. The guys debate the risk of one-year and two-year opt outs, the surprising draft pick cost, and whether this is a necessary concession in today’s marketplace. Plus, what this move means for Philadelphia after reportedly agreeing to a long-term deal, how Toronto now pivots, why Cody Bellinger still does not make sense for the Mets, and whether this finally changes the tone of a chaotic Mets offseason. Live calls, instant reactions, and a full breakdown of how the roster and expectations shift after the biggest move yet.

Hour 4: Bo Bichette Fallout, Harbaugh Watch & a Friday Rangers Gut Punch Jan 16, 2026

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with New York sports chaos. Evan, Tiki, and Sean react to the Mets’ stunning pivot to Bo Bichette after missing on Kyle Tucker and officially closing the door on Pete Alonso. Giants fans remain on John Harbaugh watch as contract details drag on, while the guys debate what his leadership would mean for Big Blue. The hour takes a sharp emotional turn with the Rangers’ brutal Friday letter signaling a reset, sparking an all-time rant from Sean. Plus, Yankees offseason questions, AL East power rankings, NFL Divisional Round picks, and plenty of passionate fan calls to close out a wild Friday on WFAN.

Bo Bichette Changes Everything for the Mets Jan 16, 2026

The discussion opens with the moment Mets fans still argue about. Pete Alonso’s defensive mistake that altered an entire season and still hangs over his departure. Now the reality is unavoidable. Pete Alonso is gone, and the New York Mets are moving in a completely new direction. That direction comes into focus with the addition of Bo Bichette, a bold pivot after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys break down why the Mets moved fast, how Bichette reshapes the lineup, and why this roster feels unfamiliar from top to bottom. The bullpen is just as different, with Edwin Díaz out and Devin Williams stepping into a high pressure closer role. From the lineup to the ninth inning, this is a new Mets identity, and everyone is about to find out if that change actually works.

Mets Go All-In on Bo Bichette Jan 16, 2026

The Mets sign Bo Bichette, and immediately the word panic starts flying. Evan explains why the money is not the panic at all. The Mets were ready to spend even more on Kyle Tucker, and short-term premium contracts are clearly part of the plan. The real concern is the opt-out. Giving up draft pick compensation for a player who could walk after one season feels less like free agency and more like a deadline rental, something David Stearns has historically avoided. The conversation turns into a deep debate on whether one year of elite talent is worth the risk, how past Mets contracts like Carlos Beltrán shape fan perspective, and why even a move everyone likes can still carry a subtle sense of urgency. The guys also dive into roster ripple effects, including what this means for Brett Baty, the Mets’ trade flexibility, and how the upcoming CBA could impact Bichette’s opt-out decision. Mets fans and Yankees fans both weigh in as New York’s baseball balance of power continues to shift.

The Harbaugh Panic Meter Is Officially On Jan 16, 2026

The show spirals immediately. A little Giants contract paranoia. A little Mets panic even while liking the move. Absolute chaos in the booth as the phones light up, voices overlap, and Cinco energy takes over. Then it turns into a full rooting guide for the NFL playoffs. From old grudges to fresh annoyances, the guys count down the five easiest teams to root against this weekend. Rams, Broncos, Bills, Patriots, Seahawks, nobody is safe. Along the way there’s Giants coaching intrigue, Sam Darnold discourse, backup quarterback nightmares, and a reminder that New York fans never forget. Plus, the Mets land Bo Bichette while Kyle Tucker bolts for the Dodgers, setting up a massive day for both New York baseball teams. Loud, unhinged, and extremely opinionated.

BREAKING NEWS: Bo Bichette Is a New York Met! Jan 16, 2026

Evan and Tiki react in real time to the breaking news that the Mets have signed Bo Bichette, finally answering the biggest question of the offseason. After weeks of debating pivots, desperation, and whether the Mets would actually pull the trigger on a major bat, the move is real. They break down why the Mets chose Bichette, what it says about David Stearns and Steve Cohen, and how this signing fits into the bigger picture after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys debate where Bichette plays, how much the bat changes the lineup, and whether this move actually closes the gap with the league’s elite. Plus, immediate fan reaction, instant expectations, and the real pressure this puts on the rest of the offseason.

Steve Cohen’s “Smoke” Joke, and the Worst Sports Talk Crime Jan 16, 2026

It turns into an all-Rico day as Evan’s Kyle Tucker meltdown spills into the newsroom, the breaks, and basically the entire show. From there, the guys pivot to a throwback clip of Steve Cohen admitting he wants the Mets to model themselves after the Dodgers, and why that gap still feels massive beyond the farm system. Then the conversation swings to how Tucker’s decision can ripple to the Yankees with Cody Bellinger, including why Toronto suddenly looms as a real threat if they are willing to throw big years and money around. And because it’s New York sports radio, the segment closes with a true courtroom drama: Evan’s infamous “Edwin Díaz re-signed” line versus Craig Carton’s “I believe” Kyle Tucker guarantee. Who committed the bigger sports talk felony, and can “I believe” really save you when you were ready to take credit if you were right?

Why the Mets Won’t Get Desperate for Bellinger Jan 16, 2026

Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is simply not a realistic option for the Mets, even with the Yankees reportedly sitting around five years and $160 million. If the Mets refused to go long-term for Kyle Tucker or Pete Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras now? The discussion turns to what desperation would actually look like, why David Stearns and Steve Cohen are unlikely to abandon their principles, and why relying on the kids may be the real outcome if no clean pivot exists. The guys also agree that pitching should be the priority regardless, and explain why even missing on Tucker does not mean the Mets are about to hand out contracts they do not believe in.

Manfred Loves This: Dodgers Break Baseball Jan 16, 2026

Evan unloads a full conspiracy theory: Rob Manfred is not mad about the Dodgers dominating baseball, he’s thrilled. The idea is simple and terrifying. Let the Dodgers keep stacking stars, let fans scream “baseball is broken,” and then use that outrage to win the PR war for a salary cap the players will hate. Tiki buys it immediately, even as they admit it still might never work. From there, the focus snaps back to the Mets problem that keeps getting louder: they can “try” for Tucker, but where’s the backup plan? A caller compares Cashman’s quick Soto pivot to the Mets dragging their feet, and the guys dig into the bigger issue: Stearns will spend huge AAV, but refuses to go long term, which kills half the market. Then it turns into pure show chaos: Free Agent Bingo standings, Knicks misery, and Mets fans roasting the offseason, including a fake “Mets fan” troll call and the return of the “chomping at the bit” debate right before Evan teases a pivot plan that does not include Cody Bellinger.

Dodgers vs Everybody: Tucker’s Deal, Pitching Debates & Why Stars Always Pick L.A. Jan 16, 2026

Kyle Tucker’s $240 million deal with the Dodgers sparks a loaded fan debate. Calls flood in on whether Yoshinobu Yamamoto or Garrett Crochet is the better arm, and why the Mets came up short on both. Evan and Tiki break down what it really takes to beat the Dodgers in negotiations, why “being close” never works, and how absurd offers are now the baseline. The conversation turns emotional as Mets fans wrestle with a brutal question: did they dodge a bullet with Tucker, or was this another missed opportunity that only hurts because it feels familiar? There’s a deep dive into New York pressure, why stars thrive in L.A., and whether elite free agents truly want the Mets or just cannot say no to the Dodgers. By the end, one thing is clear: there are only a few teams at the top of the market, and right now, everyone else is playing catch up.

Tucker to the Dodgers Leaves Mets Fans Furious and Asking Now What Jan 16, 2026

The news Mets fans feared becomes reality as Kyle Tucker chooses the Los Angeles Dodgers over the New York Mets. Evan reacts with raw frustration, breaking down why this one hurts even though the Mets made a massive and legitimate offer. Tiki Barber explains why the Dodgers always win these battles, how their financial edge changes everything, and why no one should be surprised. The conversation turns from Tucker to the bigger picture as Evan questions the Mets’ offseason direction, the failure to replace Pete Alonso, and what the real pivot is with spring training approaching. Is this anger really about Tucker, or about the position the Mets have put themselves in? Plus a Winston Churchill inspired rally cry, and a brewing conspiracy involving MLB and Rob Manfred. A must listen for Mets fans trying to figure out where this team goes next and whether there is still a path to contention.

Countdown On Kyle Tucker, Miss on Ranger Suarez | 'Rico Brogna' Jan 16, 2026

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets up their offer to 4 years on Kyle Tucker. The only good news about Ranger Suarez not signing with the Mets is he's out of the NL East! Plus more news. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Thursday Full Show: Harbaugh Is a Giant Jan 15, 2026

We have full reaction to the news of John Harbaugh taking the Giants job as Head Coach. Plus, The Kyle Tucker rumors continue to swirl.

Hour 1: John Harbaugh Changes Everything for the New York Giants Jan 15, 2026

John Harbaugh to the Giants feels like the rare “everyone wanted him and you actually got him” moment, and the guys dive into why this hire is different from the team’s recent coaching cycles. They also give Joe Schoen credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job appealing enough for Harbaugh to skip other interviews entirely. Plus, the phones light up with fans debating Harbaugh vs. McCarthy, the “can a coach win a Super Bowl with two teams” question, and whether anyone owes an apology to ownership. Then the show pivots to a brutal Knicks loss, a Brunson ankle scare, and why the effort level (especially from KAT) had everyone boiling.

Hour 2: Harbaugh Brings a Championship Edge to NY and Dante Moore Shockwaves Jan 15, 2026

The guys go down a fascinating New York sports rabbit hole: how often does a coach or manager arrive here already owning a championship, and how rarely it actually turns into a title in New York. They land on Weeb Ewbank as the lone example of someone who won before coming to a New York team and then won again here, framing just how unique the John Harbaugh moment is for the Giants. Then the phones roll with Harbaugh hype, expectations for Year 1, and early buzz about what his staff could look like, including chatter around Todd Monken. The segment also takes a detour into classic New York fan trauma, comparing “can’t miss” celebrations (Nets Big 3, Rodgers to the Jets) to why the Giants situation feels different. And of course, the Jets can’t stay out of it: Dante Moore going back to school sparks a full blown debate about options, draft pressure, and what the organization should do at quarterback next.

Kyle Tucker is Not the Key Piece to Fixing the Mets Offseason | 'WFAN Daily With Pete Hoffman' Jan 15, 2026

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff explains his issues with David Stearns and how he's playing too many games during this off-season. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Hour 3: Giants Expectations Just Exploded! Jan 15, 2026

With a real head coach now in place, the entire Giants conversation shifts from “hope” to “expectation.” The guys debate what the floor actually is in 2026: simply a winning season, meaningful football in December, or a flat-out playoff mandate. They also dig into the reality of the NFC landscape, the pressure on Joe Schoen now that the “big hire” is done, and why some fans are setting the bar high while others are preaching patience. Plus, callers weigh in on whether this feels like a true turning point, and why Harbaugh should inspire more confidence than past “winning coaches” like Dan Reeves.

Hour 4: Giants Hire John Harbaugh + Kyle Tucker’s Massive Mets Decision Looms Jan 15, 2026

It’s a wild day in New York sports. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Giants hiring John Harbaugh as their next head coach and break down what it means for Big Blue moving forward. Plus, the guys dive deep into the Kyle Tucker sweepstakes, debating the Mets’ reported short-term mega offer versus Toronto’s long-term deal, whether Tucker is worth $50 million per year, and what decision makes the most sense for both the player and the Mets. Giants history, Mets roster construction, Yankees crossover fallout, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter all in one jam-packed segment on WFAN.

Mets Facing a Franchise-Altering Gamble Jan 15, 2026

The Mets are reportedly in with a massive short-term offer for Kyle Tucker, while Toronto looms with long-term security and the Dodgers lurk as a wildcard. The guys debate the core question every star free agent faces: take the absurd annual payday and bet on yourself, or lock in a decade of guaranteed money and never look back. They dig into whether Tucker is truly worth Juan Soto-level money, the risks of overpaying on a short deal, and why a ten-year commitment feels dangerous for the Mets. From roster construction to championship ceilings to quality-of-life considerations, this turns into a full breakdown of what Tucker should do, and what the Mets should be willing to live with if they miss out.

Cinco De Luncho: 5 Best Games at the Old Giants Stadium Jan 15, 2026

Cinco De Luncho takes center stage as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank the five greatest games ever played at the old Giants Stadium. From iconic playoff blowouts to unforgettable regular season moments, each list sparks debate, nostalgia, and plenty of arguing over what truly belongs in the top five. The conversation weaves through legendary wins, painful losses that shaped championships, and personal memories from the field and the stands. A full-on Giants history lesson with strong opinions, laughs, and classic sports radio chaos.

John Harbaugh Raises the Bar: Playoffs or Bust for the Giants? Jan 15, 2026

The Giants finally have a real head coach, and everything feels different. Evan, Tiki, and Sean debate how much the John Harbaugh hire should immediately raise expectations in Year 1. Is a winning season the floor, or is it fair to expect playoff contention right away? The guys dive into what this move means for Joe Shane, how tough the NFC really is, why meaningful football in December matters, and whether Giants fans should aim high or stay patient. One thing is clear: the bar has officially been raised in New York with John Harbaugh now leading the franchise.

Fans Are Sick of Being Told to Tank Jan 15, 2026

A passionate debate erupts over tanking, fandom, and what fans are actually supposed to root for in September and October. The guys argue whether it’s ever acceptable to cheer for losses, how draft position really changes franchises, and why fans should never be told to embrace losing. The conversation spills into Giants optimism under John Harbaugh, Jets misery, long term expectations, and whether New York sports fans are finally allowed to believe again or if that’s just asking to get burned.

Dante Moore’s Decision Is a Nightmare for the Jets Jan 15, 2026

A full blown Jets meltdown after Dante Moore decides to return to college. The guys debate why Moore staying in school actually hurts the Jets by taking options off the board, killing trade down possibilities, and increasing pressure on the front office to get quarterback right. What starts as a simple prediction check quickly turns into a heated argument about draft philosophy, organizational competence, and whether Jets fans are actually celebrating being saved from themselves.

Giants Finally Land a Champion in John Harbaugh Jan 15, 2026

The guys break down a wild stat that makes the John Harbaugh moment feel even bigger: the Giants almost never bring in a head coach who already has a Super Bowl on his resume, and across New York sports it’s surprisingly rare to land a proven champion and have it translate into titles here. That leads to the Weeb Ewbank deep dive as the lone example of a coach who won elsewhere and then won again with a New York team, plus a rapid fire debate over which sports even “count” in the conversation. Then the callers take over, mixing Harbaugh euphoria with classic New York superstition, including one fan reaching for “Giants were first to do this” trivia and the show pushing back with a simpler point: Harbaugh means consistent competence, yearly playoff contention, and eventually a real shot at a title. The segment also hits on 2026 expectations with Jaxson Dart entering Year 2, and why this feels different than other “can’t miss” New York celebrations like Aaron Rodgers to the Jets or the Nets superteam. The message is basically this: even if it doesn’t immediately end in a parade, Harbaugh can still be the turning point that drags the Giants out of the mud for the long haul.

Why John Harbaugh Picked the Giants and What It Says About the Franchise Jan 15, 2026

John Harbaugh did not just take the Giants job. He chose it. The guys explain why Harbaugh skipping other interviews is such a powerful signal about where the New York Giants are headed, and why this hire stands apart from past coaching cycles. They also dig into how Joe Schoen’s roster build and the drafting of Jaxson Dart helped make the Giants the most appealing destination on the board. From past misses to present momentum, this is the clearest case yet that the Giants finally got it right.

Giants Get Their Guy: Why John Harbaugh Is a Franchise Changing Hire Jan 15, 2026

The New York Giants finally land the coach everyone wanted. The guys break down why John Harbaugh choosing the Giants over every other opening is such a massive statement for the franchise, and why this cycle feels different from the last decade of misses. They also explain how Joe Schoen deserves real credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job irresistible for a Super Bowl winning head coach. From coaching failures of the past to why this move feels like a true turning point, this is why Giants fans have every reason to believe again.

Wednesday Full Show: Kyle Tucker to the Mets Picks up Steam, Harbaugh Hops on a Plane For Giant Land Jan 14, 2026

Kyle Tucker watch is underway while John Harbaugh finally leaves Maryland for Blue Sky's.

Hour 1: Kyle Tucker or Bust for the Mets + Harbaugh Lands in NYC Jan 14, 2026

The Mets offseason is at a tipping point, and Kyle Tucker is the one move that could change the entire mood. Evan and Tiki debate why Tucker would “save” the winter, why the Mets’ only real edge is money, and how David Stearns’ short-term, high-AAV philosophy is shaping everything after losing Pete Alonso. Then it turns into a wild New York sports morning: John Harbaugh meets with the Giants, fans call in on Tucker vs pitching help (Suarez, Valdez, Giolito), and the guys hit the Yankees’ under-the-radar Ryan Weathers trade before circling back to the big question: who’s the Mets ace right now? Chapters 00:00 Kyle Tucker “saves” the Mets offseason 03:20 Mets vs Dodgers vs Blue Jays and what actually matters 06:25 Trusting Stearns, roster “maybes,” and the first base frustration 14:00 Giants news: John Harbaugh meeting and the Tisch plane buzz 18:30 Calls: Tucker vs Suarez/Valdez, plus the rotation anxiety 35:15 Yankees add Ryan Weathers, then Giolito and the Mets “ace” debate

Hour 2: Giants Go All-In for John Harbaugh: “Don’t Let Him Leave the Building” Jan 14, 2026

The Giants finally get their face-to-face with John Harbaugh, and the debate turns into a full blown strategy session: is it better to go first and try to close immediately, or go last and land the final pitch? The guys size up the competition from Tennessee and Atlanta, including why both spots are way more appealing than fans want to admit. Plus, Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti’s brutally honest press conference becomes must-listen audio, from Harbaugh’s next move to Lamar’s role in the coaching search. Then the show hits a whirlwind of calls on everything from Brian Daboll’s next stop, the Jets’ draft options and quarterback chaos, to what a “successful” Mets offseason even means and why Kyle Tucker suddenly feels like a must.

Hour 3: Ian O’Connor: Giants “Out in Front” for Harbaugh and Why No Plan B Jan 14, 2026

The Athletic’s Ian O’Connor joins Evan and Tiki with the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting and why the Giants appear to be leading the race. Ian explains what today’s sit-down really means, why the face-to-face time with Joe Schoen matters most, and what Harbaugh is looking for when it comes to roster power and the quarterback plan. Then the conversation widens to the other suitors, including why Atlanta and Tennessee might come to Harbaugh instead of the other way around, plus the one “looming” team that could still complicate things. Ian also gives his current odds on Harbaugh landing with the Giants, and why money will not be the issue. Finally, it turns to Aaron Rodgers and what comes next, including the possibility of Minnesota, a fascinating GM “word salad,” and what it all signals about the Vikings’ quarterback direction. Oh, and yes, the show also finds time for an all-time Cinco de Lunch moment: the “salmonella vs semolina” bread confusion goes fully off the rails.

Hour 4: C-Mac Accused of a Crime Against Sportsmanity, Giants Continue to Court John Harbaugh Jan 14, 2026

In this 4th and final hour of the show, Evan accuses Chris McMonigle of a crime against his fanhood and all hell breaks loose. Also more on the John Harbaugh front.

