Driven by Father Joe’s twin sister’s unwavering determination to get justice for her brother, an unlikely friendship with an outcast Priest and the autopsy tech who alongside the famous Dr. Cyril Wecht, exhume the body, perform a second autopsy and find disturbing evidence that should prove this could not have been a suicide. From the creators of Seven Deadly Sinners comes a podcast investigating a True Cold Case, Hosts and Producers Rachael O’Brien and Greg Hunter work along side Father Joe’s twin sister Sue and former autopsy tech, Joe Wedge, to expose the Diocese for what it really is – Deadly. For years the Buffalo Diocese has been covering up abuse, hiding money, exploiting children and adult men alike – This podcast investigates, boots on the ground in Buffalo, and unravels the cover up of the mysterious death of Father Joe Moreno.
S2 Ep11: The Last Pope of All Time: The End of Vatican II
Sep 08, 2025
Show notes
In this episode of Deadly Diocese, we explore the rise of Pope Leo XIV and the crisis facing the Catholic Church today. From the broken promises of Vatican II to the shadow of global abuse scandals, this story asks: can the Church reclaim its moral authority, or are we witnessing the final chapter of a 2,000-year-old institution?
S2 Ep10: An Interview with Captain Gene Gomulka - Part 2
May 29, 2025
Show notes
In part two former deputy chaplain of the U.S. Marine Corps, Gene Gomulka, details how alter boys and seminarians are groomed by the elders of the Catholic Church and why it persists to this day.
S2 Ep9: Captain Gene Thomas Gomulka
May 02, 2025
Show notes Gene Thomas Gomulka is a retired Navy Captain and Chaplain, author, investigative reporter, and screenwriter. He also works pro bono as a sex abuse victims’ advocate who helps those who were sexually abused or unjustly reprised against by Church leaders and their attorneys for reporting abuse. Gomulka earned a B.A. in Philosophy from St. Francis University and an S.T.L. from the University of Saint Thomas Aquinas (Angelicum) in Rome. After serving for five years as an associate pastor in State College, PA and teaching courses in Dogmatic Theology and Liturgy at St. Francis Seminary in addition to serving as the Diocesan Respect Life Director, he entered active duty service in 1980 and retired with the rank of Navy Captain (O6) in 2004. Saint John Paul II named Gomulka a Prelate of Honor in 1999 with the honorific title of “Monsignor.” After he and Dominican Father Thomas Doyle suffered reprisals in 2004 from then-Archbishop Edwin O’Brien for their work in exposing and combating clerical sex abuse in the Catholic Church, Gomulka retired after 24 years of active duty military service and took a leave of absence from the priesthood. During his leave Gomulka published The Survival Guide for Marriage in the Military and spoke at military family conferences on bases throughout the country. When it became clear that his bishop who had been covering up sex abuse did not want a priest abuse advocate working in his diocese, Gomulka later married and was blessed with twin children, Luke and Sasha, who were born on his birthday. Upset with the ongoing sex abuse of minors and vulnerable adults in the Catholic Church, Gomulka believes that bishops and priests who engage in or cover up sex abuse should be incarcerated, laicized, or excommunicated. Among all the titles he has been afforded throughout his life (e.g., Father, Monsignor, Chaplain, Padre, Captain), his favorite title is “Dad."
S2: Security Camera Footage Reveal Exclusive - This Thursday April 17th
Apr 15, 2025
Show notes
We’ve got a big episode coming up exclusively on Patreon revealing the secrets stored within the security camera footage at St. Lawrence the day Father Joey Died - with the help of Gina we were able to unlock hours and hours from multiple angles of security camera footage that we’ve combed through and will be showing exclusively on our Patreon THIS THURSDAY April 17th at 7pm EST - we will have a live Q and A during the episode and the entire episode will be available following the broadcast only on Patreon. Don’t miss it. LINK TO THE DEADLY PATREON: www.patreon.com/DeadlyPodcast
S2 Ep8: An Interview With Nick Bryant Part Two
Mar 08, 2025
Show notes
Rachael, Gina and our friend Frank from season 1 continue their conversation with author and journalist Nick Bryant for a revealing interview exposing hard truths about pedophiles, satanic cults and human trafficking rings....
S2 Ep7: An Interview With Nick Bryant
Feb 21, 2025
Show notes
Rachael, Gina and our friend Frank from season 1 sit down with author and journalist Nick Bryant for a telling conversation on Buffalo political figures, the Jesters, Diddy and more....
S2 Ep6: Unmasking Buffalo's Corruption: BuffNet and The Former New York Attorney General
Feb 06, 2025
Show notes
Buffalo, New York, has long been a hub for corruption, with a deeply interconnected web involving the Diocese of Buffalo, local law enforcement, organized crime, and influential political figures. At the center of this network is Dennis Vacco, former New York State Attorney General, whose career reveals patterns of systemic protectionism, ethical lapses, and selective prosecution. His involvement in high-profile cases like BuffNet, his alleged ties to organized crime, and his protection of the Diocese highlight a broader culture of impunity. This episode examines Vacco's tenure, Operation Ripcord, and his role as legal counsel for the Diocese of Buffalo.
S2 Ep5: An Interview With Kevin Brunn
Jan 24, 2025
Show notes
Kevin's story is a tough one to hear but we appreciate his bravery and determination to get justice for all of the victims of the Buffalo diocese.
S2 Ep4: Interviews With A Priest On His Deathbed Part 2
Jan 08, 2025
Show notes
The last conversations with Father Art Smith continue.
S2 Ep3: Interviews With A Priest On His Deathbed
Dec 25, 2024
Show notes
Gina boldly confronts her Uncle Father Art Smith before he passed about Father Joe's Death.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