Crime Against Sports Fan-Manatee:C-Mac Put On Trial! Jan 14, 2026

A full on courtroom breaks out on the show when allegations surface that coworker Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle coached his kid’s flag football team… as the Eagles… while wearing Kelly green. Sean serves as prosecutor and lays out the case for why a real Giants fan should refuse the Eagles assignment, rename the team, and never chant “Go Eagles” under any circumstances. Big Mac storms in to defend himself, arguing it was a league issued NFL Play 60 shirt, not real fandom, and that being a good dad matters more than jersey politics. The debate escalates into fantasy football hypocrisy, coaching fashion solutions, and Tiki delivering the final verdict: guilty. Evan agrees, says he would never wear the rival gear himself, and Big Mac leaves branded with the scarlet letter of a convicted sports fan manatee whenever he steps into their territory.

Evan vs Tiki: The Jets “Closed” Giants Stadium Fight Jan 14, 2026

A casual idea for tomorrow’s Cinco turns into a full blown argument when Evan and Tiki start debating the best games ever played at old Giants Stadium. Evan plants his flag on the Jets beating the Bengals in the final game at the building, Tiki roasts him for treating a glorified preseason as history, and the whole thing spirals into condescension, yelling, and an all time “I hope Harbaugh leaves” line. Then the Cinco de Lunch-o aftermath keeps rolling: Sean gets publicly assigned the show’s “L” on YouTube for the semolina vs salmonella disaster, the chat piles on, and a caller solves Evan’s late night PB&J problem in two seconds by diagnosing the real culprit: refrigerated peanut butter.

Cinco de Lunch-O Top 5 Sandwiches and the “Salmonella” Bread Mix Up Jan 14, 2026

Cinco de Lunch officially pivots away from football for the first time as Evan unveils his Top 5 Sandwiches of All Time and the studio immediately turns it into a food debate. The guys rank an Italian hero, grilled cheese, grilled chicken with roasted peppers and mozzarella, PB&J, and a turkey club, plus they argue the eternal question: does adding bacon change the name of the sandwich? It all peaks with an all time slip when “semolina” bread becomes “salmonella” bread live on air, leading to a full on correction, laughter, and a reminder of what you definitely do not want on your lunch.

Ian O’Connor: Giants in Front for John Harbaugh Jan 14, 2026

Veteran New York reporter Ian O'Connor joins Tiki and Evan to break down the most pivotal day in the New York Giants coaching search. O’Connor explains why the Giants are firmly out in front in the pursuit of John Harbaugh, why New York’s quarterback situation gives them an edge over Atlanta and Tennessee, and how today’s meeting could determine whether this saga ends quickly or drags on. Plus, why there is effectively no true Plan B, what could cause hesitation, and why this hire would be the biggest the Giants have made in decades.

Harbaugh In the Building: Giants Must Close Today, Jets Laugh Through Draft Chaos Jan 14, 2026

The Harbaugh watch hits peak intensity as reports say he’s flying in on a private plane and there’s a real chance he never leaves the Giants facility without a contract. The guys debate the nightmare scenario if he walks out and heads to Nashville or Atlanta, and why this is not a normal coaching search at all. It’s Harbaugh interviewing the Giants, not the other way around. Then the conversation swerves into Jets draft chaos with the Dante Moore declaration deadline, why more quarterback options is automatically good news for New York, and a classic argument over “old” takes suddenly becoming “new” again. Plus, callers jump in with Mets pressure, contract aging debates, and a brutally honest, comedy-heavy “if we ran the Giants and Jets” segment that turns into a wish list of grass fields, ticket freezes, and fan-friendly chaos.

Harbaugh Day: Giants Can’t Let Him Leave! Jan 14, 2026

The Giants finally get John Harbaugh in the building, and the whole hour turns into one question: is it better to get the first meeting and try to close immediately, or is “first” actually a disadvantage because Tennessee and Atlanta can sell him on everything after? The guys break down why Nashville feels like a legit destination, why Atlanta can outspend anybody, and why the Giants have to land the plane and finish the deal before Harbaugh even gets a chance to look around. Plus, a brutally honest Steve Bisciotti press conference adds fuel to the fire, including what he thinks Harbaugh needs most in his next job. Then the calls take over, from Jets frustration with Aaron Glenn to the quarterback reality check that could eliminate the Jets from the Harbaugh sweepstakes entirely.

The Kyle Tucker Debate Dividing Mets Fans Jan 14, 2026

Evan and Tiki open the phones and Mets fans go straight to the big question: if you can only make one marquee move, is it Kyle Tucker or a top arm like Ranger Suárez or Framber Valdez? Evan argues Tucker’s 162-game impact is bigger than any starter’s, even while admitting the rotation still screams for certainty. The conversation rolls into David Stearns’ short term, high AAV strategy, whether “connections” matter at all in free agency, and why the Dodgers are always lurking if money is close. Plus: the Pete Alonso fallout won’t go away, the “is $50M worth it?” camps battle, the Yankees finally make an under the radar move with Ryan Weathers, and a caller throws Lucas Giolito into the mix as the show debates what actually qualifies as a Mets ace right now.

Mets Need Kyle Tucker to Save This Offseason Jan 14, 2026

Mets fans are running out of patience, and it all comes down to one name. Evan and Tiki break down why signing Kyle Tucker would not make this a perfect offseason, but could absolutely save it. They dig into the bidding war with the Dodgers and Blue Jays, Steve Cohen’s willingness to flex financially, and David Stearns’ short term contract philosophy. Plus, why missing out on Tucker would leave the Mets banking on too many maybes, reopen the Pete Alonso wound, and make this offseason feel just as bleak as it did a month ago. Everything is on the line in the next 24 hours.

Tuesday Full Show: Mike Tomlin's Future in Question, Mets Flirt with Tucker Jan 13, 2026

Have we seen the end of Mike Tomlin as a coach in Pittsburgh and can that benefit the Jets? Plus the Mets are interested in Kyle Tucker and things are moving fast.

Hour 1: Is This the End for Mike Tomlin in Pittsburgh? Jan 13, 2026

The Steelers do it again: playoff game, offense disappears, season ends, and Steeler fans immediately want Mike Tomlin gone. The guys debate whether it’s actually Tomlin who might be ready to walk away, Sean Payton-style, take a TV break, and reset. They break down the never-ending Pittsburgh QB problem, why the timing makes a Giants move tough (contract and trade compensation), and why a one-year Tomlin hiatus could be a Jets fan’s dream scenario down the line. Plus, Aaron Rodgers’ early exit turns into a bigger conversation: what’s his next move, and has he stopped being the “difference-maker” at this stage of his career? The hour also hits the record-setting coaching vacancy chaos, fan reaction clips, and the bigger “great coach vs. postseason ceiling” debate.

Hour 2: Ranking the Biggest Threats to Steal John Harbaugh Jan 13, 2026

Hour 2 dives deeper into the John Harbaugh sweepstakes and asks the real question: who actually threatens the Giants most. The crew runs a “Pick 3” ranking of the top teams that could lure Harbaugh away, weighing roster appeal, quarterback situations, draft capital, cap space, and the one factor they keep coming back to: ownership stability. Atlanta’s reputation and leadership get a hard look, Cleveland is framed as the storm you monitor but do not fear, and Tennessee jumps into the conversation as a sneaky powerhouse threat with a young QB, a high pick, major cap room, and an intriguing roster base. Then it gets personal as Logan Ryan takes shots at Joe Shane, and the guys debate how much to trust criticism that might come from a bad breakup. Plus, a fun detour into what a “lunch meeting at Harbaugh’s house” should actually look like, a caller claims Tom Coughlin may have made a key outreach, and the hour spirals into Posted and Toasted, Al Dukes going viral over “F the Packers,” and a bigger argument about class, rivalries, and why fans love hearing their coach talk like a fan.

Hour 3: Coaching Carousel Bingo, and Rodgers Rips the “Hot Seat” Talk Jan 13, 2026

Hour 3 starts with a brutal scorecard check on the show’s MLB free agent predictions, as everyone whiffs on Alex Bregman landing with the Cubs. Then it turns into full-blown “Head Coach Vacancy Bingo,” with rapid-fire picks across the league and a heavy Giants focus as the crew debates John Harbaugh vs. Kevin Stefanski, plus the looming possibility of a Mike Tomlin breakup in Pittsburgh and who could replace him. The hour also features a troll-heavy “Aaron Rodgers 5 Greatest Career Accomplishments” list that spirals into a Jets expectations argument, followed by Rodgers’ postgame comments defending Mike Tomlin and taking shots at media “experts.” On the baseball side, the Mets get linked to a short, mega-AAV Kyle Tucker offer, then Jeff Passan’s report drops with Nolan Arenado finally getting traded. Plus, a classic Evan social moment: Sean Morash compared to a Cabbage Patch Kid, with the receipts. #EvanAndTiki #Giants #JohnHarbaugh #MikeTomlin #AaronRodgers #Jets #NFLCoachingCarousel #MLBHotStove #Mets #KyleTucker #NolanArenado #WFAN

Hour 4: Harbaugh Watch Continues On, Greg Roman Potential Giants OC? Jan 13, 2026

Listen to the 4th and final hour of this edition of the Evan and Tiki show.

Giants Put Mike McCarthy Under the Microscope Jan 13, 2026

With Mike McCarthy meeting the Giants, the crew plays out what the interview really needs to cover and what answers could actually change minds. The focus stays on McCarthy’s staff plan, how he would keep up defensively with modern offenses, and whether he can restore real on field accountability after too many Giants lapses. The conversation widens into full Harbaugh watch, with John Harbaugh framed as the Juan Soto of the coaching market and the clear prize everyone is waiting on. Calls weigh in on how Giants fans would react to a McCarthy hire, fears of settling if Harbaugh goes elsewhere, and what kind of staff Harbaugh would build for a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart. The segment also veers into a heated debate on teams threatening season ticket holders over secondary market sales, with Evan arguing it is unfair for long suffering fans to take losses for years and then get blocked from finally making money back when a team gets good.

Mets Chase Kyle Tucker Jan 13, 2026

The Mets are making a real push for Kyle Tucker, with reports of a massive short term, high AAV offer that fits David Stearns and Steve Cohen’s recent roster philosophy. The crew debates whether the Mets can actually beat out the Dodgers or Blue Jays, and why Tucker might prefer a short deal to reenter a thin future free agent market.

Cinco de Luncho: Rodgers 5 Greatest Accomplishments Jan 13, 2026

Shaun Morash fires up full Cinco de Luncho mayhem, sending the booth into total chaos with yelling, laughing, and a runaway bumper. The show then pivots to Aaron Rodgers and the strangest possible retirement scenario: he quietly disappears without ever officially announcing he’s done, while nobody even knows who he married.

Coaching Carousel Bingo! Jan 13, 2026

Evan and Tiki pull out the “prediction desk” to grade their MLB free agent picks and immediately take an L: everyone misses on Alex Bregman, who signs with the Cubs. The scoreboard gets updated, the slow-burn MLB offseason gets roasted, and then the show pivots hard into “NFL Head Coach Free Agent Bingo.” They fire off early predictions for the Browns, Raiders, and Titans, with names like Mike McCarthy, Jim Schwartz, Brian Flores, Jesse Minter, Joe Brady, and Matt Nagy getting tossed around. The segment crescendos into the Giants debate, where the crew lines up on John Harbaugh vs. Kevin Stefanski and what each hire would mean for the franchise moving forward.

Posted & Toasted and Ben Johnson Says “F the Packers” Jan 13, 2026

A brand-new Posted and Toasted kicks off with a rapid-fire trip through old takes and wild questions, including “Who leaves the Chargers first, Justin Herbert or Jim Harbaugh?” and a flashback to harsh Harbaugh slander that did not exactly age well. Then the segment turns into a full-blown debate after Al Dukes posts a viral complaint about Ben Johnson’s “F the Packers” moment. Tiki is genuinely annoyed, Evan defends rivalry heat, and the guys argue whether fans actually want more personality from coaches or more “class.” It gets even better when the show plays Ben Johnson’s response and he basically refuses to apologize, leaning into the rivalry. Add in a side quest about “skinny fat,” the YouTube chat judging Evan’s belly, and the whole thing becomes classic chaos.

Giants on Harbaugh Watch Jan 13, 2026

The Giants’ coaching search heats up as the guys rank the top three teams that could realistically steal John Harbaugh away from New York. Cleveland is framed as the storm you monitor but do not fear, Atlanta’s ownership and reputation put them firmly in the mix, and Tennessee emerges as the surprise heavyweight with cap space, draft capital, and a quarterback Harbaugh might actually prefer. The conversation shifts from fan logic to what truly matters in these decisions: ownership stability, roster flexibility, control, and long-term vision. Logan Ryan’s blunt criticism of Joe Shane sparks debate over bias versus truth, while callers weigh in on Tom Coughlin’s reported outreach and whether behind-the-scenes relationships could help close the deal. Plus, the show takes a hilarious detour into what really happens at a coach recruiting lunch, who should bring the food, and why stadium talk might be nothing more than noise.

Fire Drury Chants, Tomlin Tremors and Evan’s Rodgers Takedown Jan 13, 2026

The NFL coaching carousel might be headed for history: the guys note the league could be staring at a record number of head coach openings if Pittsburgh joins the party. Then the show pivots into full New York sports pain, with the Rangers getting buried, “Fire Drury” chants, and the Nets openly tanking. After that, it’s Steelers fan therapy time. They play viral fan reactions that range from blaming Arthur Smith to blaming the crowd itself, then get into the uncomfortable part: if Pittsburgh moves on from Tomlin, are there even enough legit candidates to replace a guy who never has a losing season? The debate turns into a bigger sports question: when you’re sick of the ceiling, is blowing it up worth the risk? The hour finishes with a sharp breakdown of Aaron Rodgers’ sideline blowups and why it hits differently when you have not earned years of trust in a locker room. Jets perspective, Steelers perspective, and the brutal truth about disappointment all collide.

Mike Tomlin Finally Done in Pittsburgh? Jan 13, 2026

Another January, another familiar ending in Pittsburgh. The Steelers bow out early, the offense goes silent, and Steeler fans immediately turn their frustration toward Mike Tomlin. But the conversation shifts to a more uncomfortable question: what if Tomlin is the one who’s ready to move on? The guys break down the post Ben Roethlisberger quarterback void, the never-ending coordinator carousel, and why the Steelers’ constant playoff appearances may actually be trapping them in mediocrity. They explore the Sean Payton comparison, the idea of Tomlin stepping away to reset, and why that scenario could quietly benefit the Jets while complicating things for the Giants. Plus, Aaron Rodgers’ latest playoff exit raises real questions about his future and whether this version of Rodgers can still lift a team when it matters most.

Maybe Evan Is Wrong About Kyle Tucker | 'Rico Brogna' Jan 13, 2026

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Is Evan totally wrong about the Mets going after Kyle Tucker? Plus, the rumored trade for Edward Carera. Alex Bregman fall out, Yankees out on Cody Bellinger and how it impacts the Mets. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: A Wild-Wild Card Weekend Jan 12, 2026

The Giants get good news out of Green Bay, plus a full recap of perhaps the greatest Wild Card Weekend ever

Hour 1: LaFleur Fallout, Harbaugh Hold-Up, and Wild Card Weekend Chaos Jan 12, 2026

Wild Card Weekend had everything, including one brutal Packers collapse that had everyone wondering if Matt LaFleur could actually be in trouble. Then Adam Schefter pours water on it with a new contract expectation, and Evan and Tiki connect the dots to the coaching carousel and why John Harbaugh might be the one move that freezes everything else. The guys hit the Sirianni vs AJ Brown sideline blowup, what Philly’s loss really means, and why Giants fans can probably relax about certain “new” vacancies. Then they dive into the Bills vs Jaguars finish and the debate that took over sports bars everywhere: kneel at the 1 and bleed clock, or take the touchdown and trust your defense? Plus, the end-of-half officiating mess that almost became the story of the week. Also in Hour 1: why the Jets feel like they’re playing a different sport after watching playoff football, what makes the Patriots defense so hard to diagnose, and Tony Romo’s all time confusing broadcast moment that had everyone asking, “What game are you watching?”

Hour 2: Bregman Bomb During Bears-Packers, Jets Misery, and Playoff Chaos Calls Jan 12, 2026

Hour 2 starts with one of the strangest timing moments you’ll hear all season: the Bears are in the middle of an epic home playoff comeback against the Packers when news breaks that the Cubs are stunningly signing Alex Bregman. Evan and Tiki debate how a city even processes a massive baseball move during the biggest football night in years, plus a Barstool meltdown from the Boston side of the deal. Then the calls take over, starting with a deep dive into the modern fourth down obsession and the Jaguars decision to pass up points against Buffalo, especially after being gifted field position. The guys break down why “take the points” still matters in January and how one empty possession can flip a playoff game. The hour also hits the Jets fan reality check after watching real playoff football, the quarterback trade up fantasies, and why one Fernando Mendoza quote might have ended Jets dreams on the spot. Plus: the Liam Cohen press conference moment that has media people furious, a debate on whether a reporter can be supportive, and a round of playoff hot takes including which coaches are easiest and hardest to root for.

Hour 3: Wild Card Weekend Delivered and the Jets Are Still Miserable Jan 12, 2026

Hour 3 opens with the biggest win of Wild Card Weekend: the games were awesome, competitive, and for once the NFL escaped without a single officiating disaster hijacking the conversation. Evan and Tiki love that the storyline stayed on football, and they argue the league feels completely wide open, with guaranteed new blood headed to the Super Bowl. The guys then hit the funniest “info win” from the weekend, including a bizarre baseball stat tied to a Bills defender that somehow becomes a running joke for Buffalo’s playoff run. Calls follow on how to combat tanking in the NFL, Buffalo’s chances on the road, and why the Bills’ path is brutal even if the vibes feel like “this is their year.” Then it turns into full Jets fan pain as Evan lays out the nightmare remaining AFC field, debates what would hurt Jets fans most, and gets pulled into a Justin Herbert discussion: is he overrated or just stuck with no help? The hour also includes Cinco de Luncho ranking the Wild Card games, Yankees anxiety over Cody Bellinger, Mets hopes for Kyle Tucker, and a darkly hilarious Jets Super Bowl timeline that spirals all the way into the distant future.

Hour 4: LOL Jets, Wild Card Weekend Fallout & Making the Final Pick Jan 12, 2026

Evan & Tiki close out the show with a wide-ranging and emotional final hour, headlined by Evan’s raw rant on why it’s never been more depressing to be a Jets fan. The guys dive into the “LOL Jets” stigma, Davante Adams’ unnecessary shade, and whether the franchise is miles behind the rest of the AFC. Plus, a spirited debate on whether fans can (or should) ever abandon their team, stories about long playoff droughts, and why winning after decades of pain just hits different.

A Brutal Weekend Reminder of How Far the Jets Lag Behind Jan 12, 2026

After a weekend of playoff football, Evan and Tiki hit the harshest reality for Jets fans. The Patriots look sharp, Drake May is already being talked about like a future MVP, and Josh Allen is still standing in the AFC. The question becomes brutally simple: can the Jets realistically find a quarterback who can go toe to toe with those two in the division? The guys rip into the gap between the Jets and the best coached playoff teams, debate Aaron Glenn’s future, and react to a perfectly timed shot from an Amazon Prime pregame clip that sums up the Jets’ current reputation. Then the punchline arrives: the Jets announce a futures deal with Bailey Zappe, turning the whole situation into peak “are we being trolled?” energy. It’s Jets despair, league wide trolling, and the uncomfortable truth that nothing changes until the Jets start winning.

Yankees, Bellinger, and Boras Playing Contract Chicken Jan 12, 2026

While Wild Card Weekend dominated the headlines, a major MLB bomb dropped in the background. The New York Yankees are now operating under the assumption that Cody Bellinger could sign elsewhere as contract talks stall over years, not dollars. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down the reported standoff with Scott Boras, why the Yankees are refusing to negotiate against themselves, and why this situation feels eerily similar to what the New York Mets dealt with last year. The conversation pivots to potential fallback options, including interest around Kyle Tucker, the realities of short term high AAV deals, and why teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers and Toronto Blue Jays loom large in the background. Plus, a deeper debate on free agency leverage, market reality, and why Yankee fans may want to stay calm as this staring contest plays out.

Cinco de Luncho Ranks the Best Games of Wild Card Weekend Jan 12, 2026

Cinco de Luncho takes over the booth as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank every game from an unforgettable Wild Card Weekend. From the snoozer at the bottom of the list to an epic rivalry comeback at the top, the guys debate what actually makes a playoff game great. Is it the ending, the full three hour ride, the stakes, or the atmosphere? They break down Chargers vs Patriots, 49ers vs Eagles, Bills vs Jaguars, Rams vs Panthers, and the emotional roller coaster between the Packers and Bears. The discussion turns into a full blown argument over best ending versus best overall game, DVR watching versus live chaos, and why some games get punished just for kickoff time or location. Pure sports radio energy, food jokes included, as Cinco de Luncho delivers the definitive Wild Card Weekend rankings.

The NFL Is Wide Open and Wild Card Weekend Proved It Jan 12, 2026

Wild Card Weekend delivered exactly what fans have been begging for. Close games, real drama, and no officiating controversy stealing the spotlight. Evan and Tiki break down why the biggest win of the weekend was actually talking about football again, not refs or rule debates. They dive into the wide open feel of the NFL, debate the legacies of Josh Allen and Justin Herbert, and explain why this postseason feels different from the dynasty driven years dominated by Kansas City and New England. The conversation shifts to belief and perspective for struggling franchises, including why fans of the New York Giants

Jags Reporter BREAKS All the Rules With Wild Postgame Pep Talk Jan 12, 2026

With the coaching carousel settling for now, the spotlight unexpectedly shifts to Jacksonville after the Jaguars’ playoff loss to Buffalo. A local reporter steps to the mic and skips the question entirely, offering Liam Cohen a heartfelt pep talk instead, and the media world erupts. Evan and Tiki find the moment funny, human, and completely overblown as a controversy. They push back on the outrage from fellow reporters, arguing there’s room for empathy as long as the tough questions still get asked, and imagine what the New York version of that moment would sound like if the Jets ever won 13 games. The conversation then spills into the Bills-Jaguars finish, revisiting the score versus kneel debate at the goal line, the fear of false starts and bad snaps, and why trusting your defense still makes sense in today’s NFL. Plus, calls on playoff officiating, pocketed flags in January, and a walk down memory lane with Giants fans reliving the most painful postseason losses of their lifetime.

Jags Gamble Backfires and Jets QB Dreaming Jan 12, 2026

A Bears-Packers playoff comeback is already chaos, then Chicago gets a second shockwave mid-game: news leaks that the Cubs are signing Alex Bregman. Evan and Tiki debate how any fan is supposed to process a blockbuster baseball move during the biggest football moment in years, plus why good news can wait but bad news hijacks your brain instantly. Then the show pivots back to the NFL with a caller hammering the league’s new addiction: going for it on fourth down. The guys break down the Jaguars’ pivotal decision to pass up points against Buffalo, why it felt even worse after a gifted short field, and how one empty possession can swing a playoff game. From there it turns into full Jets fan therapy. Calls flood in with trade-up fantasies for Fernando Mendoza, reality checks on what it would actually cost, and the clip that sent Jets hopes into a spiral when Mendoza names Tom Brady as his dream dinner guest. Plus: a debate on Ben Johnson’s “talking spicy” persona, whether he’s hard to root for, and why Sean McVay is the easy choice when likability becomes part of the playoff rooting chart.

Score or Kneel? Josh Allen Debate + Romo Goes Off the Rails Jan 12, 2026

Evan and Tiki open the phones on the Giants coaching search, but the conversation quickly pivots to the most entertaining game of Wild Card Weekend: Bills vs Jaguars. After Josh Allen’s ridiculous late push, the classic barstool argument erupts at the goal line. Do you take a knee at the 1 and bleed clock, or punch in the touchdown and trust your defense? Evan says it’s simple: if you need a touchdown, you take the touchdown, because nothing is guaranteed in the red zone. The crew debates the value of those 30 extra seconds, the risk of giving away a down, and why Buffalo’s past “13 seconds” trauma still hangs over every late game decision. Then the calls roll in, including a furious breakdown of a chaotic end of half sequence that nearly handed Jacksonville points and could have changed the entire game if the kick was made. And to top it off, Evan unloads on Tony Romo’s bizarre broadcast, from head scratching commentary to a moment where Romo somehow convinced himself a clear Josh Allen touchdown might not count.

LaFleur Survives, But Harbaugh Freezes the Carousel Jan 12, 2026

The Packers melt down in an all time ugly loss to the Bears, and for a minute it feels like Matt LaFleur could actually be in trouble. Then Adam Schefter drops the update: Green Bay expects a new deal, and the conversation flips from “fire him” to “what if the contract talks get weird?” From there, Evan and Tiki zoom out to the Giants’ view of Wild Card Weekend and why it didn’t create any scary new openings. The real issue is the same one it’s been: the entire coaching market is basically stuck until John Harbaugh makes his move, with teams like the Giants and Browns convinced they have a shot. They debate the reported Harbaugh price tag, why the top coach available is going to push for top dollar, and how LaFleur’s postseason résumé has taken hits despite regular season success. Plus: Schefter’s “Packers connection” to Harbaugh, why it’s interesting but not needle moving, and what would actually make Green Bay a real threat if a vacancy somehow opened up.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: A Look Into the Future Jan 11, 2026

Boomer & Gio on why the Oregon-Indiana College Football Playoff semifinal could shed more light on the Jets’ quarterback future. Plus, Craig Carton sounds off on Aaron Glenn’s arrogance (9:43); Carton and C-Mac also take calls on the Jets and discuss Breece Hall’s future (29:45); Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash listen to Glenn and GM Darren Mougey and react to their answers (45:41)

Best of the Giants on WFAN: What If It’s Not Harbaugh? Jan 11, 2026

Craig Carton warns Giants fans not to crown John Harbaugh as the next head coach just yet. Plus, Boomer & Gio raise the possibility of the Eagles or Bills pursuing Harbaugh (22:57); Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash discuss the risks of going all in on Harbaugh and other coaches who could emerge (33:07); Tiki Barber argues he’d rather have Kevin Stefanski over Harbaugh (52:57); Craig and C-Mac on Stefanski sighting in New Jersey (1:10:00); Gio makes the case for Stefanski prior to Harbaugh news (1:25:20)

Best of interviews on WFAN: James Dolan and Rob Manfred Jan 10, 2026

This week's highlights include James Dolan in studio with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to talk all things Knicks and Rangers, while MLB commissioner Rob Manfred also paid them a visit. Plus, Blueshirts legend Mark Messier in studio with Boomer and Gio, and Joe Benigno joined Evan and Tiki for a classic Jets rant.

Best of the Knicks on WFAN: Still NBA Finals or bust Jan 10, 2026

This week's Knicks highlights include James Dolan's extensive in-studio interview with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and the guys reacting to the interview and Dolan's expectations for this team. Plus, both Evan Roberts and Tommy Lugauer don't think there should be much concern with the team's recently-halted four-game losing streak.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Go Get Harbaugh Jan 10, 2026

Craig Carton shares breaking news that John Harbaugh is now available on the coaching market, much to the delight of C-Mac. Plus, SNY’s Connor Hughes delivers the latest on the Giants pursuit of Harbaugh (17:33); Evan & Tiki analyze Harbaugh’s playoff resume and hear from callers (39:31); Boomer & Gio on what Harbaugh needs to hear from the Giants front office (58:28), and what his staff could look like (1:15:11); Craig and C-Mac on what Giants need to do to secure Harbaugh (1:30:21).

Friday Full Show: The Giants Get Fishy Harbaugh news, Wild Card Weekend Preview Jan 09, 2026

The Dolphins make a GM decision that eases Giants fans worries, plus a Football Friday playoff edition with all the trimmings.

Hour 1: Giants Coaching Search Turning Into “Harbaugh Or Disappointment” Jan 09, 2026

The Giants coaching search hits a fever pitch as the show debates why it suddenly feels like John Harbaugh is the one hire that changes everything, and why missing out could trigger a full fan meltdown. Evan and Tiki break down the Dolphins GM curveball, what it means for Harbaugh’s options, and why Kevin Stefanski is still a real long-term alternative. Plus, Giants fans call in on ownership, Joe Schoen’s role in the search, wild record predictions for next season, and the viral Jaxson Dart lip-reading moment that has everyone trying to decode the future.

Hour 2: Evan’s “Banned” Manfred Question, MLB Realignment and How Well Does Tiki Know Tiki? Jan 09, 2026

Hour 2 starts with the mystery of Evan’s pre-recorded question for MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred that never made air, and the behind-the-scenes explanation from Craig Carton on why it got spiked. The guys finally reveal the question, argue whether it was fair or “too much,” and debate Manfred’s obsession with a salary cap and the financial gap between big and small markets. Then the conversation turns into full MLB confusion as Manfred talks realignment, geography, and keeping the Mets and Yankees separate, and nobody can quite agree on what he actually meant. Calls roll in to interpret it, while Evan vents about owners crying “unable” instead of “unwilling” to spend. Plus, the show pivots to Wild Card weekend storylines, including how often teams win rematches, and a fun deep dive into Tiki Barber’s playoff games where he faced an opponent for the third time in the same season. The hour also touches on the Giants coaching search optics, Evan’s choice between banishing Woody Johnson or Rob Manfred, and a Yankees offseason debate about Cody Bellinger’s market and whether Brian Cashman should pivot to Bo Bichette.

Hour 3: NFL Playoff Rooting Interests, Coaching Chaos + Cinco de Luncho Jan 09, 2026

It’s Wild Card Weekend, so we’re playing the most dangerous game: who are we selfishly rooting for and why. The guys go matchup by matchup with Jets and Giants agendas all over the place, from hoping Carolina creates Bryce Young doubt (hello, Jets QB options) to rooting for pure chaos in Bears-Packers if it means more coaching openings. They also hit Bills-Jaguars, Eagles-Niners (and the John Harbaugh fear factor), plus the Patriots as the ultimate “please lose” postseason villain. Then it turns into full New York sports radio perfection: Cinco de Luncho takes over, Evan’s brain gets exposed, and the crew reacts to the Saquon Barkley billboard shot at Giants fans on I-95. Hour 3 also dips into Knicks/Wizards draft-pick drama, Giants coordinator continuity talk (Kafka, Dart development), and a college QB watch that turns tonight’s game into a Jets scouting mission. Key moments: rooting-interest power rankings, Giants coaching search circus, Saquon billboard outrage, Cinco de Luncho, and the phones lighting up with callers.

Hour 4: Could Trinidad Chambliss be the Next Jets QB? WFAN Jeopardy Controversy Jan 09, 2026

Hour 4: Could Trinidad Chambliss be the Next Jets QB? WFAN Jeopardy Controversy

The Mets Skipped FanFest! Jan 09, 2026

The Mets choose not to hold FanFest, and the optics could not be worse. The guys break down why skipping a fan event makes the organization look scared of its own fans, especially when there is nothing new to celebrate. Outside of modest moves, nothing about this roster feels better than it did months ago, and fans can feel it. The conversation then pivots to the New York football picture, including Antonio Pierce emerging as a legitimate sleeper candidate in the New York Giants head coaching search if it is not John Harbaugh or Kevin Stefanski. From there, the show spirals into classic chaos, Cinco de Lunch energy, Wild Card Weekend rankings, draft obsession, quarterback scouting madness, and the brutal reality that most fans watch sports through selfish rooting interests. It is part Mets frustration, part Giants coaching intrigue, and part unhinged Friday sports radio at its finest, with food debates, cheese takes, and playoff chaos layered on top.

We’re Rooting for Absolute Playoff Chaos Jan 09, 2026

The guys kick off Wild Card Weekend by laying out their “selfish rooting interest” list, where Jets bitterness, Giants coaching paranoia, and pure chaos all collide. It starts with Rams-Panthers and a very specific agenda: hope Carolina’s Bryce Young doubt grows just enough to create more QB options for the Jets, while also keeping the Panthers from becoming a real future threat. Then it turns into Bears-Packers, where personal grudges (Ben Johnson), weather talk, and the dream of a coaching-search circus take center stage. If the Packers lose, does it crack open another job and send the league into full-blown coach chaos? That’s the debate. They hit Bills-Jaguars with the “maximum pain” theory for Buffalo fans, plus the Harbaugh ripple effects in Eagles-Niners, before the segment swerves into the Saquon billboard drama that feels like a direct shot at Giants fans. The back half includes Knicks-Wizards draft-pick paranoia, Giants OC continuity talk (Kafka and the Dart development angle), and a mini debate on why you can’t blindly trust AI without fact-checking.

Evan’s Manfred Question Gets Spiked Jan 09, 2026

Evan explains how he was promised a chance to ask Rob Manfred a question on the air, only to have it pulled at the last second for being “too disrespectful.” The show finally reveals the question about a salary cap, debates whether it crossed the line, and argues if it would have forced a real answer from the commissioner. Craig Carton explains why it never aired, while Tiki Barber compares his version of a Manfred question to how it was actually asked on the show. The segment then spirals into total confusion when Manfred discusses MLB realignment, geography, and keeping the New York Yankees and New York Mets out of the same division. Evan and Tiki try to decode what he actually meant, whether MLB is moving toward an East vs West conference model, and why the explanation left more questions than answers. The segment wraps with listener calls, World Baseball Classic timing debates, and breaking news that Ketel Marte is not being traded after weeks of rumors.

Jets Can’t Gamble On Harbaugh, Giants Still Can Jan 09, 2026

Evan takes the unpopular stance with Jets fans: you can’t fire Aaron Glenn after one season just to take a blind swing at John Harbaugh, especially when Harbaugh isn’t committing to anybody and might even consider taking a year off. That’s why Schefter’s reporting matters, and why the Dolphins were able to play it differently since they were already on the fence with Mike McDaniel. The conversation then flips back to the Giants, where the urgency is real, the fan base is locked onto one name, and the stakes feel enormous if ownership can’t close the deal. Calls roll in on whether Mara and Tisch need to directly recruit Harbaugh, what Joe Schoen’s role really is, and why being “Harbaugh or bust” might be unfair, but also totally inevitable.

Giants Fans Are Getting Set Up For Harbaugh… Or A Meltdown Jan 09, 2026

The Giants coaching search has reached the point where it feels like one name is towering over everyone else: John Harbaugh. Evan explains why this has become a “massive disappointment” situation if the Giants don’t land him, even if the replacement is a proven coach like Kevin Stefanski or Mike McCarthy. Tiki pushes back with a reality check: Harbaugh could want a break, he might not want a rebuild, and nothing is guaranteed. The big question becomes simple: are Giants fans being reasonable… or is this officially turning into Harbaugh or heartbreak?

Hibernating For the Winter | 'Rico Brogna' Jan 08, 2026

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The offseason is extremely slow moving. Even with it dragging, it feels like the direction is not going the right way for Mets fans. Evan takes you through all the latest rumors and where the Mets stand. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Thursday Full Show: John Harbaugh Mania Continues Jan 08, 2026

Tiki is back and prefers Stefanski to Harbaugh. Mike McDaniel gets fired in show leading to more Harbaugh speculation.

Hour 1: Tiki Picks Stefanski Over Harbaugh for Giants HC Jan 08, 2026

Hour 1 kicks off with the Giants coaching search heating up fast. With names like Bill Belichick floating out there, Tiki Barber drops a stunner: he’d lean Kevin Stefanski over John Harbaugh. The guys debate QB development, offensive upside, and why building the right staff might matter even more than the head coach. Plus, the “sure thing vs bust factor” argument, Harbaugh’s coordinator track record, and the one concern that could change everything: does Harbaugh still have the fire for a full rebuild in New York?

Hour 2: Joe Schoen “Underpaid” Flex, Harbaugh Rumors Collide, and Belichick’s Next Move Jan 08, 2026

Hour 2 opens with some off the rails concert and weekend planning before the show snaps back to Giants business. The guys react to Joe Schoen basically bragging about how “cheap” the Giants’ core is, and debate if that’s smart roster building or a quote that could annoy his best players. Then it turns into full Harbaugh madness: why the Giants can’t assume anything, what factors really drive a coach’s decision, and the conflicting reports from the league’s biggest insiders on what actually happened in Baltimore. Plus, the Joe Schoen question hangs over everything, fans fear it could cost the Giants Harbaugh, and the crew makes official date and time predictions for when the Giants finally hire their next head coach. They wrap with Belichick talk, skepticism about his “I’m happy at North Carolina” line, and a larger debate about age, perception, and whether one recent coaching flop changed the market for older legends.

Hour 3: Super Bowl Picks Go Off the Rails, Giants Coaching Panic, and a Pre–Labor Day School Revolt Jan 08, 2026

Hour 3 spirals fast as the guys revisit their preseason Super Bowl predictions and realize just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field really is. Updated picks get bold and uncomfortable with Jacksonville, Seattle, and Buffalo all in the mix, while trust in the NFC completely collapses. The conversation shifts back to the Giants coaching search, fan fear over “settling” for Kevin Stefanski, and Rex Ryan questioning whether Stefanski belongs in the elite tier. Tiki pushes back with a strong case for crisis management and leadership in New York. The hour ends with a full Northeast parent meltdown when the crew learns school may start before Labor Day, triggering boycott talk, PTA outrage, and an all time relatable rant.

Hour 4: Evan & Tiki Talks Public School Chaos, Evan's 1 Question For Manfred Jan 08, 2026

The 4th and final hour of the Evan & Tiki Show

Question for Rob Manfred That Could Change Baseball Jan 08, 2026

The crew debates the one question every baseball fan would want to ask Rob Manfred. The conversation dives into the widening financial gap in Major League Baseball, whether teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers are exploiting the system, and why a true salary cap could blow up the sport all over again. From fears of another labor war to the idea that would hit New York fans hardest, the possibility of the New York Yankees and New York Mets eventually sharing a division, this segment breaks down what really matters, what Manfred will never say out loud, and why one honest answer could change baseball’s future overnight.

Parents Revolt After NYC Schools Cross the Line Jan 08, 2026

Parents officially lose it after learning New York schools are starting before Labor Day. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun react in real time to the calendar shocker, threaten a full-scale parent boycott, and argue why the Northeast has one sacred rule you do not break. The conversation spirals into vacation chaos, NFL timing, snow days that never happen, and why this decision feels like a direct attack on families who plan their lives around that final summer week.

Giants Coaching Anxiety Explodes Jan 08, 2026

The crew revisits their preseason Super Bowl predictions and quickly realizes how wrong almost everyone was, highlighting just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field feels. Buffalo, Philly, Baltimore, Kansas City, and Green Bay all get put under the microscope as old picks get roasted and eliminated. From there, the discussion pivots to bold updated predictions, with Jacksonville, Seattle, the Rams, and Buffalo emerging as trendy and uncomfortable new favorites. The segment closes with a heated Giants coaching debate, as fans panic over the idea of Kevin Stefanski being the answer, Rex Ryan openly questions his résumé, and Tiki fires back with a strong defense centered on crisis management and surviving dysfunction in New York.

Is Bill Belichick Officially Done? Jan 08, 2026

The guys put their reputations on the line by predicting the exact date and time the Giants’ next head coach will be reported by Schefter or Rapoport, not the press conference, the real breaking news moment. From there, the conversation swerves into a brutal reality check on Bill Belichick. Is the greatest resume in NFL history suddenly irrelevant? They dissect why the phone might not be ringing anymore, how Pete Carroll’s one and done stint changed league perception, and why age suddenly feels like a bigger factor than anyone wants to admit. Then it turns into a wide ranging debate on Harbaugh vs McCarthy, playoff failures, coaching “stench,” and whether history actually matters when hiring a Super Bowl caliber head coach.

Did Joe Schoen Just Expose the Giants? Jan 08, 2026

What starts as a lighthearted detour into concert plans and feeling old quickly turns serious once Joe Schoen’s latest comments hit the table. The guys debate whether Schoen basically admitted the Giants’ best players are underpaid and if that kind of honesty helps roster building or risks irritating the locker room. From there, the conversation pivots back to John Harbaugh and why his decision may come down to far more than roster strength, including lifestyle, geography, and even old family ties to Cleveland. The segment heats up with conflicting reports from Ian Rapoport and Adam Schefter on whether Harbaugh truly lost the Ravens locker room, and Tiki explains why both sides can actually be true. The hour closes with mounting fan anxiety that retaining Joe Schoen could cost the Giants their dream coach and shape the narrative around this hire no matter how it ends.

McDaniel Hits the Market: OC Gold Jan 08, 2026

The coaching carousel gets even crazier when Mike McDaniel suddenly becomes available, and the guys immediately frame him as a potential offensive coordinator jackpot, not the Giants head coach. They break down why his scheme is so “nerdy” and QB friendly, why Jaxson Dart could benefit from that kind of detail and precision, and why Stefanski and Harbaugh still sit in a different tier as head coach options. Plus, the conversation swings into the staff building obsession, the Dolphins emerging as a real Harbaugh threat, and the chaos theory: when an upgrade appears, teams start firing coaches just to get in the race.

Tiki Explains It: Why He’d Take Stefanski Over Harbaugh Jan 08, 2026

Tiki Barber doubles down on his surprising stance in the Giants coaching debate, explaining why Kevin Stefanski edges out John Harbaugh for him. The discussion centers on QB development, staff building, and long term upside versus the comfort of a proven track record. The guys dig into Stefanski’s “boost factor,” Harbaugh’s elite résumé, concerns about burnout, and why the Giants may need hunger and fire as much as experience in their next head coach.

Wednesday Full Show: The John Harbaugh Sweepstakes Jan 07, 2026

FULL SHOW: John Harbaugh is exactly what the Giants have been looking for, Evan gives the pros and cons of Harbaugh as an HC, Connor Hughes joins the show, Cinco De Lunch-O, and much more.

Hour 1: Giants Coaching Search Panic vs Patience (Harbaugh, Stefanski, Tomlin?) Jan 07, 2026

Hour 1 opens with a wild thought experiment: what if the Giants coaching market gets even crazier, with longshot names like Sean McVay or Matt LaFleur potentially entering the mix? With Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, the show debates the core question every Giants fan is wrestling with: do you strike fast for John Harbaugh, or stay patient and let the full “historic” coaching class reveal itself? Evan argues the Giants cannot afford a waiting game where they lose Kevin Stefanski while hoping Harbaugh doesn’t pick a more playoff-ready “mystery team.” The conversation turns into a full breakdown of urgency versus patience, Rooney Rule logistics, and whether the Giants should have been interviewing candidates weeks ago to get a true head start. Then it gets even messier: Jets fans start dreaming about firing Aaron Glenn for a tiny shot at landing Harbaugh, leading to a heated debate about realism, desperation, and whether a “secret backchannel” is the only way to even find out if a coach would consider the job. The hour wraps with a spirited caller segment, resume comparisons (Harbaugh vs McCarthy), and a preview of a deep dive into why some Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh in recent years.

Hour 2: Harbaugh & the Giants, Ravens Fan Backlash, and the Browns Curveball Jan 07, 2026

John Harbaugh’s playoff résumé compared to the Giants’ last 20 years sparks a brutal reality check, then the guys break down why Ravens fans actually turned on him. From big-game failures and conservative decisions to staff loyalty and late-season fades, every criticism gets aired out. Plus, a surprise contender emerges as a real threat in the Harbaugh sweepstakes with Cleveland entering the picture, fueled by deep family ties and an all-time White Castle honeymoon story. Calls pour in on whether Harbaugh would even choose the Giants, how much money should matter, and whether Joe Schoen helps or hurts New York’s case.

Hour 3: Harbaugh Holds the Power, Schoen on the Clock, and the Stefanski Meltdown Jan 07, 2026

Hour 3 focuses on the latest reporting around John Harbaugh and whether Joe Schoen will actually factor into the Giants coaching decision. With early indications that Schoen is not a roadblock, the conversation centers on power dynamics, long term control, and why Harbaugh would immediately become the unquestioned voice in the room for the New York Giants. The hour then turns to intense debate and caller reaction on what happens if the Giants miss on Harbaugh, whether first time head coaches are even sellable to the fan base, and why this hire feels different than recent searches. It all builds to a heated on air showdown over Kevin Stefanski, complete with audio receipts, arguments over playoff wins, and a real time dispute about honesty, framing, and taking accountability on the air.

Hour 4: Connor Hughes Talks Harbaugh Sweepstakes, Shaun's Hat, and More on the Coaching Carousel. Jan 07, 2026

Hour 4: Connor Hughes Talks Harbaugh Sweepstakes, Shaun's Hat, and More on the Coaching Carousel.

Connor Hughes: Why All Signs Point to John Harbaugh Landing with the Giants (Full Interview) Jan 07, 2026

Connor Hughes joins the show to deliver a deep dive into why momentum is building toward John Harbaugh becoming the next head coach of the New York Giants. Connor explains why the process will take time despite clear interest, how the Rooney Rule factors into the timeline, and why Harbaugh has quickly separated himself from the rest of the field. The conversation digs into the power dynamic between Harbaugh and Joe Schoen, whether ownership would reshape the front office to land a proven coach, and how Harbaugh’s presence would immediately change decision making inside the building. Connor also addresses competition from other potential openings, why the Giants are viewed as the most desirable vacancy, and whether candidates like Kevin Stefanski remain realistic alternatives. The interview wraps with expectations if Harbaugh is hired, from short term win projections to long term culture change, and Connor ultimately makes his call that all signs point toward Harbaugh and the Giants coming together sooner rather than later.

Cubs Swipe Edward Cabrera and the Yankees Get Stuck in Bellinger Limbo Jan 07, 2026

Edward Cabrera is off the board, and not to the Yankees. With Ken Rosenthal reporting the Cubs land the hard-throwing righty, the conversation shifts to what this means for New York’s offseason plan, why Cabrera made sense as a target (upside, velocity, control), and why the Cody Bellinger situation might be clogging up every other move. From there, it turns into a bigger picture Yankees debate: how badly do they really need another starter, what kind of trade is coming next, and what happens when the rotation logjam hits in May. Plus, the show veers into peak chaos with Harbaugh countdown talk, tanking jokes that can get you in trouble, and an all-time “take the L” moment as Sean gets called out on the Stefanski playoff win debate.

Harbaugh Changes Everything for the Giants Jan 07, 2026

The Giants coaching search takes center stage as early reports suggest Joe Shane will not be a roadblock if John Harbaugh seriously considers the job. The discussion breaks down why Harbaugh would immediately hold the power in the room, how this hire could future proof the organization even if Shane is gone in a year, and why fans view Harbaugh as a rare no bust option. The conversation also spins into classic WFAN chaos with on air debates, caller reactions, awkward office stories, and plenty of laughs along the way.

John Harbaugh to the Browns Is a Real Threat Jan 07, 2026

Everyone assumes John Harbaugh choosing his next job is a straight Giants conversation, but there is one team that keeps popping up as a legitimate surprise contender. The Cleveland Browns. The guys break down why Cleveland should not be dismissed, digging into the Harbaugh family’s deep personal ties to the city, including stories passed down through Jim Harbaugh that reveal just how strong that emotional connection really is.

John Harbaugh’s Playoff Resume Is Everything the Giants Aren’t Jan 07, 2026

The numbers are staggering. John Harbaugh has won at least one playoff game in nine different seasons with the Baltimore Ravens, while the New York Giants have managed playoff wins in just ten seasons across the entire Super Bowl era. The guys dig into what that gap really means, how often Harbaugh has hosted playoff games, and why Giants fans are still dreaming of a January home playoff tailgate. The conversation then shifts to why Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh, breaking down the biggest criticisms from playoff failures and late game decision making to staff loyalty and late season collapses. Are those flaws deal breakers, or just the normal baggage that comes with any long tenured successful coach? Plus, a candid debate on whether Harbaugh is truly the best possible answer for the Giants right now, and why even elite resumes always come with real concerns.

jets Desperation vs Giants Patience Jan 07, 2026

The coaching carousel turns into chaos as the conversation shifts from the Jets to the Giants and back again. Should the Jets really consider firing a first year head coach just to chase a slim chance at landing John Harbaugh? And if money is the only leverage, would Woody Johnson have to make him the highest paid coach in NFL history to even listen?

Harbaugh Fever: The Giants Are Playing With Fire Jan 07, 2026

The Giants are caught between temptation and patience as the coaching market heats up. Evan and Shaun debate whether chasing John Harbaugh is worth the risk of losing Kevin Stefanski, and why this search could turn historic fast. Desire, panic, and power plays collide as the New York Giants try not to blow the biggest hire of the decade.

Hour 1: Giants Coaching Search Heats Up, Stefanski vs. McCarthy Debate Jan 06, 2026

Evan opens a chilly Tuesday in NYC with Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, and it immediately turns into a full-blown Giants coaching search argument. Is Kevin Stefanski the clear best option for Big Blue, or is he being overrated because the other candidates feel like bigger risks? Evan and Shaun go back and forth on Stefanski’s résumé, the red flags, and why fans are split between “safe hire” and “dream hire” as names like Mike McCarthy, Brian Flores, and other coordinators get dragged into the debate. Then the conversation shifts to the New York Knicks after another ugly loss and a stretch of sloppy, low-effort basketball. Are the warning signs real, or is this just a January lull that good teams go through? Plus: a preview of what’s coming later in the show, including reaction to James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and hearing from Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey.

Hour 2: Giants Coaching Fight, Dolan Speaks, and the Boomer Message Jan 06, 2026

Hour 2 starts loose and gets weird fast before settling back into serious Giants talk. Evan, Shaun, and Tiki explain why they were standing during the show, joke through an awkward cold weather discussion, and set the table for a packed hour. The focus quickly turns to James Dolan’s in studio appearance, breaking down what stood out from his answers on the Knicks and Rangers. Dolan saying Leon Rose can overrule him sparks a real conversation about ownership, power, and trust, while his patience with Chris Drury frustrates Rangers fans and draws comparisons to the Giants sticking with Joe Schoen. From there, the Giants coaching search takes over again. Callers debate Kevin Stefanski versus Mike McCarthy, defensive minded hires versus offensive development for Jaxson Dart, and whether keeping Schoen could cost the Giants their top coaching choice. The Knicks slump, Trae Young trade rumors, and draft pick implications also get mixed in before the hour takes another sharp turn with an unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story that completely hijacks the show.

Hour 3: Why Joe Schoen Still Has a Job, Jaxson Dart’s Role, and the Giants Coaching Endgame Jan 06, 2026

Hour 3 centers on the question Giants fans actually want answered: why Joe Schoen is still the general manager. Evan and Shaun react to Schoen’s press conference and replay his explanation for keeping the job, then rip apart the idea that the Giants have merely “stubbed their toe.” The discussion turns into a blunt breakdown of accountability, ownership patience, and whether Schoen is underselling just how bad things have gone. The hour also dives into whether Jaxson Dart should have any input in the next head coaching hire. Schoen’s dismissive answer sparks frustration, with Evan arguing that listening to your young quarterback does not mean handing him the keys. The guys explain why ignoring Dart’s perspective sends the wrong message about development, leadership, and the future of the franchise. From there, the Giants coaching search opens back up. Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Rex Ryan, Bill Belichick, and surprise candidates all come up, with a focus on who the Giants are most likely to hire rather than who fans want. Callers weigh in on dynastic ownership, why bad owners only fix things by accidentally hiring the right person, and whether the Giants should slow the process in case a major name becomes available. The hour ends with classic show chaos, including Jets misery comparisons, Olympic hockey arguments, media access stories, and a reminder of the hard truth of fandom: you scream, you argue, and then you hope you are wrong.

Tuesday Full Show: Debating Kevin Stefanski to the Giants & Reacting to Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey's Press Conference Jan 06, 2026

FULL SHOW: Evan and Shaun debate if Kevin Stefanski is the right hire as the new Giants Head Coach. Plus, reacting to Mougey and Glenn's press conference, Yankees offseason talk, Bill Belichick is not a legitimate HC candidate for the Giants, the Knicks have looked lifeless since the NBA Cup, and much more.

Hour 4: Darren Mougey & Aaron Glenn Speak but Did They Say Anything? Jan 06, 2026

Hour 4: Darren Mougey & Aaron Glenn Speak but Did They Say Anything?

Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey Press Conference Reaction Jan 06, 2026

Evan and Shaun listen to Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey meet the media and react in real time, pausing after each answer to break down what was actually said… and what wasn’t. The Jets leadership promises to “exhaust every option” at quarterback, but the follow-ups (or lack of them) leave a lot hanging in the air. They debate whether the Fields signing was a clear mistake, why Glenn keeps hijacking answers meant for Mougey, and how much confidence fans should have in this staff’s ability to develop a young QB. Plus, the guys kick around potential defensive coordinator candidates (including a big name idea), question the bold “we can be competitive next year” claim, and point out why Jets talk always seems to turn into motivational slogans instead of real substance.

The 5 Biggest Villains in NY Football Jan 06, 2026

Time for Cinco de Lunch-o the show turns into a full-blown vent session for New York football fans. Evan and Shaun rank the five figureheads fans should be most furious with, starting with the Giants’ defensive mess and ending with the most infuriating answer of all: how the Giants can justify bringing Joe Schoen back. Along the way, they debate whether Aaron Glenn’s “tough guy” approach should matter, and why Jets ownership keeps making the job feel impossible. Then the show pivots into baseball with a hilarious MLB free agency bingo update where everybody whiffs on where Murakami would land. That leads into Evan’s frustration with the Mets and Yankees seemingly passing on a perfect fit from Japan, and why the price tag makes it even more annoying. The segment closes with a surprisingly honest conversation about being a sports fan: you scream, you vent, and then you’re forced to live with whatever your team does. Plus, a quick dive into early 2026 win totals and why Mets fans might have to accept an “86 wins is fine” mindset on January 6. Finally, the phones bring the chaos, including coaching takes, a Nets trade detour, and an all-time moment with a “17-year-old” caller who is definitely, absolutely, totally not cutting school.

Joe Schoen Faces the Heat, Jaxson Dart’s Role, and the Belichick Question Jan 06, 2026

Evan and Shaun dive into two key moments from Joe Schoen’s press conference and why Giants fans still aren’t buying what he’s selling. First, they react to Schoen being asked to justify keeping his job, and why his “course correction” explanation feels like it minimizes how bad things have gotten. Shaun lays out the kind of brutally honest answer he wishes Schoen gave, one that actually owns the misses and explains why the last two years should matter. Then comes the big topic that Giants fans care about most: should Jaxson Dart have any input on the next head coach? Schoen dismissing it sparks a debate about leadership, ego, and whether ignoring your young quarterback’s perspective is a massive mistake even if he’s not making the decision. The segment rolls into more Giants coaching talk with calls on what the team needs most, why waiting could matter in case a surprise candidate shakes loose, and the idea that the only thing that truly fixes “dynastic ownership” is accidentally hiring the right person and staying out of the way. Plus, a quick detour into Big Mac’s Dolan interview bet story, and whether the Giants should at least have a conversation with Bill Belichick before making the biggest hire of the offseason.

Boomer Gave the Massage of a Lifetime Jan 06, 2026

It’s a new edition of Posted and Toasted with old WFAN tweets resurfacing, including some very questionable takes that did not age well. The conversation then swings back to serious Giants coaching debate, comparing Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Todd Bowles, and the risk of letting ownership decisions derail the search. Plus, a bizarrely unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story, Knicks draft lottery intrigue tied to Trae Young rumors, and more calls from fans trying to make sense of everything.

Knicks Slump, Dolan Speaks, and the Stefanski Circus Jan 06, 2026

Evan and Shaun dig into James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle. They break down the short-term bet on Big Mac’s first question, Dolan’s comments on the Knicks, trade deadline expectations, and what it really means when Dolan says Leon Rose can overrule him. Then the conversation turns to the Rangers, Chris Drury, and Dolan preaching patience, which sparks frustration and skepticism. The Knicks slump comes back into focus with more reaction to their lack of effort and whether this rough stretch actually matters long term. Plus, more Giants coaching search calls, Kafka criticism, defensive coach debates, and a live report from Detroit after another ugly Knicks performance.

Knicks Get Embarrassed Jan 06, 2026

The Knicks get blown out by the Pistons and Evan says this isn’t a one-game overreaction, it’s a real slump that’s been building since the NBA Cup. The effort is awful, the ball movement has vanished, and the numbers are getting ugly, including Karl-Anthony Towns having the worst statistical game of his career and Jalen Brunson finishing with zero assists. Evan tries to calm the panic by pointing out even elite teams like OKC have hit a midseason wall too.

Giants Coaching Search in Crisis: Stefanski Not the No-Brainer Fans Think Jan 06, 2026

Evan says Kevin Stefanski feels like a solid option, but not the automatic answer many fans are demanding, pointing to Cleveland’s recent offensive struggles, head-scratching decisions, and the concern of a coach jumping right into another job after getting fired. Shaun pushes back hard, arguing Stefanski is the best available “CEO type” and the safest move compared to rolling the dice on coordinators, especially with a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart in place. The debate turns into a bigger question: is Stefanski a perfect fit for the Giants, or just the best option because the rest of the market is shaky? Plus, if the Giants want him and he turns them down, does that become a flashing warning sign about the organization and Joe Schoen’s presence?

Best of Jets on WFAN: Worst season in team history? Jan 06, 2026

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the Jets and their season-ending blowout loss at the hands of the Buffalo Bills from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Reactions to Week 18 Win, Schoen Staying Jan 06, 2026

We share the best reactions to the Giants' 34-17 win over the Cowboys and the decision to retain Joe Schoen from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show

Mets Say No-Kamoto | 'Rico Brogna' Jan 06, 2026

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets pass on another player as Kazuma Okamoto signs a 4 year deal with the Toronto Blue Jays. What is David Stearns doing? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: A Dreadful Football Season is Over Jan 05, 2026

The Jets reach new lows to end of the year, he Giants officially keep Joe Schoen, and much more we we begin our reign in Mid Days

Hour 1: Jets Rock Bottom and Why Firing Aaron Glenn Could Backfire Jan 05, 2026

Evan and Tiki break down the brutal reality of the New York Jets after an embarrassing finish to the season and a disastrous first year under Aaron Glenn. They explain why Aaron Rodgers winning games in Pittsburgh does not mean the Jets made the wrong decision, and why keeping him would have actually made the future worse. The conversation dives into whether firing Aaron Glenn after one season would truly fix anything, or if it would push the Jets further into dysfunction. Evan lays out why “trust me” and “have faith” is not a real plan, while still arguing that a one and done firing may do more harm than good without a clear upgrade waiting. They examine how trading Sauce Gardner and Quinnen Williams changed the locker room, why the roster looked nonprofessional down the stretch, and how the Jets ended up here with so little talent on the field. Plus, a realistic look at the quarterback options, draft capital, cap space, and whether there is any legitimate reason for hope moving forward. It is an honest Black Monday discussion about a franchise at rock bottom and the dangerous choices that come next.

Hour 2: Schoen Stays, Giants on the Clock Jan 05, 2026

Hour 2 kicks off with the Giants making it official: Joe Schoen is staying as GM, and the debate instantly turns into one question, what does “stability” actually buy you when the wins are this low? Evan, Tiki, and Shaun Morris argue the case for and against running it back, and why the next head coach hire has to be a proven, veteran voice if the Giants are going to avoid another reset. Then it’s Jets time, as Evan unloads on the “trust me” messaging from the coaching staff and why faith is not a plan for a fanbase that’s watched quarterbacks and offenses collapse for years. The calls pour in on what the Jets should do next, what kind of coach can fix this, and whether leadership needs to address the noise. Plus, Black Monday chaos continues with more coaching dominoes falling around the league, including the Raiders moving on from Pete Carroll after one year, and a truly wild coaching rumor that has everyone reacting. Subscribe for more Evan and Tiki on WFAN, featuring real-time reactions, big-picture roster talk, and nonstop New York football therapy.

Hour 3: Joe B Torches the Jets and the NFL Coaching Carousel Explodes Jan 05, 2026

Joe Benigno joins Evan and Tiki and delivers a scorched-earth review of the Jets’ season, calling the last five weeks unwatchable and questioning how the head coach could possibly return. Joe blasts the historic lack of forced turnovers, the lifeless offense, and the embarrassing mistakes that made the Jets feel closer to a college team than an NFL franchise. From there, the conversation turns to what comes next: the value of the No. 2 pick, whether a quarterback is mandatory, and how the Jets avoid repeating the same rookie QB failures with a real veteran bridge. Joe weighs in on coaching candidates, why certain names would take the job, and what kind of coordinator hires are non-negotiable if the current regime stays. The hour closes with the Black Monday carousel, the most appealing openings, and a quick detour into Mets frustration before the show pivots back to a fanbase stuck between draft hope and total exhaustion.

Hour 4: Raiders Coaching Chaos, 4th-Down Analytics Debates & Jets/Giants Predictions Revisited Jan 05, 2026

Hour 4: Raiders Coaching Chaos, 4th-Down Analytics Debates & Jets/Giants Predictions Revisited

A Win That Broke Giants Fans Jan 05, 2026

The debut of Cinco de Lunch gets heated as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun argue why the Giants’ late-season win might have done more harm than good. From wrecked draft position to missed trade leverage, the crew breaks down the five reasons this victory felt hollow for Giants fans who sat through months of misery only to lose ground when it mattered most. The conversation expands into a bigger debate about tanking, draft lotteries, and whether the NFL is headed toward a system that rewards losing. Callers weigh in on whether the Giants are actually one of the most appealing coaching jobs on the market, how much draft position really matters, and why fans feel stuck between wanting wins and needing change. It’s a loud, messy, and brutally honest lunchtime segment that captures everything broken about late-season football for losing teams.

Joe B Erupts: Fire Everyone! Jan 05, 2026

Joe B joins Evan and Tiki for a must-hear, no-filter interview as Black Monday fallout hits full force. Joe unloads on the Jets keeping Aaron Glenn after a historically brutal finish, calling it one of the most embarrassing stretches of football he’s ever seen. The conversation dives into why this coaching staff can’t be trusted to develop a young quarterback, what the Jets should do with the No. 2 pick, and whether drafting a franchise QB into this situation is setting him up to fail. Joe also lays out his blueprint for fixing the roster, from adding a real veteran quarterback to overhauling a broken defense, plus his thoughts on Rex Ryan, Mike McCarthy, Kliff Kingsbury, and why this job still isn’t attractive to top coaches. The interview wraps with Super Bowl predictions, Mets frustration, and classic Joe B rants that hit like a fastball.

Mara Doubles Down on Schoen Jan 05, 2026

With Joe Schoen officially returning, the Giants conversation turns into a full-on tug of war between two realities: is the roster quietly close, or is this just stability theater after another lost season? Evan owns the take he got wrong, Tiki meets him halfway, and the core argument becomes clear, the next head coach has to be experienced, because the margin for error is gone. The debate hits everything Giants fans fight about: how much of the losing was coaching versus roster building, whether Schoen can be trusted with another major hire, and why “meaningful December football” has to be the standard in 2026. Then it gets spicy with a back-and-forth on the salary cap, keeping key free agents like Jermaine Eluemunor and Wan’Dale Robinson, and whether the Giants are actually in a healthy spot or just kicking the can like everyone else. Plus, fan calls, Mike McCarthy as a real option, frustration with “stability” as an excuse, and the big question hovering over it all: if the roster is better, why does it keep looking worse?

Giants Keep Joe Schoen: Stability or More of the Same? Jan 05, 2026

Breaking news hits right away as the Giants officially retain Joe Schoen, and the debate turns into a full Black Monday autopsy: is continuity the smart play, or is ownership settling for “good enough” after back to back ugly seasons? The guys break down why the next head coach hire has to be a proven veteran, what “meaningful December football” actually looks like, and why the Giants feel closer than their record suggests.

Black Monday Reality Check for NY Football Jan 05, 2026

On Black Monday, the Jets and Giants seasons officially come to an end, and the focus shifts from speculation to hard truths. The Giants retain Joe Schoen in the name of stability, while the Jets face tougher questions after another embarrassing finish. The conversation centers on continuity versus chaos, why front offices crave stability when hiring a head coach, and whether hope and faith are enough to sell a broken fan base. Plus, a blunt reaction to Aaron Glenn’s “trust me” answer, why belief without evidence falls flat, and how both franchises now face defining decisions at quarterback that will shape the next decade.

The Jets Have No Easy Fix Jan 05, 2026

The Jets hit rock bottom over the final weeks of the season, and the frustration is justified. But this segment digs into why firing the head coach after one year could actually make a bad situation worse. From a noncompetitive roster and brutal point differentials to a locker room shaken by midseason trades, the conversation centers on why patience may be the smarter gamble when there is no clear upgrade waiting. It is a hard look at a franchise with no quick answers, no obvious savior, and a future that cannot be repaired by panic decisions.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Does Schoen Deserve Blame? Jan 04, 2026

Boomer & Gio on Joe Schoen’s standing within the Giants organization. Plus, Chris McMonigle on potential Giants coaching candidates and why Schoen remaining is hardly a surprise (11:21); C-Mac is rooting for the Giants to lose on Sunday (20:46); Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash dispute the narrative Jaxson Dart is prone to concussions (36:38); Brian Baldinger on the appeal of the Giants coaching job (48:34); C-Mac explains why Eli Manning deserves to be in the Hall of Fame (54:36).

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: What's the Plan? Jan 03, 2026

Jon Heyman joins Marc Malusis to discuss the latest rumors around the Yankees and the direction they’re going in what has been a quiet offseason. Plus, Jerry Recco and Willie Colon speculate what the plan is for the Bronx Bombers (8:40); Chris McMonigle refutes the notion the Yankees are ‘dysfunctional’ with Hal Steinbrenner calling the shots (15:57); C-Mac also says do not expect the Yankees to make a splash (24:20)

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Should Aaron Glenn Stay or Go? Jan 03, 2026

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber to voice his disdain for the Aaron Glenn Jets; Boomer and Gio weigh in on Glenn’s future (22:09); Jets beat reporter Al Iannozzone joins Marc Malusis on why Glenn will likely get another year (38:50); Shaun and Tiki on whether or not the Jets coaches are in over their heads (56:21); Shaun and Tiki also discuss if Joe Burrow really is a realistic option for the Jets (1:08:23).

Friday Full Show: The Final Afternoon Show for Evan and Tiki Jan 02, 2026

A Football Friday and farewell to the afternoons.

Hour 1: Evan Isn’t Ready to Fire Aaron Glenn Jan 02, 2026

Evan doesn’t feel excited about who would replace Aaron Glenn

Hour 2: Evan begins his 20th Year at WFAN Jan 02, 2026

Evan started WFAN when New York sports were in a different place

Hour 3: The Jets Can’t Pick Number 1 Without a Trade Jan 02, 2026

A trip down memory lane in Jets draft history

Hour 4: A Football Friday Jan 02, 2026

Tips down Cinco Memory Lane plus our NFL Picks

Cinco De Five Oh Jan 02, 2026

The 5 Best moments on Evan and Tiki from the afternoon run

Final Lugash Debate Series Jan 02, 2026

One final Tommy vs Shaun War

Bold Predictions for 2026 Jan 02, 2026

We make our predictions for 2026.

Giants Head Coach Search list Jan 02, 2026

The Giants have a list of coaches they want to interview, do any excite us?

Evan thinks the Giants are going to win big Sundy Jan 02, 2026

Are the Giants going to blowout the Cowboys?

Wednesday Full Show: Should the Giants Be Tanking to Get A Better Pcik? Jan 01, 2026

C-Mac on the Giants running the risk of missing out on a top 5 daft pick. What should the Jets do with Aaron Glenn? Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer? Are the Yankees dysfunctional?

Hour 5: Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer? Jan 01, 2026

C-Mac gives Giants fans a hard truth about Eli Manning's case to be in the Hall of Fame.

Which New York Football Team Is In Better Shape Going Forward? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says the Giants have a brighter future than the Jets.

Hour 4: Is Hal That Bad Of An Owner? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says Hal isn't that much worse than George. Where does Aaron Judge rank amongst Yankee greats in the 21st century?

People Forget the Negatives of George Steinbrenner Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says Hal isn't that much worse than George, contrary to most fans' beliefs.

Hour 3: Are They Ways To End Tanking? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac on the ways that the NFL and MLB can make positives changes for 206 and beyond. Are the Yankees a dysfunctional franchise?

Are the Yankees Dysfunctional? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says despite the lack of championships, Hal is not running a "dysfunctional" franchise.

Things That Need To Change In 2026 Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says the NFL and MLB need to make some changes for the better.

Hour 2: Is Tanking Bad For Sports? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac debates callers on if tanking is bad for sports and younger generations who look up to these pro athletes.

Are There Any New Year's Eve Traditions? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac on the best New Year's Eve traditions, if there are any.

Hour 1: The Future of the Giants Rests On This Sunday Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac says it's very important that Giants secure a top 2 pick in the 2026 draft by losing to the Cowboys.

Should the Giants Keep Joe Schoen? Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac is starting to change his mind on what the Giants should do with GM Joe Schoen.

The Giants Need To Lose On Sunday Dec 31, 2025

C-Mac opens the show by saying he is rooting for the Cowboys to beat the Giants in the season finale.

Tuesday Full Show Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on the Giants and Jets' coaching situations, what offseason additions each team could make, Jaxson Dart's rookie season, and the Knicks' All-Star chances.

Hour 1: Do the Jets move on from Aaron Glenn? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss whether or not the Jets should keep head coach Aaron Glenn for next season and what the team can do at the quarterback position going forward.

Hour 2: Nobody makes sense when talking about Giants QB Jaxson Dart (except us) Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the narratives surrounding Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart, whether or not he has a problem with concussions, and if Saints QB Tyler Shough has looked better under center this season.

Hour 3: Where can the Giants & Jets go from here? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend the third hour of Tuesday's show discussing what Giants and Jets offseason targets are realistic, if the Jets' coaching staff is in too deep with this roster, and if the roster is so bad that it's unfair to fire Aaron Glenn.

Hour 4: Quiet NFL coaching carousel ahead? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber give you a New Years-themed Cinco de Five Oh, discuss the Giants and Jets' coaching situations, ask what coaches could be available, and talk some Knicks.

Are Knick fans failing Jalen Brunson's All-Star Campaign? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the first NBA All-Star fan voting returns, which feature several Knicks players but had superstar Jalen Brunson surprisingly come in third place.

Cinco de Five Oh Dec 30, 2025

Shaun presents Tuesday's Cinco de Five Oh to Tiki Barber. The 5 worst New Year's Resolutions, brought to you by Helix Wireless.

Real or No Real: Joe Burrow to New York? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash hosts a new game called Real or No Real, where he poses potential offseason targets for the Giants and Jets to Tiki Barber in search of just how realistic that player (or coach) coming to New York could be.

Can you fairly judge Aaron Glenn with this Jets roster? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss how fair it is to call for Aaron Glenn's firing when the Jets' roster is this gutted.

Is the Jets' coaching staff in over their heads? Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the start to Aaron Glenn's tenure as New York Jets head coach and ask if the team is best-served moving on now.

Giants' Jaxson Dart is not concussion prone despite narratives Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber lament the discourse surrounding Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart, whether or not Tyler Shough has a better case for OROY than him, and get fired up over the narrative that he is prone to concussions because of his playstyle.

Sean McVay proved NFL coaches are too reliant on analytics Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber talk about the Los Angeles Rams' Monday Night Football loss to the Atlanta Falcons, which Shaun thinks happened because they were too reliant on analytics ... and Tiki reacts.

Why Aaron Glenn's Jets tenure might need to end Dec 30, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber open Tuesday's show by discussing Aaron Glenn's future as the Jets head coach - and whether or not he should have one.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Monday Reactions to Patriots Loss Dec 30, 2025

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle discuss if it’s time to clean house. Marc Malusis on the Jets’ ‘historically bad’ performance against the Patriots (10:13), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on if the lack of fight is indicative of Aaron Glenn’s future (28:14)

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Monday Reaction to Win vs. Raiders Dec 30, 2025

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle wonder where the Giants season went wrong? Marc Malusis believes the Giants showed they have talent (7:48), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on why Sunday’s win is meaningful despite losing the No. 1 pick (18:38).

Monday Full Show Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber open the week by reacting to the Giants and Jets' weekend woes and questioning Joe Schoen, Jaxson Dart, and Aaron Glenn's futures in New York.

Hour 1: Are either the Giants or Jets trending upward? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and TIki Barber get the week started by wondering what the Giants and Jets have planned next, if the Giants are keeping QB Jaxson Dart and GM Joe Schoen, and how hot Aaron Glenn's seat should be amid an abysmal start.

Hour 2: Will the Giants bring Schoen, Dart into next year? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend the second hour of Monday's show discussing the Giants futures of General Manager Joe Schoen and first-round draft pick Jaxson Dart, as well as filtering in some news around the NFL.

Hour 3: Joe B. on the Jets | What do NY fans root for in Week 18? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are joined by Joe Benigno, who says he's done with Aaron Glenn, and look around at the NFL playoff picture with the Week 18 schedule having been released.

Hour 4: Can someone learn to love football? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend Hour 4 of Monday's show going through Shaun's five ways to fix the NFL, Deonte Banks' return touchdown and future in NY, and take YOUR calls.

Deonte Banks & Learning to Love Football Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss Deonte Banks' return touchdown against the Raiders, his standing on the Giants, and what he can learn from Tiki about learning to love everything about the game of football.

Cinco de Five Oh Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash gives Tiki Barber five ways to fix the NFL for Monday's Cinco de Five Oh.

NFL Playoff Picture is shaping up... Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber break down the NFL's Week 18 schedule and discuss which teams will look to win or lose as the season winds down.

Joe B. is DONE with Aaron Glenn's Jets Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are joined by Joe Benigno for his weekly spot on the show. This week's included plenty of ire being directed toward Aaron Glenn and Woody Johnson, for continuing to employ him.

Could Kevin Stefanski be the PERFECT Giants fit? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate the merits of the Giants looking to see if Browns HC Kevin Stefanski becomes a free agent as well as field some calls with suggestions for the NFL's tanking problem.

Are Jaxson Dart, Joe Schoen's Giants futures safe? Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss a pregame non-report from Ian Rapoport that Joe Schoen is expected to stay as the Giants' general manager "through the draft," as well as Jaxson Dart's standing with the organization.

The NFL needs to do something to fix tanking Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the merits of tanking in professional sports in the wake of the Giants' win over the Raiders and another blowout loss by the Jets.

Giants, Jets leave fans with more questions than answers Dec 29, 2025

Shaun Morash and TIki Barber open Monday's show by discussing if the Giants lost by winning against the Raiders - and how hot Aaron Glenn's seat should be amid the Jets' disaster season.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Dart vs. No. 1 Pick Dec 28, 2025

Evan & Tiki question which is more valuable to the Giants: Jaxson Dart or the No. 1 pick? Plus, Marc Malusis on why he believes this weekend’s game vs. the Raiders is the Giants’ Super Bowl for draft capital (18:43); Malusis also expresses skepticism he has about Fernando Mendoza (32:12); Shaun Morash and Tiki dive into Dart liking a video of C-Mac’s criticism of the Giants (45:41); Jerry Recco and Willie Colon if it’s worth playing Jaxson Dart if the goal is to tank (55:20).

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Finding the Next QB Dec 27, 2025

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash to talk Jets’ future and NFL Draft trade possibilities. Plus, Morash and Tiki discuss if Gang Green could realistically target Lamar Jackson in a trade; Jerry Recco and Willie Colon on whether the Jets should pursue a rookie or veteran QB; Marc Malusis entertains the possibility of a Jets-Giants draft trade for the No. 1 pick; Jerry and Willie dissect what went wrong with Justin Fields and also whether or not the Jets are stuck going nowhere.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Jeff McNeil the latest exit Dec 25, 2025

The Mets have continued taking a sledgehammer to the team's core, trading Jeff McNeil to the A's. Jerry Recco doesn't understand the plan after parting with several key contributors, while Evan says there better be additions coming soon. Plus, Marc Malusis says the Mets are clearly David Stearns' team now, and he better get it right.

Brandon Nimmo Tribute Show | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 25, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The dust has finally settled on Brandon Nimmo being traded away from the Mets. Evan gave it some time and made sure he was able to give Nimmo a proper tribute show. So without further disruption we present the top 10 moments of Brandon Nimmo as a New York Met. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Jeff McNeil Traded To The A's For A Bag Of Balls | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 24, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It's not a literal bag of balls, but it sure feels that way. Jeff McNeil has been shipped out to the Athletics along with $5.75M in cash for a 17 year old pitcher Yordan Rodriquez. While this sounds like a great move to get rid of more of the core, what are we doing in the outfield? Evan breaks it down! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tuesday Full Show Dec 23, 2025

Full Show: Harbaugh to Giants? Lamar to Jets? Dart a WFAN listener? and is Home Alone a Christmas movie?

Hour 1: Trouble in Baltimore? The Jets and Giants MUST Take Advantage Dec 23, 2025

Hour 1: If John Harbaugh is out in Baltimore, the Giants should run to hire him. Plus, if Lamar wants out, the Jets should go get him.

Hour 2: Dart Likes WFAN Post, Posted / Toasted Dec 23, 2025

Hour 2: Jaxson Dart liked a WFAN post calling out the Giants. Plus, a brand new edition of Posted and Toasted

Hour 3: Joe B. joins the Show and Tiki Does Last Minute Christmas Shopping Dec 23, 2025

Hour 3: Joe B. joins the Show and Tiki Does Last Minute Christmas Shopping

Hour 4: Cinco, Christmas Movies Dec 23, 2025

Hour 4: The guys debate the best and worst Christmas Movies

Cinco De Five Oh Dec 23, 2025

Cinco de Five Oh - The top 5 Christmas Characters

Joe B Monday on a Tuesday Dec 23, 2025

Joe Benigno wonders if the Giants would help the Jets by trading the first overall pick.

Jaxson Dart Liked C-Mac's Video Bashing the Giants Dec 23, 2025

Jaxson Dart liked a video of C-Mac bashing the Giants current regime

Should the Jets Trade for Lama Jackson? Dec 23, 2025

If things keep going south in Baltimore, should the Jets try to trade for Lamar Jackson?

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Monday Reactions to Loss vs. Saints Dec 23, 2025

Boomer & Gio take calls from fed-up Jets fans. Plus, Marc Malusis (11:20) and Evan & Tiki (27:30) react to the loss and talk Aaron Glenn’s future.

Best of Giants on WFAN: Monday Reactions to Loss vs. Vikings Dec 23, 2025

Boomer and Gio react to the Giants’ 16-13 loss to the Vikings and wonder if Jaxson Dart should still be playing. Plus, reactions from Marc Malusis (7:13) and Evan & Tiki (21:22)

New York Mets Payroll And Beyond | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 23, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Steve Cohen fights back on the Payroll criticism from the MEDIA, not the fans, let them be pissed. Plus, Luis Robert he next target for David Stearns? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show Dec 23, 2025

Evan and Tiki talk the Giants loss to the Vikings, Jets loss to the Saints and jump around the NFL. They also talk about if domes are ending the mystique of the NFL, Jeff McNeil being traded from the Mets and this being their last show on SNY as a duo.

Hour 1: The Giants & Jaxson Dart's Awful Performance; The Number One Pick in the NFL Draft Dec 23, 2025

Evan and Tiki talk about Jaxson Dart's "regression" after his awful performance against the Vikings on Sunday. They then talk about the sports radio gold that would happen if the Giants had the number one pick in the upcoming NFL Draft.

Hour 2: The Mets Finally Trade Jeff McNeil ; Is the NFL Shifting to Domed Stadiums? Dec 23, 2025

Evan and Tiki talk about the breaking news that the Mets traded Jeff McNeil. They then talk about the Chiefs moving to the state of Kansas and how that domed stadium might be changing the face of the NFL.

Hour 3: The QB Future for the Jets; The Wave at NFL Games Dec 23, 2025

Evan and Tiki talk about the QB future for the Jets and the wave that happened at the Jets-Saints.

Hour 4: Cinco de Five Oh ; Evan and Tiki's Last Show on SNY Dec 22, 2025

Evan and Tiki talk about Tommy's Cinco about next Giants Head Coach Candidates as well as talk about their last ever show on SNY during the afternoons.

Cinco de Five Oh ; Loogy's Power Rankings of Potential Giants Head Coaches Dec 22, 2025

Tommy give his top 5 names for the next Head Coach of the Giants.

The Jets Cloudy Future Dec 22, 2025

Evan and Tiki discuss the ramifications of the Jets 29-6 loss to the Saints.

The Mets Have Traded Jeff McNeil Dec 22, 2025

The show reacts to the breaking news that the Mets have traded INF Jeff McNeil to the Athletics.

What is More Valuable? Jaxson Dart or the #1 Overall Draft Pick Dec 22, 2025

Evan and Tiki discuss the values of Jaxson Dart and the #1 overall pick in the upcoming NFL Draft,

Reasons for Jaxson Dart's Awful Showing Against The Vikings Dec 22, 2025

Evan and Tiki open up their Monday show by talking about the reasons why Jaxson Dart struggled mightily against the Vikings on Sunday afternoon.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Fernando Mendoza or Bust? Dec 21, 2025

Boomer & Gio discuss the outlook for the rest of the Jets season and why they should position themselves to draft Fernando Mendoza. Plus, Boomer & Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn will be one and done; Brandon Tierney believes the Jets must tank the rest of the season; Evan Roberts asks Tiki Barber if he would want Mendoza in New York; Tierney reacts to the Jets firing of Steve Wilks.

Best of the Knicks on WFAN: NBA Cup Champs! Dec 20, 2025

Brandon Tierney, Boomer & Gio (18:46), and Evan & Tiki (33:47) all react to the Knicks winning the NBA Cup in-season tournament and what it means for the franchise and rest of season. Plus, Evan says the Knicks are not obligated to raise a banner for the NBA Cup (51:06); Marc Malusis makes the case to keep the core intact and not go after Giannis (1:02:31); Boomer wonders if this could be the Knicks’ year? (1:17:04)

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Stockpiling former Yankees Dec 20, 2025

Luke Weaver is heading to the Mets, and both Evan and Morash believe it could turn out to be a high-reward signing. McMonigle agrees, but wonders why the salary was as high as it was. Plus, Moose sounds off on David Stearns' philosophies that led to losing Pete Alonso, and McMonigle says the team is having a brutal offseason so far.

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Waiting on Cody Bellinger Dec 20, 2025

Brandon Tierney says the Yankees better not lose Bellinger to the Mets, or it will be the biggest embarrassment of the Hal Steinbrenner era. He also believes the Yanks should load up on pitching and revamp their identity in 2026. Marc Malusis rips the organization's complacency, and the Evan and Tiki crew lament New York's quiet offseason.

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 16 in the NFL. | 'Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti' Dec 20, 2025

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti cover wall to wall NFL for week 16. Jets fire their defensive coordinator. Commanders went after Jaxson Dart. Texans are the team to beat and QB carousel for 2026. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Friday Full Show: Steve Cohen Breaks Silence, plus a Football Friday Dec 19, 2025

The Mets Owner takes to Twitter, Carton and McMonigle stop by, plus a Football Friday with picks and more.

Hour 1: Steve Cohen Has an Issue with Idiots Dec 19, 2025

The Mets owner breaks his silence on twitter, but what does it mean?

Hour 2: Flyers Radio has an Epic Hot Mic Moment Dec 19, 2025

Did last night give us a hot mic moment in sports we will never forget?

Hour 3: Number’s 2 and 1 in The Top 25 of 25 Dec 19, 2025

What was the biggest sports story of the year? Plus, Craig and McMonigle stop by

Hour 4: The Jets and Giants Fight for the First Pick Dec 19, 2025

Evan refuses to admit getting the first overall pick is more important for the Giants

Craig Carton and C Mac Join us In Studio Dec 19, 2025

The new afternoon show joins the current afternoon show

Garrett Wilson Shuts It Down for the Season Dec 19, 2025

Garrett Wilson will not play again the rest of the season

Thursday Night Football Had a Weird Fumble Ruling Dec 19, 2025

Does the NFL need a rule change?

Mike Breen Gave a Regular Season Double Bang Dec 19, 2025

Mike Breen was overly excited on a Brunson shot vs the beat up Pacers

Mets Sign Luke Weaver | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 19, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets scoop up another former New York Yankees relief pitcher. This time it's Luke Weaver. Along with that, Evan runs through the "Rico 10" which is a list of 10 Mets headlines from the week. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Thursday Full Show: Debating if the Jets Should Fire Aaron Glenn, The Knicks are Resting Players, NFL Draft Positioning Dec 19, 2025

FULL SHOW: Should Aaron Glenn be fired? The Knicks resting after the NBA Cup, Giants-Raiders will have huge ramifications down the road, and much more.

Hour 4: The Knicks are Resting Players After Winning the NBA Cup Dec 18, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Tommy give their thoughts on the Knicks resting players after winning the NBA Cup on Tuesday. That and much more.

Cinco De Five-Oh: Sports Moments We've Forgotten About in 2025 Dec 18, 2025

Shaun gives his top-five sports moments we've forgotten about in 2025.

Counting Down the Top 25 Sports Moments of 2025 Dec 18, 2025

The Countdown continues, as the show gives you the Top 25 Sports Moments of 2025.

Hour 3: When You Get Close to a Title You Must Win It Dec 18, 2025

Evan and Shaun discuss teams that have gotten close to a title and how you must win it when you get there. Plus, Top 25 Moments and much more.

Hour 2: Giants vs. Raiders Will Have Major Ramifications Dec 18, 2025

Evan and Shaun break down the Giants-Raiders game coming-up later in the season and how it will have huge ramifications for the Giants and Jets. That and much more.

Some of the Most Unique Plays in Sports Dec 18, 2025

Evan and Shaun discuss some of the unique plays in sports, including the shootout, the fair-catch free-kick, and much more.

Hour 1: Debating if the Jets Should Keep Aaron Glenn Dec 18, 2025

Evan and Shaun debate whether the Jets should move on after the year. Plus, would Bill Belichick be an option for the Jets or Giants?

Wednesday Full Show: The Knicks are Serious Title Contenders, How to Improve the NBA Cup, The Mets Sign Luke Weaver, And Much More Dec 18, 2025

FULL SHOW: The Knicks are Serious Title Contenders, How to Improve the NBA Cup, The Mets Sign Luke Weaver, Who is the Biggest Rangers fan at WFAN, and much more.

Hour 4: How to Improve the NBA Cup & Debating Who is WFAN's Biggest Rangers Fan Dec 18, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Loogy discuss how to improve the NBA Cup and much more.

Cinco De Five-Oh & Evan Steals Adam Silver's Idea Dec 17, 2025

Shaun delivers his Cinco De Five-Oh and it looks like Evan may have stolen Adam Silver's idea for the NBA Cup.

Joe Burrow Appears to Want to Stay With the Bengals Dec 17, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Tommy give their thoughts on the latest Joe Burrow clip and why it seems he doesn't want to leave.

Hour 3: What to Call Last Week's Mets Debacle Dec 17, 2025

Evan and Shaun talk about last week, where the Mets let Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz walk, and discuss what it should be named. Plus, the countdown of the Top-25 Sports Moments continues, Joe Burrow sounds like he's staying in Cincinnati, and more.

Luke Weaver is a New York Met Dec 17, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Tommy give their thoughts on Luke Weaver joining the Mets and his importance at the back end of the bullpen.

Hour 2: Josh Hart Got Handsy with Jalen Brunson & Luke Weaver to the Mets Dec 17, 2025

Hour 2: Evan, Shaun, and Loogy discuss Josh Hart Oil Checking Jalen Brunson....Plus, thoughts on Luke Weaver heading to the Mets, and much more.

Josh Hart Gives Jalen Brunson an Oil Change..... Dec 17, 2025

Evan and Shaun talk about Josh Hart's antics with Jalen Brunson while celebrating after last night's game.

The Knicks are NBA Cup Champions Dec 17, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Loogy break down the Knicks beating the Spurs in the NBA Cup and the significance of the win.

Hour 1: The Knicks Have a Legitimate Chance to Win the NBA Title Dec 17, 2025

Hour 1: Evan, Shaun, and Loogy give their thoughts on the Knicks winning the NBA Cup and why it signals they are real contenders to win the Finals this year.

Tuesday Full Show: Yankees Offseason Questions, NBA Cup Discussion, Martin Brodeur vs. Henrik Lundqvist Dec 16, 2025

FULL SHOW: Breaking down the Yankees offseason decisions, debating the importance of the NBA Cup, Shaun claims Henrik Lundqvist is better than Martin Brodeur, and much more.

Hour 4: Shaun Argues that Henrik Lundqvist was Better Than Martin Brodeur Dec 16, 2025

Hour 4: Shaun claims that Henrik Lundqvist is better than Martin Brodeur, Cinco De Five-Oh, thoughts on divide in the Mets clubhouse and much more.

Cinco De Five-Oh: Top Five Reasons Tommy Wants the Knicks to win the NBA Cup Dec 16, 2025

Tommy gives his reasons why he wants to win tonight.

Debating if the Knicks Should Hang the NBA Cup Banner Dec 16, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Tommy debate whether the Knicks should hang the NBA Cup banner at the Garden if they win tonight.

Hour 3: The Best Candidate to be the Jets Defensive Coordinator Dec 16, 2025

Hour 3: Evan gives his best candidates for the Jets DC job. That and much more.

Hour 2: Could the Jets Go After Joe Burrow or Tua Tagovailoa? Dec 16, 2025

Hour 2: Evan and Shaun give their thoughts on the Jets QB situation and if Joe Burrow or Tua are legitimate options. That and much more.

Edwin Diaz Turned Down an Offer from the Braves Dec 16, 2025

Evan and Shaun discuss Edwin Diaz turning down an offer from the Braves.

Hour 1: The Yankees Quiet Offseason & Cody Bellinger to the Mets? Dec 16, 2025

Hour 1: Evan and Shaun break down the Yankees quiet offseason and if Cody Bellinger could wind-up with the Mets. That and much more.

The Yankees Quiet Offseason Continues Dec 16, 2025

SHOW OPEN: Evan and Shaun open the show giving their thoughts on the Yankees quiet offseason and if things will change.

Best Jets Reactions on WFAN: Steve Wilks Out After Blowout Loss Dec 16, 2025

The WFAN team talks through draft scenarios and the firing of defensive coordinator Steve Wilks following the Jets' loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday

Best Giants Reactions on WFAN: Keep Or Trade a Top NFL Draft Pick? Dec 16, 2025

The WFAN team is questioning whether or not the Giants should trade the top overall NFL Draft pick after the 21-29 loss to the Washington Commanders on Sunday

David Stearns Trade History | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 16, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Evan Roberts takes a closer look at David Stearns trade history. Will this offseason have an unexpected trade go down? Also, a look back at Pete Alonso declining an extension in 2023 and the loss of Tyler Rogers. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: Joe Schoen’s Seat is Scorching Hot, Kreider Returns Dec 15, 2025

Jaxson Dart vs Fernando Mendoza is a hot topic as the Giants have the top pick, plus the Mets have crushed Joe B.

Hour 1: Can’t Let Joe Schoen Make the Decision on the Draft Dec 15, 2025

Sunday was another message that Joe Schoen needs to be fired

Hour 2: Tom Brady Said What on the Lions-Rams Game? Dec 15, 2025

Tom Brady said an astonishing thing about Matt Stafford’s pass

Hour 3: Joe Beningo Feels Violated by the Mets Dec 15, 2025

It has not been a good week to be a Mets or Jets fan

Hour 4: Chris Kreider Returns to MSG Dec 15, 2025

Reminiscing about other former NY athletes looking odd in different team’s jerseys.

Number's 10 and 9 in The Top 12 in 25 Dec 15, 2025

A Jaxson Dart filled moment list

The NFL Playoffs Officially Won't Have Mahomes or the Chiefs Dec 15, 2025

The Chiefs were eliminated, and Mahomes is out for a long time

Should the Giants Have Gone for 2 Earlier? Dec 15, 2025

Should the Giants have gone for 2 with 3:26 left on Sunday?

Is there a Scenario Where Tiki Would Want Mendoza? Dec 15, 2025

Ferando-Mania could end up in New York

The NFL is Now Unfairly Treating Jaxson Dart Dec 15, 2025

Jaxson Dart is being sent to the blue tent on normal contact now

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Silent Nights Dec 14, 2025

Boomer & Gio and BT & Sal are all wondering the same thing: where have the Yankees been at the Winter Meetings? Plus, Sal suggests Nice Hoerner as a good fit for the Bronx Bombers; a caller asks who will win the World Series first: the Yankees or Mets? And Evan Roberts dives into what the Yankees’ selecting a player in the Rule 5 Draft means for the offseason outlook.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Is Joe Burrow a Possibility? Dec 14, 2025

Recent comments from Joe Burrow have Boomer & Gio and Evan & Tiki wondering about his future and if the Jets could be in play to pursue the quarterback. Plus, Gio wonders if Indiana QB Fernando Mendoza could be a potential target for the Jets; BT & Sal wonder how the Daniel Jones injury could impact the Jets in the draft, and they react to news Brady Cook will start Week 15 against the Jaguars.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: David Stearns public enemy No. 1? Dec 13, 2025

The Mets have taken a wrecking ball to their core, and Evan Roberts is livid with David Stearns and Steve Cohen, while Sal Licata says the organization deserves the benefit of the doubt after letting Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz go. Joe Benigno says the Wilpons would have kept Alonso, and Boomer Esiason declares this offseason "The Great Met Reset."

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Alonso and Diaz's shocking exit Dec 13, 2025

Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz bolted in consecutive days, leaving Mets fans up in arms at two stars leaving for seemingly reasonable contracts. All of our main shows had heated reactions to the news, ranging from ripping the team to praising the organization for having the guts to shake things up.

Picking Up The Pieces | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 13, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets weren't as active at the winter meetings as it looks. It was more about losing Edwin Diaz and Pete Alonso and not gaining a thing. Let's hear what the President of Baseball Operations has to say about the offseason so far. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Friday Full Show: A Football Friday With Losing on Fans' Minds Dec 12, 2025

Jets and Giants fans seemingly both want to lose Sunday, plus it sounds like Edwin Diaz was tired of losing with the Mets

Hour 1: Giants Fans Want the Jets Picks Dec 12, 2025

The Giants fans want to lose because they want the Jets picks as we head down the stretch of the NFL Weekend

Hour 2: Bryan Cox Was Fired after an Airplane Seating Issue Dec 12, 2025

The Giants season of disaster continues to be funny

Hour 3: Brady Cook Will Start Sunday Dec 12, 2025

Did Justin Fields opt out of running wild cat plays for the Jets?

Hour 4: Edwin Diaz Speaks on his Mets Departure Dec 12, 2025

Did Diaz take a shot at the Mets on the way out the door?

Top 25 in 25 List Continues Dec 12, 2025

Numbers 13, 12 and 11 are revealed

Should the Mets move on Skubal? Dec 12, 2025

Tarik Skubal to the Mets is something Mets fans remain dreaming about

Marcus Freeman as a Giants Candidate Dec 12, 2025

A caller asks Tiki about the Notre Dame Coach as a Giants candidate

Todd Bowles as a Coaching Candidate Dec 12, 2025

If the Bucs fire Todd Bowles, could he make sense for the Giants

Jaxson Dart Stat Predictions Dec 12, 2025

We predict what Jaxson Dart will do on Sunday vs Washington

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 15 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti' Dec 12, 2025

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 15 in the NFL. Bears look for real. What happened to Jalen Hurts? Bucscaneers are floundering. Can Boomer get a first down in today's NFL right now? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Episode 601 - Say Goodbye To Home Run King Pete Alonso | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 12, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Let's try to put this gently. PETE ALONSO IS GONE AND THERE'S NOTHING WE CAN DO!!!!!! Has Evan cooled off from the past two days of complete hell? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Thursday Full Show: Now What for The Mets? Dec 11, 2025

The Mets may not be done saying goodbye to players, plus should the Jets fans start dreaming about Joe Burrow?

Hour 1: What is Next on the Mets Reset? Dec 11, 2025

The Mets feel like they are resetting, could a Lindor trade be next

Hour 2: Evan Once Predicted Pete Alonso Would Sign a Deal on December 10th Dec 11, 2025

We look back on a couple of Pete Alonso predictions we made in 2025.

Hour 3: Joe Burrow Doesn’t Sound Like He Wants to Play in Cincinnati Much Longer Dec 11, 2025

Did Joe Burrow drop major hints about his future?

Hour 4: The Mets Never Tried to Sign Pete Alonso this Winter Dec 11, 2025

The Mets handled Pete Alonso worse than they did Jacob deGrom

Moments 16, 15, and 14 in The Top 25 of 25 Dec 11, 2025

Jaxson Dart's start and Pete Alonso's return to the Mets last winter make the list

Yankees Did Something They Never Do Dec 11, 2025

A Rule 5 pitcher was selected by the Yankees, sending ominous vibes about the off season.

Jeff McNeil is Untradeable at the Moment Dec 11, 2025

Jeff McNeil's surgery is being forgotten.

Corey Seager vs Francisco Lindor Dec 11, 2025

Which shortstop would the Yankees be more interested in?

Evan's Parents Told Him How He Was Conceived Dec 11, 2025

The life and legacy of Evan Roberts gets stranger

Wednesday Full Show: The One Where Pete Alonso Leaves the Mets Dec 10, 2025

For the 2nd straight day, a Mets funeral of sorts. Plus, a huge WFAN announcement.

Hour 1: Pete Alonso Leaves the Mets Dec 10, 2025

A day after leading the show with Edwin Diaz leaving, the Polar Bear ices out the Mets

Hour 2: Mets fans are Angry Dec 10, 2025

Mets fans pound the phones in hour 2 many of which blaming Steve Cohen for focusing too much on a Casino.

Hour 3: Joe Beningo Erupts at the Mets Decision to let Pete Alonso Walk Dec 10, 2025

Joe B joins us for a surprise Wednesday visit and melted down about losing Pete Alonso

Hour 4: The Mets Should Not Trade for Tarik Skubal Dec 10, 2025

Evan doesn’t believe the Mets are in position to trade assets for Tarik Skubal

Moments 19, 18, and 17 in The Top 25 of 25 Dec 10, 2025

An Aaron Judge home run, Torpedo Bats, and Eli Manning make the list

Edwin Diaz Wanted to Be Informed about Devin Williams Dec 10, 2025

Edwin Diaz was reportedly unhappy with the Mets for a nonsensical reason

A New Lineup Announcement Dec 10, 2025

WFAN is revamping it's lineup beginning January 5th.

Positive Tommy Addresses Pete Alonso's Departure Dec 10, 2025

Did Positive Tommy stay positive after Pete has left?

Pete Alonso leaves the Mets as a Hero Dec 10, 2025

Pete Alonso is leaving the Mets with no Mets fans angry with him

Tuesday Full Show: The Edwin Diaz Farewell Show Dec 09, 2025

Edwin Diaz has left for the Dodgers and Evan Roberts patience is tested over the course of 4 hours.

Hour 1: The Mets Lose the Greatest Closer in Franchise History Dec 09, 2025

Edwin Diaz is gone, and Evan Roberts is completely numb

Hour 2: Is Pete Alonso the Next to Leave? Dec 09, 2025

On Paper it feels like Pete Alonso and Scott Boras just got a lot more leverage

Hour 3: Yankees Free Agency Quietness Dec 09, 2025

Should the Yankees be more invested in Bo Bichette?

Hour 4: David Sterns Speaks on Loss of Diaz Dec 09, 2025

David Sterns is comfortable with Devin Williams as the Mets’ closer.

Top 25 in 25 Continues Dec 09, 2025

Moments, 22, 21, and 20 are revealed

Post It and Toasted Dec 09, 2025

Our favorite weekly game is back, in timely fashion.

Are Chances Higher Pete Alonso Returns? Dec 09, 2025

With the departure of Diaz, are the chances higher Pete Alonso returns?

Evan will wear the L to All the Mets-Dodgers Games Dec 09, 2025

Evan deserved punishment after hinting that Diaz would sign back with the Mets last week

Evan is Angry at Everyone with the Mets Dec 09, 2025

A passionate and dare we say unhinges Evan Roberts responds to Edwin Diaz leaving for the Dodgers?

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Looking Ahead to the Draft After Another Loss Dec 09, 2025

Boomer & Gio, Tierney & Licata and Evan & Tiki talk through Jets offseason scenarios after the team was blown out by the Dolphins on Sunday

Hall Calls, Hot Stove and Hijinks | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 09, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): On the latest episode of Rico Brogna we breakdown Jeff Kent getting the call to Cooperstown, Winter Meeting moves and some wild Mets Yankees fantasy trades! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: Mendoza Madness, the Jets Lose Again Dec 08, 2025

The 1st overall pick in the NFL became clearer, the Giants own the pick, the Jets lose again, and much more.

Hour 1: Fernando Mendoza May Have been the Highlight of a Down Jets Weekend Dec 08, 2025

Did losing to the Dolphins lead to thoughts of Fernando Mendoza in Jets’ fans heads?

Hour 2: A Mike Tomlin Report Changes Nothing for the Giants Dec 08, 2025

Adam Schefter reported the Steelers won’t fire Mike Tomlin, but did anyone think his ending was going to be a firing anyway?

Hour 3: Joe Beningo after a Dreary Jets Loss Dec 08, 2025

Joe Beningo in his weekly spot plus The Top 25 of 25 begins.

Hour 4: A Wacky Sunday in the NFL, Including the Potential Death of the Chiefs Dec 08, 2025

Sunday Night Football had wild moments and Andy Reid made a massive mistake

The 25 in 25 Kicks Off Dec 08, 2025

Moments 25,24, and 23 are revealed in our annual countdown.

Jets Lack Of Turnovers Continue Dec 08, 2025

The Jets failed to get a turnover... again.

Would you trade for Mike Tomlin? Dec 08, 2025

How much would you trade if you were the Giants' to acquire Mike Tomlin?

Tiki Barber once said He would Trade Dart and Draft Mendoza if he won the big Ten Championship Dec 08, 2025

Would Mendoza fit as a Giants quarterback?

The Giants Could be the ones to trade back with the Jets in the Draft Dec 08, 2025

A Jets-Giants draft day trade hypothetical.

Best of WFAN Interviews: Joe Benigno, Fran Tarkenton and More Dec 07, 2025

Hear the best interviews of the week, including Joe Benigno on the Jets; SNY NFL reporter Connor Hughes with Evan & Tiki; Brian Baldinger on the Giants with BT & Sal; NFL talk with Nick Kostos from You Better You Bet, and Hall of Famer Fran Tarkenton joins Boomer & Gio in studio.

Best of the Knicks of WFAN: Giannis Rumors Heat Up Dec 07, 2025

Boomer & Gio react to the report that Giannis Antetokounmpo would only approve a trade to the Knicks shortly before he sustained an injury that night. Plus, Evan Roberts has a source that says the Knicks do not want to pursue Giannis; BT and Sal on how Giannis’ injury impacts a potential trade, and discuss which Knicks are untouchable in a potential deal and why Karl-Anthony Towns is the roadblock in the way.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Grading Joe Schoen Dec 07, 2025

Evan & Tiki evaluate the job Joe Schoen has done up to this point as GM of the Giants. Plus, Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata wonder why the Giants are sticking by Schoen and why they’d prefer a new GM to come in and pick a new head coach; Evan & Tiki on whether or not Abdul Carter is a bust; Boomer & Gio take calls on Abdul Carter and weigh in on Mike Tomlin as a possible fit for the Giants.

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Any big moves coming? Dec 06, 2025

This week's Yankee highlights include the worry that has fallen over the fanbase after YES Network's Yankee Hot Stove hinted that the Bombers could be out on Cody Bellinger now that Trent Grisham is back on a $22 million salary. Evan says there should be big concerns in the Bronx, while Sal can't believe the mighty Yankees wouldn't be in on the likes of an Edwin Diaz or thought to be willing to spend big on Kyle Tucker.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Devin Williams in Queens Dec 06, 2025

This week's Mets highlights are full of Devin Williams reactions, from Sal calling it a good move regardless of what happens with Edwin Diaz to Chris McMonigle giving it an incomplete grade, depending on what moves are next. Plus, BT and Sal react to reports of a chilly relationship between Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, and ponder what the market is for Pete Alonso.

Friday Full Show: Jets QB Shuffling into the Future, Mike McCarthy on the Giants Job Dec 05, 2025

A Football Friday with all the trimmings, and Evan comes under fire for making a prediction hat may or may not have been a report.

Hour 1: Kyler Murray will be the Veteran QB Available this Off Season Dec 05, 2025

Is Kyler Murray the next Jets quarterback?

Hour 2: Deshaun Watson’s Future in the NFL, maybe with the Jets? Dec 05, 2025

Watson’s practice window opened, will the Jets eventually be linked to him?

Hour 3: Mike McCarthy Sounds like He Wants the Giants Job Dec 05, 2025

Mike McCarthy wants Jaxson Dart to go out of Bounds Quicker

Hour 4: The Jets-Dolphins Rivalry Never Has Winning Juice Dec 05, 2025

The last time both the Jets and Dolphins both made the playoffs in the same year was 2001.

NFL Picks Dec 05, 2025

The NFL Picks for Week 14 are here.

Caller Carol Can Explain Football to Evan's Kid Dec 05, 2025

The perfect way to teach a young kid football

The Jets uniforms are the Ugliest in Sports Dec 05, 2025

How ugly is Jets green?

Lebron James was Unselfish Thursday Night Dec 05, 2025

Lebron James ended a streak and nobody is talking about it.

Evan is not interested in trading for Lamar Jackson, in a Hypothetical World Dec 05, 2025

Evan said something blasphemous about the Jets QB future..

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 14 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' Dec 05, 2025

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 14 in the NFL. The boys go over what happened in week 13. They pick every game against the spread and Boomer hands out his awards for the season. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Position Player Trade Market | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 05, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets had plenty of holes to fill with Pete Alonso hitting free agency, and then they traded away Brandon Nimmo! What are the Mets plans now? If free agency isn't the way to go will they pursue some trades? Let's see who Evan thinks would make great trade targets. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Thursday Full Show Dec 04, 2025

The Yankees may have a lackluster offseason, Pete Alonso vs. Kyle Schwarber, Bad Tiki makes an appearance, Connor Hughes Interview, and much more.

Cinco De Five-Oh: Five New York Sports Predictions Before the Ground Thaws Dec 04, 2025

Shaun gives his Cinco De Five-Oh.

Hour 4: The Cowboys Could Spell Trouble for Tommy & Cinco De Five-Oh Dec 04, 2025

Tommy may have to wear an L after the Cowboys' success, Cinco De Five-Oh, Picks for the Thursday Night Game, and more.

Hour 3: Bad Tiki & Connor Hughes Joins the Show Dec 04, 2025

Bad Tiki joins the show to give his thoughts on the changes at WFAN, Connor Hughes talks with Evan and Tiki about the Jets and Giants, and much more.

Connor Hughes Interview Dec 04, 2025

Connor Hughes of SNY joins the show to give his thoughts on Joe Schoen's press conference, the Jets, and much more.

Bad Tiki Dec 04, 2025

Bad Tiki joins the show for the first time in six months to give his thoughts on the schedule changes at WFAN.

Hour 2: Evan Reports the Knicks are Out on Giannis & Mets Offseason Targets Dec 04, 2025

Hour 2: Evan and Tiki discuss the possibility of Giannis coming to the Knicks, Mets offseason plans, and much more.

The Knicks are Out on Giannis Dec 04, 2025

Evan says a source told him the Knicks do not have interest in trading for Giannis Antetokounmpo.

Hour 1: Concerns About the Yankees Offseason Dec 04, 2025

Evan and Tiki give their thoughts on the YES Network's hot stove show, insinuating the Yankees may not make big moves this offseason.

The Yankees Offseason May Be Underwhelming Dec 04, 2025

Evan and Tiki break down the Yankees Hot Stove show and why the Yankees might have an underwhelming offseason.

Wednesday Full Show: Joe Schoen gets Graded, Giannis Wants out Dec 03, 2025

Joe Schoen’s report card, the Knicks may be star hunting. The pressure of The Bronx vs Queens.

Hour 1: Grading Joe Schoen Dec 03, 2025

We finally break down exactly what Joe Schoen has done well and what he has done wrong.

Hour 2: Giannis Is Headed out of Milwaukee Dec 03, 2025

Is Giannis New York Bound?

Hour 3: Jets or Giants, Brighter Future? Dec 03, 2025

Who has the brighter future the Jets or the Giants?

Hour 4: Pressure in The Bronx vs Queens Dec 03, 2025

Is there more pressure to pitch for the Yankees than the Mets

Cinco De Five Oh Dec 03, 2025

The 5 worst moves of Joe Schoen's career

Giannis New Team Predictions Dec 03, 2025

Giannis wants out of Milwaukee, so where will he land?

Devin Williams Team Predictions Revisited Dec 03, 2025

Devin WIlliams team predictions, a look back on if any of us predicted the Mets

The NFL Schedule May Begin on Labor Day Down the Line Dec 03, 2025

Boomer dropped a subtle hint about the NFL

Our Grades on Joe Schoen's Job Dec 03, 2025

Joe Schoen gets his grades from our show, finally

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Reaction to MNF Loss to Patriots Dec 03, 2025

The best reactions from the Giants' 33-15 loss to the Patriots from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney & Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki.

Mets Sign Devin Williams | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 03, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Breaking news, the best closer in baseball stays in New York, according to Hoff! That's right, the New York Mets sign Devin Williams to a 3-yr/$50M deal. What does this mean for Edwin Diaz? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tuesday Full Show: Giant Embarrassment, the Mets Take another Former Yankee Dec 02, 2025

The Giants imploded on Monday Night, Joe Schoen imploded in his press conference, and the Mets signed Devin Williams

Hour 1: The Giants Are The New Jets Dec 02, 2025

The Giants hit another rock bottom in the 2025 season on Monday Night

Hour 2: Joe Schoen Met the Media and We React Dec 02, 2025

Joe Schoen did not have a banner day at the podium

Hour 3: The Butt Fumble May Have Gotten Passed by Koo Dec 02, 2025

Was the foot stub on MNF the Giants version of the Butt Fumble?

Hour 4: A Fake Tweet about Abdul Carter was Believed by Many Dec 02, 2025

The legend of Wesley Steinberg grew on Monday Night

Jaxson Dart Rushing Predictions Revisited Dec 02, 2025

Jaxson Dart ran, but didn't accumulate the big yards. So who on our show nailed their stat prediction?

Devin Williams signs with the Mets Dec 02, 2025

Devin Williams is the latest to leave the Yankees for the Mets

Mike Kafka was Terrible Last Night Dec 02, 2025

Did Mike Kafka have the worst coached game for the Giants in a decade

Is Jaxson Dart still Reckless? Dec 02, 2025

Jaxson Dart had more controversial runs on Monday Night

Abdul Carter Bust Watch Dec 02, 2025

Abdul Carter may be showing signs of being a bust, or is he?

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Reactions to the Win Over Atlanta Dec 02, 2025

Boomer & Gio, Tierney & Licata and Evan & Tiki break down the Jets' win over the Falcons and ask if it was worth potentially losing some draft position

Senga's Future, Deep Dive Starting Pitching Trade Market | 'Rico Brogna' Dec 02, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Kodai Senga speaks his peace to the New York Mets. Will David Stearns listen? Do the fans even want David Stearns to listen? Plus, we take deep dive into the Starting Pitching trade market. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: Mike Tomlin to the Giants Increases as a Possibility, the Jets win again, Giants Prep for MNF Dec 01, 2025

We return from the Holiday weekend with Giants coaching dreams dancing through our heads, the Giants get ready for a Dart attack, and the Jets win again.

Hour 1: The Most Important New York Football Story Happened in Pittsburgh Dec 01, 2025

“Fire Tomlin” chants reigned loudly in another Steelers loss, perking up the Giants attention

Hour 2: Jonathon Vilma Said some Crazy things on the Jets Broadcast Dec 01, 2025

Jonathon Vilma thought the Jets should trade draft picks to go get Mac Jones.

Hour 3: Joe Beningo After another Jets Win! Dec 01, 2025

Joe B is in a happy holiday mood and thinks, maybe, the Jets have something here

Hour 4: What can the Giants do to Beat the Patriots? Dec 01, 2025

We preview the Giants heading into New England for Monday Night Football

Cinco De Five Oh Dec 01, 2025

Morash gives 5 reasons the Giants will win tonight

Evan's 5 Year Old Son Had A Lot of Questions at the Jets Game Dec 01, 2025

Evan audio recorded every question his son had at a rainy Jets win and it was fascinating

Evan wouldn't trade Jets Draft Capital for almost Any Quarterback Dec 01, 2025

Outside of Joe Burrow, Evan wants to hold onto the draft capital the Jets have accumulated

The Jets Won With Evan in the Building Dec 01, 2025

The Jets won, tank be damned

Evan further looks back at a Prediction in the Making Dec 01, 2025

Evan calls back a poll of what Giants fans would be looking for

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Happy Tanksgiving! Nov 30, 2025

Evan Roberts is in full tank mode as he is fully invested in the Jets losing out to secure a high draft pick. Plus, Joe Benigno reacts to a Week 12 loss to the Ravens and Chris McMonigle on why there’s nothing for the Jets to build on.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Who Should Be The Next Coach? Nov 29, 2025

Sal Licata makes the case for Bill Belichick as the next Giants head coach. Plus, Brian Baldinger joins BT & Sal on whether or not the Giants are better than their record indicates; Boomer & Gio speculate Chris Shula as the next Giants head coach and riff on how the team is at least entertaining losers; Evan & Tiki discuss if Mike Kafka has ruined his chances at winning the head coaching job;

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Hal speaks, fans fume Nov 28, 2025

This week's Yankee highlights are all about the latest comments from Hal Steinbrenner. BT and Sal went off on the owner lacking emotion and even suggesting that his franchise is not profitable. Evan and Tiki agree that Steinbrenner is better off not speaking about money, and Chris McMonigle says the owner isn't doing himself any favors.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Better without Nimmo? Nov 27, 2025

This week's Mets highlights cover all the reactions to the stunning offseason trade, which sent Brandon Nimmo to Texas for Marcus Semien. Evan says New York is now a worse offensive team, while Tommy Lugauer debates that they are immediately better. Sal Licata doesn't get the emotional attachment to Nimmo, while he and BT break down David Stearns' press conference.

Wednesday Full Show: A Football Friday on a Wednesday Nov 26, 2025

Tanksgiving for Jets fans, Kafka had to answer some funny questions, and much more.

Hour 1: Happy Tanksgiving Jets Fans Nov 26, 2025

Evan feels like he is on an island of 1 as a Jets fan that doesn’t want to lose

Hour 2: Mike Kafka Had To Answer Some Wild Questions Nov 26, 2025

From Trump comments to Nabers’ Tweets Mike Kafka had a wild press conference Wednesday

Hour 3: If Sean McDermott Got Fired, Would he be a Giants Fit Nov 26, 2025

Evan poses an interesting name to watch should he become available for Big Blue

Hour 4: Chiefs-Cowboys Could be the Highest Rated Regular Season game Ever Nov 26, 2025

Thanksgiving Football feels must watch this year, plus our NFL picks.

NFL Picks Nov 26, 2025

Our weekly picks for Thanksgiving Weekend are here

Mike Kafka Got Asked about Trump Criticizing his Playcalling Nov 26, 2025

If a President had an issue with a 4th down decision, would you want to know?

Would the Gi-ETS Make the Playoffs? Nov 26, 2025

The Giants and Jets combo team right now still wouldn't be great

Tommy May get to Potty Train his Cat Nov 26, 2025

Tommy could be able to do something ridiculous with his new pet

Has Dexter Lawrence Played his Last Game as a Giant? Nov 26, 2025

Dexter Lawrence is battling another elbow injury, maybe he requests a trade next?

David Stearns Press Conference, Trading Nimmo | 'Rico Brogna' Nov 26, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): David Stearns meets the media to discuss the Brandon Nimmo trade to the Texas Rangers for Marcus Semien. Evan does what Evan does as we listen to every question and dissect the heck out of every answer! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tuesday Full Show: Giants Coaching Rumors, Mets May Flirt with Bellinger Nov 25, 2025

Bill Belichick may be after NFL jobs after all, Joe Schoen may have a case to stay, The Mets free agency plans, and much more

Hour 1: Bill Belichick Rumors Heat Up Once Again Nov 25, 2025

Josina Anderson says team’s are interested in Bill Belichick, are the Giants one of them? A story as old as time is reignited.

Hour 2: The Case for Keeping Schoen Nov 25, 2025

Evan says we can look at other franchises as to why Joe Schoen should keep his job

Hour 3: The Mets May Truly Be in on Cody Bellinger Nov 25, 2025

Could the Yankees lose a star outfielder to the Mets for a 2nd straight off season?

Hour 4: Mike McCarthy vs Sean Payton Nov 25, 2025

Why do fans not treat Mike McCarthy the same way as Sean Payton?

Cinco De Five Oh Nov 25, 2025

The 5 celebrities we'd like to live near

Nights vs Overnights Nov 25, 2025

Evan asks an important question to Lugey and McMonigle

Going for it on 4th Down Debate Nov 25, 2025

Going for it on 4th down becomes an interesting question when asking what you prefer your opponent to do

Mike Kafka Has Hurt his Chances at Full time Head Coach Nov 25, 2025

Has Mike Kafka already coached himself out of becoming the full time guy for Big Blue?

Post It and Toasted Nov 25, 2025

Our favorite weekly game is back

Best of Giants on WFAN: Shane Bowen fired after loss to Lions Nov 25, 2025

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the latest on Big Blue from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney & Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki. Reacting to the Giants' crushing loss in Detroit -- and the team's decision to part ways with defensive coordinator Shane Bowen in the aftermath.

Brandon Nimmo Traded To Rangers | 'Rico Brogna' Nov 25, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): David Stearns did the unthinkable. He traded Brandon Nimmo! Where is Nimmo landing? The Texas Rangers. Who do the Mets get back? Marcus Semien. Evan and Hoff react to what is a blockbuster trade to start the early portion of the offseason! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: Shane Bowen Fired, Brandon Nimmo Traded Nov 24, 2025

Shane Bowen finally gets axed, the Mets shake up their core, Hal Steinbrenner meets the media, and much more

Hour 1: The Dismissal of Shane Bowen Nov 24, 2025

The Giants finally let go of their defensive coordinator after a 5th double digit blown lead

Hour 2: Malik Nabers Tweets about Giants Disgust Nov 24, 2025

Malik Nabers posted then deleted a Tweet taking a shot at Giants’ coaching decisions

Hour 3: Joe Beningo On the Nimmo Trade and the Jets Loss Nov 24, 2025

Joe B kicks off the third hour and isn’t happy with David Stearns

Hour 4: Tiki Predicted Nimmo Would Be Traded Nov 24, 2025

Tiki Barber was very much in front of this Mets trade

Cinco De Five Oh Nov 24, 2025

The 5 takeaway's from Hal Steinbrenner's press conference

Dexter Lawrence Was Off the Field in Overtime Nov 24, 2025

Why was Dexter Lawrence actually off the field in Overtime?

Evan vs Tommy on Nimmo Nov 24, 2025

Evan and Tommy get into a heated argument about what is next for the Mets

Kafka's Decision to not kick the Field Goal at the end of Regulation Nov 24, 2025

Did Mike Kafka actually make a bad decision at the end of the 4th quarter?

Evan's Reaction of Nimmo being traded Nov 24, 2025

Evan gives his thoughts on the trading of a home grown Met

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Wrestling with Dysfunction Nov 23, 2025

The recent actions from Cam Skattebo and Abdul Carter have Gio calling for the Giants to clean house across the coaching staff and front office. Plus, Boomer lights into Carter and other NFL players for lacking a sense of responsibility; BT & Sal have strong feelings on the Skattebo WWE appearance; Phil Simms joins BT & Sal to talk all things Giants; Evan & Tiki dive deeper into Skattebo's online streaming presence and analyze Jay Glazer's top coaching candidates for Big Blue.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Tyrod Time Nov 22, 2025

The Jets officially make the switch from Justin Fields to Tyrod Taylor and Boomer & Gio give their take. Plus, BT & Sal listen and react to Aaron Glenn on switching to Taylor; Evan & Tiki find amusement in Glenn’s press conferences; C-Mac reacts to the QB change, and Keith McPherson says we don’t deserve the “same old Jets.”

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Blueprint to best offseason Nov 22, 2025

This week's Mets highlights dive into some blockbuster hypothetical trades, including one that would send Francisco Lindor to the Yankees and another that brings Tarik Skubal to Queens. Plus, Sal Licata has heard a Pete Alonso return is unlikely, while Evan Roberts says Alonso HAS to be re-signed.

Lions -10.5 vs Giants | 'Cash the Ticket' Nov 22, 2025

From 'Cash The Ticket' (subscribe here): Costa has a stat about the Lions after a loss you don't want to miss. Download the latest episode of Cash the Ticket today. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Did Trent Grisham ruin the offseason? Nov 22, 2025

This week's Yankee highlights include all of the reaction to Trent Grisham accepting the qualifying offer to return to the Bronx. Boomer doesn't see the big deal, and Sal says it shouldn't impact the team's spending this winter. But BT believes this could be the start of an awful Yankees offseason, and C-Mac says the heat is now on Hal Steinbrenner to spend.

Deep Dive Free Agency (Bullpen Arms) | 'Rico Brogna' Nov 22, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets have plenty of holes to fill in the bullpen. Do they have the arms needed to last a full season or does David Stearns look in free agency. It's just another piece to a huge puzzle that the Mets have to fix this offseason. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Friday Full Show: No Dart, Cashman on Grisham, and Much More Nov 21, 2025

A football Friday with all the trimmings including a Giant quarterback problem and plenty of baseball off season discussion.

Hour 1: Jaxson Dart Has Been Ruled Out Nov 21, 2025

Did Sunday’s Giants game lose ay excitement it had left?

Hour 2: Brian Cashman Comments on Grisham Accepting the QO Nov 21, 2025

The Brian Cashman annual sleep out event brought some answers about the Yankees outfield plan

Hour 3: The Chiefs Missing the Playoffs Would Make it Boring Nov 21, 2025

Do we actually need Kansas City to rally and make the playoffs?

Hour 4: Giants-Lions Could Become Embarrassing Nov 21, 2025

With Dart the Giants game has lost luster, can they manage to keep it close?

NFL Picks Nov 21, 2025

The weekly NFL Picks are here, with a new leaderboard

Cashman Can't Say Meme Nov 21, 2025

Did Brian Cashman not know how to say a word everyone else can say perfectly fine?

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 12 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti' Nov 21, 2025

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 12 in the NFL. The guys tackle everything in the NFL for week 12. Eagles can win ugly. What teams are in panic mode? Cowboys deals are paying off. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Bills Super Bowl Chances Are Still High to Evan Nov 21, 2025

Evan thinks by becoming road warriors the Bills may still go to the Super Bowl

Why Watch New York Football Sunday? Nov 21, 2025

The Giants and Jets have truly uninteresting games' on tap Sunday

Al Michaels' Had No Juice on a Wild Hook and Ladder Nov 21, 2025

Did Al Michaels' not get excited enough on Thursday Night Football?

Thursday Full Show: Pete Alonso Needs to Be Back, Skattebo is a Legend Nov 20, 2025

Pete Alonso's stock is still up with Mets fans, Cam Skattebo loves being a Giant, Mike McCarthy as a HC Candidate, and much more

Hour 1: The Mets Need To Get Pete Alonso Done Nov 20, 2025

Evan has gotten the memo from Mets fans, the drum has to be banged more for Pete Alonso to return

Hour 2: A Quirky Ending to Knicks-Mavs Nov 20, 2025

The ending to Knicks-Mavs was wild, plus Josh Hart stealing candy.

Hour 3: Cam Skattebo is a Streaming Star Nov 20, 2025

Cam Skattebo is building a side internet career by the day

Hour 4: Fernando Mendoza is Gaining Steam Nov 20, 2025

Fernando Mendoza is exciting fans and even Urban Meyer the more he speaks

LUGASH Debate Series Nov 20, 2025

Mike McCarthy vs the Field for a Giants coach to take them to the playoffs

Evan Won't Eat a Nut Nov 20, 2025

Evan refuses to put a nut in his mouth despite it having sat on his desk

Pete Alonso as a US President Nov 20, 2025

Juan Soto recommends Pete Alonso as the Met that could be President

Andrew in Virginia Attended Dick Cheney's Funeral Nov 20, 2025

A caller to the show went to Dick Cheney's funeral and recapped the people he saw

Jason Kidd Pokes at the Knicks and it Airs on the Knicks Channel Nov 20, 2025

Jason Kidd lifts the Nets franchise up and the Knicks let it air

The Mets Are Blowing Up Plenty | 'Rico Brogna' Nov 20, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): According to Jeff Passan's latest article, the New York Mets are looking to do a lot during this offseason. It's not just about adding to the team, but what they're looking to get rid of as well! Names like Brandon Nimmo, Jeff McNeil, Mark Vientos, Luisangel Acuna, Brett Baty were all named to be players who are available on the trade market. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Wednesday Full Show Nov 19, 2025

FULL SHOW: Aaron Glenn keeps things entertaining for the Jets, re-living Jon in Maspeth's call, was Aaron Judge the reason Trent Grisham was brought back, Evan hears of a possible Mets trade for Mike Trout, the worst free-agent signings in Mets history, and much more.

Cinco De Five-Oh & Worst Mets Free Agent Signings of All-Time Nov 19, 2025

Shaun gives his Cinco De Five-Oh and Tommy, Evan, and Shaun debate the worst Free Agent signings in Mets history.

Hour 4: Debating Mike McCarthy as the Future Giants Head Coach Nov 19, 2025

Hour 4: Evan and Shaun take calls on possible future Giants coaches and Shaun, Loogy, and Evan debate the merit of Mike McCarthy. That and much more.

Should the Mets Trade Brandon Nimmo For Mike Trout? Nov 19, 2025

Evan got a DM saying the Mets might trade Brandon Nimmo for Mike Trout.....Would it be a good move?

Hour 3: Evan Hears Talk of a Crazy Mets Trade Nov 19, 2025

Hour 3: Evan gets a DM of a possible Mets trade and the guys break it down. Plus, some potential Giants coaches and much more.

Hour 2: Is Aaron Judge the Reason Trent Grisham is Back? Nov 19, 2025

Hour 2: Evan and Shaun discuss the possibility that Aaron Judge wanted Trent Grisham back. That, plus reliving Jon in Maspeth's call and much more.

A Caller is Going to Dick Cheney's Funeral Nov 19, 2025

A caller asks Evan what he should say if he runs into President George W. Bush.

Aaron Glenn Explains the Change at Quarterback Nov 19, 2025

Short Clip: The guys break down Aaron Glenn making Tyrod Taylor the starting Quarterback.

Hour 1: Aaron Glenn Brings Some Entertainment to the Jets Nov 19, 2025

Evan, Shaun, and Loogy give their thoughts on Aaron Glenn's press conference announcing Tyrod Taylor as the starting Quarterback and much more.

Tuesday Full Show: Yankee Off Season Wars, Cam Skattebo Causes a Stir Nov 18, 2025

Kyle Tucker vs Cody Bellinger, Grisham takes his offer, Cam Skattebo angers WFAN hosts, and much more

Hour 1: Where has the Kyle Tucker love Gone? Nov 18, 2025

Why are Yankee fans not pounding the table for Kyle Tucker?

Hour 2: Brandon Nimmo Trade Winds Nov 18, 2025

Should Brandon Nimmo, with a full no trade clause, actually be shopped by the Mets?

Hour 3: Trent Grisham Accepts the Yankees Qualifying Offer Nov 18, 2025

Trent Grisham is back with the Yankees in surprising Tuesday news to jumpstart the off season

Hour 4: Cinco De Rookio Nov 18, 2025

Who has been the best rookie in NY Sports in 2025?

Mike Brown Used a Challenge Way Too Early Nov 18, 2025

Mike Brown learned a huge lesson and owned it

Jon in Maspeth is Ticked at Brian Cashman Nov 18, 2025

Jon In Maspeth sounds like a Frank the tank off brand version after Trent Grisham accepts his qualifying offer

Post It and Toasted Nov 18, 2025

Our favorite weekly game is back

A Lindor to the Yankees Hypothetical Nov 18, 2025

A Yankee-Met trade, who says no?

Cody Bellinger Mega Contract would be a Concern Nov 18, 2025

Would Cody Bellinger's contract becoming a mega deal worry you?

Best of Giants on WFAN: Reactions to Week 11 Loss vs. Packers Nov 18, 2025

The best reactions to the Giants' Week 11 loss to Green Bay from Boomer & Gio, BT & Sal, and Evan & TIki

Deep Dive Free Agency (Position Players), Josh Naylor Signs | 'Rico Brogna' Nov 18, 2025

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets have plenty of holes to fill in the batting order. Do they have the players in the minors or could David Stearns look in free agency. It's just another piece to a huge puzzle that the Mets have to fix this offseason. Plus, Josh Naylor re-signs with the Mariners! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Monday Full Show: Another Giant Embarrassment Nov 17, 2025

The Giants lose and have no faith in Shane Bowen. Abdul Carter gets punished, Jay Glazer gives a coach list to watch, and much more

Hour 1: The Giants Players’ Have Had Enough of Shane Bowen Nov 17, 2025

Another blown 4th quarter lead had Tiki seeing through defensive players’ comments

Hour 2: Abdul Carter was Benched for the Opening Drive Nov 17, 2025

A damning report about Abdul Carter after he was benched is released

Hour 3: Jay Glazer Gives 6 Giants Coach Candidates Nov 17, 2025

Is Mike McCarthy a front runner for the Giants Job?

Hour 4: Sam Darnold May Have Turned into a Pumpkin Nov 17, 2025

Did Sam Darnold prove again that he is not a big game quarterback?

Evan misuses another Word Nov 17, 2025

Did Evan make up a word and die on the sword?

Cam Skattebo is going to Monday Night Raw Nov 17, 2025

Will anybody be upset that a banged up Cam Skattebo is headed to MSG on a Monday Night?

Alternate Terms for Tanking Nov 17, 2025

Is there a better term to use for Tanking?

Giants Players' Get Handed Jobs Due to Draft Status Nov 17, 2025

The Giants continue to reward players' who don't earn it

The Giants Results Remained the Same Nov 17, 2025

Nothing changed for the Giants after a change at Head Coach

Best of Interviews on WFAN: Marlon Wayans, Jay Leno and More! Nov 16, 2025

Listen to the best interviews from the week on WFAN, including Marlon Wayans, Jay Leno, Brian Baldinger, Connor Hughes, Joe Benigno and Nick Bickall.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Should Schoen Stay or Go? Nov 16, 2025

Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata wonder if anyone in the Giants front office deserves the benefit of the doubt. Plus, BT & Sal discuss if Joe Schoen is really on the hot seat or not; Evan & Tiki wonder if the Giants head coaching job is attractive with Schoen still around; they also discuss an Adam Schefter report on the next possible Giants coach; Boomer & Gio riff on the idea of Bill Belichick coaching the Giants and react to Jameis Winston being named the starter vs. the Packers.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Will Cohen spend big again? Nov 15, 2025

This week's Mets highlights include reaction to David Stearns speaking at the GM Meetings in Las Vegas. BT and Sal want Stearns to be aggressive in resolving the Pete Alonso situation to move on to other roster needs, and they debate if Brandon Nimmo can be traded to free up payroll. Plus, Boomer and Gio react to the wild story of Steve Cohen auctioning off a golden toilet, and the Evan and Tiki crew play MLB free agency bingo.

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Does Paul Skenes want the Bronx? Nov 15, 2025

This week's Yankees highlights include reactions to the bombshell report that Paul Skenes told a Pirates teammate that he wants to join the Yankees. BT and Sal agree that the Yanks should trade the farm for the Cy Young winner, while Chris McMonigle throws cold water on the report. Plus, multiple hosts agree that the Bombers cannot afford to lose Cody Bellinger this offseason.

Best of the Jets on WFAN: Reactions to 27-14 Loss to Patriots Nov 15, 2025

Hear the best takeaways from the Jets’ Week 11 loss to the Patriots from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki.

Friday Full Show: Jets Misfortune, Hafley comes to MetLife, and Jameis Starts Nov 14, 2025

A Football Friday is here and we recap another miserable Jets playoff loss and a Giants coach audition awaits us.

Hour 1: Do the Jets trust Justin Fields? Nov 14, 2025

The Jets have another lifeless offensive performance, but who is that on?

Hour 2: Jeff Hafley Auditions in The Meadowlands Nov 14, 2025

The Packers DC is a Jersey guy who may be ready to show the Giants he can be their next head coach

Hour 3: Joe Beningo On the Jets loss and Mets Off Season Nov 14, 2025

Joe B after a depressing Jets loss and on the potential of losing Pete Alonso

Hour 4: The Jameis Winston Experience Is Here Nov 14, 2025

It is time for Jameis Winston, the good and the bad, to lead the Giants

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected