Cincinnati's Crime Vault | Beyond the Broadcast

28: SOLVED CASE - Avondale Jane Doe Identified Jun 06, 2025

Back in 2018, an unidentified woman was discovered dead and partially buried near an apartment complex in Avondale, a Cincinnati, Ohio neighborhood.

For years, she was known only as the "Avondale Jane Doe" or the "Rose Lady."

Fast forward to 2025... and that woman has been identified. Thanks to the work of investigators with the Hamilton County Coroner's Office, the Ohio BCI, and the FBI, Patricia Collina Goodwin's family members finally have some answers.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt shares the full update on this investigation and breaks down how DNA and forensic genetic genealogy solved this case.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

UPDATE: Avondale Jane Doe Case SOLVED May 30, 2025

In this brief bonus episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt shares that there is a significant update in the Avondale Jane Doe case that was previously covered in the podcast.

A detailed episode breaking down the news will be available soon.

In the meantime, you can listen to episodes 23 and 24 of season two to catch up on the Avondale Jane Doe case.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

27: Case Unsolved - Father of Four Gunned Down in Auto Shop in 2013 Apr 23, 2025

In 2013, a father of four, who built his own business, was shot in cold blood while inside his Hamilton, Ohio shop. His brother was with him, but was not able to see the killer's face.

And to this day.. Broderick McGhee's murderer hasn't been identified.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt takes a look at the unsolved murder of Broderick McGhee. She speaks with relatives about the pain of his passing, shares what we know about the attack, and breaks down why his loved ones believe he was targeted.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

26: Suspect Identified in 1974 Disappearance of Ed Nichols Mar 28, 2025

Prosecutors and detectives in Boone County, Kentucky have made significant progress in a cold case - the 1974 disappearance and presumed murder of Ed Nichols.

On the day Nichols vanished, he was reportedly going hunting with a friend... but investigators say he was actually shot and killed because of a dispute over a woman.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt takes a look at the Ed Nichols case and shares the latest developments that led to the identification of a suspect.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

25: The 1974 Disappearance of Ronald Vonderheide Feb 28, 2025

Decades after Ronald Vonderheide seemingly vanished without a trace, detectives are using DNA databases to try to track him down. They say their evidence shows he's no longer alive... and may have been the victim of foul play.

But Vonderheide's mother has a different theory.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt sits down with the detective who has worked this cold case to talk about what happened the day Vonderheide vanished, what they have done to advance the investigation, and break down what we know about Vonderheide's life at the time.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

16: Pike Co. Massacre - Jake and Angela Wagner Learn Their Fate Jan 17, 2025

Four members of the Wagner family are accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in April 2016 in what has been called the Pike County Massacre.

Now, two of them, Jake and Angela Wagner, have been sentenced.

In this episode of Season One of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down Jake and Angela Wagner's sentencing - including the victim impact statements, statements made by the Wagners themselves, and a decision from the judge that shocked many.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

Pike Co. Massacre UPDATE #5: Angela and Jake Wagner's Sentencing Dec 31, 2024

Jessica Schmidt gives an update on the Pike County massacre case, specifically related to the upcoming sentencings of Jake Wagner, Angela Wagner, and Rita Newcomb and the upcoming trial of George "Billy" Wagner III. She also addresses some unresolved issues related to the case, including the death penalty and a change of venue.

Pike Co. Massacre UPDATE #4: Judge Grants Change of Venue Nov 26, 2024

Jessica Schmidt gives an update on the upcoming trial of George "Billy" Wagner III, who is set to go on trial in the Pike County Massacre case in January 2025. There are two significant developments: the judge issued rulings on the defense's change of venue request and the death penalty.

24 [Part Two]: New Technology Helping Coroners Close Cases Oct 16, 2024

*Note: we encourage you to listen to part one of this two-part series, episode 23, before listening to this episode.

At the Hamilton County, Ohio Coroner's Office, the investigators, analysts, and technicians are trained in a number of areas. They handle autopsies, even from other counties, help police with murder investigations, and identify Jane and John Does.
It can be challenging work, but they're hopeful that advancing technology will help them solve even more cases.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt goes behind the scenes to see the latest technology at their disposal and talks with Dr. Lakshmi Sammarco about how they have already used some of the tools to return names to the unidentified.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

TV Version of This Story

23 [Part One]: Potential DNA Breakthrough Could ID Avondale Jane Doe Sep 30, 2024

In 2018, an unidentified woman was discovered dead and partially buried near an apartment complex in Avondale, which is a Cincinnati neighborhood.

She became known as the "Avondale Jane Doe" or the "Rose Lady."

Dr. Lakshmi Sammarco and her team at the Hamilton County, Ohio Coroner's Office have never given up on the case. Since the day the woman was found, they've pursued every avenue they can to try to find out her identity.

And now, they're revealing that with help from the FBI and Ohio's Bureau of Criminal Investigation, they're closer than ever before.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks with Dr. Sammarco about the work they've done on this case and breaks down why it could be solved very soon.

In part two, episode 24, Jessica learns more about the latest technology and the newest tools being used in Jane and John Doe cases.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

TV Version of This Story

Pike Co. Massacre UPDATE #3: An Appeal and Upcoming Trial Aug 21, 2024

Jessica Schmidt gives an update on season one by explaining where the Pike County Massacre case stands right now, as of August 2024. She touches on George "Billy" Wagner's upcoming trial and George Wagner the 4th's pending appeal.

22: The FBI's Highway Serial Killings Initiative Aug 01, 2024

According to the FBI, right now, there are multiple serial killers, who could be connected to dozens and dozens of unsolved murders, operating in the United States.
Investigators are actively working to track the murderers down by focusing in on a specific pool of suspects - long haul truckers - through the agency's Highway Serial Killings Initiative.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks with Frank Figluizzi, a former FBI Assistant Director, about his research on this topic. She also speaks with a truck driver and trucking instructor who offers perspective on the job, the industry, and the HSK initiative.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

21: The Easter Sunday Massacre Jun 28, 2024

Even decades later, a case known as the Easter Sunday Massacre continues to haunt the Hamilton, Ohio community.

In 1975, James "Jim" Ruppert murdered 11 members of his own family.
Journalist Karen Holcomb first became familar with the case in the 1990s, when she was a reporter for the Journal News. She didn't know at the time that her coverage would lead to her marrying the prosecutor's son, and, decades later, taking her late father-in-law's words and crafting them into a book that details the trauma left behind after this tragedy.
Warning: some of the details in this episode may be disturbing to hear.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks with Holcomb and her husband about the horrific killings, the aftermath, and about how the case is still impacting people today.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

TV Version of This Story

20: INTERVIEW - UPDATE on the 1997 Possible Abduction & Murder of Laney Gwinner May 15, 2024

NOTE: We suggest listening to episode 19 before listening to this one.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault: Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt interviews Randy Hubbard, a high school teacher who has investigated Laney Gwinner's case and is writing a book about it.

Hubbard's students have created a podcast of their own, where they talk about the cases they have been working on: Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

19: "She Definitely Was A Fighter": The 1997 Possible Abduction & Murder of Laney Gwinner Apr 29, 2024

More than 20 years after she disappeared and was later found dead, Laney Gwinner’s murder remains unsolved, and her vehicle is still missing.

Police believe she vanished after she went to a bowling alley in Fairfield, Ohio with a friend in December 1997. She left sometime around 1 a.m. to go to her boyfriend's house, but she never made it there.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks with a retired detective about why he believes Gwinner was abducted, details how a local teacher got involved with the case, and explains how volunteers have helped search for Gwinner's car.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

18: INTERVIEW - Inside the Mind of A Serial Killer Mar 15, 2024

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt speaks with clinical psychologist Dr. Rachel Toles, who is currently touring the country for her show "The Psychology of Serial Killers and Why They Captivate Us."

Dr. Toles, who is making a stop in Cincinnati, shares some of her research on serial killers, gives her perspective on whether serial killers still exist today, talks about nine common factors found during her studies, and breaks down why she believes so many people are interested in true crime. She also touches on mass shooters and how she hopes to help teachers.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

Pike Co. Massacre UPDATE #2: Billy Wagner's Trial Delayed Mar 07, 2024

The trial for George “Billy” Wagner III has been delayed until 2025. Jessica Schmidt gives an update.

17: Stripped Naked and Dumped - Detectives Reopen 1975 Cold Case Mar 04, 2024

It's been nearly 50 years since a young woman was strangled, stripped naked, and dumped on the side of the road.
Even decades later, Cora Durham's sister is dedicated to finding out who is responsible, and now, Warren County, Ohio detectives are taking a new look at the case.
In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks with Cora's sister about her search for justice and speaks with a detective who calls the case an active investigation.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

16: ‘Someone Shot My Husband’: Deadly Home Invasion Turned Cold Case Jan 31, 2024

Thirteen years later, a deadly home invasion in Fairfield Township, Ohio is considered a cold case.
Police believe the victim, Joe Patterson, was shot and killed in his own home, just feet away from his wife and stepchildren. Detectives are still trying to track down the gunmen who are responsible for what's been described as a vicious, targeted attack.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt shares the 911 call made after Patterson was shot, speaks with relatives about how the tragedy has impacted them, and gathers the latest from detectives.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

15: The 6th Street Cold Case Dec 30, 2023

For the first time, relatives of a woman who was murdered in downtown Cincinnati are speaking publicly to call for justice.

In this episode of Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the newest theories in the unsolved murder of Ernestine Hurt - theories connected to love.. money... revenge.. and retaliation.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

14: The Execution-Style Killing of A Vet and His Dogs Nov 30, 2023

West Chester, Ohio detectives have described George Gibson, a veterinary pathologist, as a good man... but they also say he had a lot of secrets, and that's made it hard for them to solve his murder.
It was a brutal crime - a planned ambush - that led to Gibson's death and to the death of his dogs.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt speaks with detectives about what secrets they uncovered while looking into Gibson's murder.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

13: Where is Timothy Stanton? Oct 25, 2023

This year marks nine years since a Cincinnati man disappeared without a trace.

Timothy Stanton's family believes, to this day, that the 40-year-old father of two was met with foul play.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt speaks with Timothy's relatives about where he was last seen, what they know about his disappearance, and why they're desperate to find him.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Timothy Stanton

12: What Happened to the Mysterious Man Living on Lawnview? Sep 25, 2023

Police are pursuing every lead they can in the murder of a Springdale, Ohio man, who was found brutally beaten to death inside his home in 1999.

There's been DNA testing, surveillance, and even an arrest, but the case remains unsolved.

Detectives believe what could be holding them back is what little they know about the victim, Frederick Walker.
In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt talks about the crime scene, the people of interest, and detectives' efforts to learn more about the victim.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Frederick Walker

11: Two Teens Murdered By Same Creek The Same Year Aug 28, 2023

In 2012, two Fairfield, Ohio teens were found dead by the same creek. Joey Oakley, 19-years-old, was discovered dead months after 15-year-old Chelsea Johnson was stabbed to death.

Oakley's case, like Johnson's, remains unsolved and open. Although police have not connected the two cases, their families believe there may be something tying them together.

Now, for the first time, Oakley's sister is ready to talk about her brother's case.

Warning: some of the details in this episode may be graphic.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down what happened to Oakley and why loved ones believe Oakley and Johnson's cases may be linked.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Joey Oakley's Case

10: Family Demands Answers in Brutal Stabbing of Teen Jul 17, 2023

For more than a decade, relatives of Chelsea Johnson have tirelessly fought to keep her memory alive after someone stabbed the 15-year-old to death in Fairfield, Ohio in 2012.

Now her loved ones, frustrated with a lack of justice, are giving us insight into what happened before Chelsea vanished and was later found dead. They're also telling us more about a man who's long been considered a person of interest in this case and are sharing new details about the crime scene.

Warning: some of the details in this episode may be graphic.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down what happened the day Johnson was last seen alive, explains what we know about her murder, and breaks down why relatives are fed up with the investigation.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Chelsea Johnson's Case

9: 1980s Mystery: Young Mom Gunned Down at Work Jun 12, 2023

More than 35 years after a young mother was gunned down at work, Pierce Township Police in Ohio hope shining a spotlight on the cold case could help them solve it.

Detectives have investigated the murder of 19-year-old Amy Diesman from the very beginning, sometimes getting the help of other agencies along the way.

Now, one detective is opening up the case files to show us the investigation in a whole new light.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down what happened the day Diesman was killed, explains what detectives have done with the case, and details where it stands now.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Amy Diesman's Case

8: The Missing Victims of Serial Killer Samuel Little May 22, 2023

More than two years after one of the most notorious serial killers in United States history died in prison, the FBI is still trying to identify and find some of his victims. Several of the "Jane Does" are connected to the Greater Cincinnati area.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down what we know about the victims.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

7: The Deadly Attack on Pregnant Mother Brittany Stykes Apr 17, 2023

In August 2013, a pregnant mother was gunned down while driving in Brown County, Ohio. The gunshots also struck her young daughter, who miraculously survived.
The Brittany Stykes murder case continues to gain traction on social media and is getting national publicity. There's no question those who were closest to Brittany are dedicated to her case.

However, the person who killed Brittany has yet to be identified.

Investigators do say they are using some incredibly new technology that could bring them their next big break.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the heartbreaking case, speaks with relatives of Brittany, and finds out where the investigation stands today.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Brittany Stykes

6: The Brutal Stephenson Murders and A Possible Connection to Delphi (Part Two) Mar 27, 2023

One of Northern Kentucky's most horrific killings remains unsolved nearly 12 years later, but the detectives working the case are leaving no stone unturned.

Bill and Peggy Stephenson, a beloved couple, were discovered dead inside of their own home in May 2011. It is considered to be a complex and haunting case that's deeply impacted the community.

In recent months, the investigation has led detectives in several different directions, including to Indiana to look into a possible connection to the highly publicized Delphi murders. They're also pursuing potential breaks in the case using a DNA profile.

This is the second of two episodes covering this case.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the disturbing case, learns about the lives of Bill and Peggy Stephenson, and digs into the latest leads in the investigation.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on the Stephensons

5: The Brutal Stephenson Murders and A Possible Connection to Delphi (Part One) Mar 20, 2023

One of Northern Kentucky's most horrific killings remains unsolved nearly 12 years later, but the detectives working the case are leaving no stone unturned.

Bill and Peggy Stephenson, a beloved couple, were discovered dead inside of their own home in May 2011. It is considered to be a complex and haunting case that's deeply impacted the community.

In recent months, the investigation has led detectives in several different directions, including to Indiana to look into a possible connection to the highly publicized Delphi murders. They're also pursuing potential breaks in the case using a DNA profile.

This is the first of two episodes covering this case.

In Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the disturbing case, learns about the lives of Bill and Peggy Stephenson, and digs into the latest leads in the investigation

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on the Stephensons

Pike County Massacre UPDATE #1: March 2023 Update Mar 01, 2023

Billy Wagner is one of four family members accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in April 2016. The case has been called the Pike County Massacre, and it is Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

Billy's wife Angela and son Jake have taken plea deals in the case to get the death penalty off the table for all four of them. Billy's son George IV was found guilty in 2022 and sentenced to life in prison.

Billy has maintained his innocence and is expected to go on trial this year. This is an update to where that stands now.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now hosted by Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

4: The Murder of Georg Ann Reiter Feb 20, 2023

Georg Ann Reiter lost her life on September 9, 1970. She was killed near Hamilton, Ohio.

The investigation has new life in the last five years. The Butler County Sheriff's office assigned two new detectives to the cold case. The detectives hope it could lead to new tips and maybe bring them the big break they’ve been waiting for throughout the investigation.

In this episode, detectives reveal Reiter and her friend, Melvira, were in a car together when they stopped at a park along OH-128 in St. Clair Township to talk moments before Reiter was killed.

This is Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast. Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt follows the new leads and speaks to family members as the search for the killer continues in the murder of Georg Ann Reiter.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

TV Version of This Story

3: The Conclusion | The Newest Ohio Serial Killer Jan 30, 2023

In November, the Hamilton County Prosecutor announced a break in a 44-year-old cold case - the sexual assault and murder of a Cincinnati college student.

This is part three of of the case. This episode focuses on other victims and one victim who got away. Jessica also interviews collegue Courtney King who covered the case of Cheryl Thompson extensively for Fox19.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault had been covering the mysterious case of Cheryl Thompson's death for years as the news broke that Ralph Howell was responsible. New technology used on decades old evidence indicates that Howell may have killed a total four young women.

This is Season Two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast. Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the case, learns about the victims, explains what led investigators to Ralph Howell, and why they now call him Ohio's Newest Serial Killer.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

TV Story on Ralph Howell

**2: Victim #2 | The Newest Ohio Serial Killer** Jan 23, 2023
This is part two of three episodes covering The Newest Ohio Serial Killer - Ralph Howell.

In November, the Hamilton County Prosecutor announced a break in a 44-year-old cold case - the sexual assault and murder of a Cincinnati college student.

Police believe Howell is responsible for the deaths of Cheryl Thompson and three other young women.

In this episode, our investigation introduces the second victim Howell is believed to have killed, Nancy Theobald.

In Season Two of **Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast**, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the case, learns about the victims, and explains what led investigators to Ralph Howell and why they now call him Ohio's Newest Serial Killer.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

Original TV Crime Vault on Nancy Theobald

1: Ralph Howell | The Newest Ohio Serial Killer Jan 16, 2023

In November, the Hamilton County Prosecutor announced a break in a 44-year-old cold case - the sexual assault and murder of a Cincinnati college student.

The next three episodes of Cincinnati's Crime Vault will focus on a case we have covered for years.

The mysterious case of Cheryl Thompson's death was solved as investigators used new technology on decades-old evidence pointing to Howell.

However, police believe Howell is responsible for the deaths of four young women.

In Season two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the case, learns about the victims, and explains what led investigators to Ralph Howell and why they now call him Ohio's Newest Serial Killer.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

TV Story on Ralph Howell

Season 2 - The Newest Ohio Serial Killer | Preview Jan 09, 2023

In November, the Hamilton County Prosecutor announced a break in a 44-year old cold case - the sexual assualt and murder of a Cincinnati college student.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault had been covering the mysterious case of Cheryl Thompson's death for years as the news broke that Ralph Howell was responsible. New technology used on decades old evidence indicates that Howell is responsible for a total four young women.

In Season two of Cincinnati's Crime Vault Beyond the Broadcast, Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the case, learns about the victims, explains what led investigators to Ralph Howell and why they now call him Ohio's Newest Serial Killer.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast. A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

15: Pike Co. Massacre - The Sentencing of George Wagner IV Dec 24, 2022

A week before Christmas, George Wagner IV was given eight consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole.

During this episode, we hear from several members of the Rhoden, Gilley, and Manley families for the first time. Plus, we share the letter written to the court by 10-year old Brentley who was found unharmed next to his parents when they were killed in 2016.

We also go one-on-one with Ohio Governor Mike DeWine, as he speaks about the case and scope of the investigation.

Wagner is one of four of his family members accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in April 2016.

Generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre and it is Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

TV Coverage of George Wagner's Sentencing

14: Pike Co. Massacre - Guilty Dec 06, 2022

George Wagner IV was found guilty of all charges against him - 22 counts - including the murders of the Rhoden Family. The jury deliberated only one day before reaching a verdict.

Jessica Schmidt breaks down the verdict, replays the closing arguments from both sides, and shares reaction from the Rhoden family to the Governor. Hear in their own words what they think of the guilty verdict.

Plus, what it was like to be in a newsroom trying to plan extended coverage of the jury's decision. The trial of George Wagner IV took months, but the jury needed only one day to determine George Wagner IV is guilty.

Wagner is one of four of his family members accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in April 2016.

Generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre and it is Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

TV Coverage of Guilty Verdict

GUILTY: George Wagner IV | Verdict in the Pike County Massacre Dec 01, 2022

George Wagner IV has been found guilty on all charges including eight counts of aggravated murder in the Pike County Massacre trial.

George sat downcast and expressionless as Judge Randy Deering read the jury’s verdict on each of the 22 counts.

More to come...

Jessica

13: Pike Co. Massacre - George Wagner IV Testifies Nov 22, 2022

A shocking development on the 42nd day of testimony in the Pike County Murder Trial as George Wagner IV testified in his own defense.

Wagner is one of four of his family members accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in April 2016.

Generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it is Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

This episode, FOX 19 Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down George's testimony as Wagner explains in his own words what he claims happened the night of the murders and what unfolded in the months to follow.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

12: Pike Co. Massacre - The Wiretaps Nov 14, 2022

The months-long trial continues for George Wagner IV in the Pike County Murders. This episode features the police wiretaps, giving you the chance to hear George, Jake, and Angela Wagner after the murders.

Jessica Schmidt brings you the audio from the trial used as evidence in the case, plus she interviews courtroom reporter Mike Schell about the latest developments in the case.

In April 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

11: Pike Co. Massacre - Angela Wagner Testifies Nov 07, 2022

Now it is time for Angela Wagner to testify against her son George Wagner IV in the Pike County murder trial.

In 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were killed in one night.

The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

George Wagner IV is on trial as one of four people accused of the murders.

Angela Wagner would not allow our reporters to record video or audio from his testimony. Angela has pled guilty for her involvment in the massacre, and as part of the plea deal, she must testify against her son George and husband Billy.

This episode chronicles the insight from reporter Mike Schell. Mike has reported on this case since April 2016. He has been in the courtroom since the trial started.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

10: Pike Co. Massacre - Jake Wagner Testifies Oct 31, 2022

Episode 10 features what everyone has been waiting for since the murder trial of George Wagner IV in Pike County, Ohio began. Jake Wagner testified against his brother.

In 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were killed in one night.

The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

George Wagner IV is on trial as one of four people accused in the murders.

Jake Wagner would not allow our reporters to record video or audio from his testimony.

This episode chronicles the insight from reporter Mike Schell. Mike has reported on this case since April 2016. He has been in the courtroom since the trial started.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

9: Pike Co. Massacre - Elizabeth Armer, Jake's Ex, Testifies Oct 24, 2022

This is Episode 9 of Cincinnati's Crime Vault, and we continue to follow the murder trial of George Wagner IV in Pike County, Ohio.

In 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were killed in one night.

The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

George Wagner IV is on trial as one of four people accused of the murders. In this episode, we hear extensively from the ex-wife of one of the accused.

Elizabeth "Beth Anne" Armer was married to Jake Wagner after the murders in Alaska. She explains her life with the Wagners, including the day she says Jake threatened to beat her to death with a bat.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

8: Pike Co. Massacre - The Angela Wagner Interview Oct 16, 2022

In 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were killed in one night.

The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

Angela Wagner has been described by prosecutors and witnesses as the puppet master of the Wagner Family.

Wagner has entered a guilty plea for her involvement in the murders of the Rhoden family.

George Wagner IV is on trial as one of four people accused of the murders. In this episode, we hear extensively from one of the accused.

Ohio BCI interviewed Angela Wagner months after the murders. The recorded interview was played in court as agents testified.

This episode is the lengthy interview as it was played in court.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

7: Pike Co. Massacre - The Billy Wagner Interview Oct 09, 2022

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

George Wagner IV is on trial as one of four people accused of the murders. In this episode, we hear extensively from one of the accused. Ohio BCI interviewed Billy Wagner after the murders. The recorded interview was played in court as agents testified.

*WARNING* We use parts of the interview in this podcast, and there are many expletives used by Billy Wagner. If you would like to hear the entire interview with all the offensive language removed - Click Here.

FOX 19 Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the complex case as the trial continues.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

6: Pike Co. Massacre - Week Three of The Trial Oct 03, 2022

Week 3 of George Wagner IV's trial brought emotional testimony and new details into the Pike County Massacre. Here is the recap with testimony from inside the courtroom.

Wagner IV is one of four people accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in 2016. George Wagner maintains he is innocent.

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

5: Pike Co. Massacre - Week Two of the Trial Sep 26, 2022

The trial of George Wagner IV has completed its second week. Wagner is one of four people accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in 2016.

George Wagner maintains he is innocent. This episode features the new stunning details about the murders, the audio from inside the courtroom, and legal analysis.

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

4: Pike Co. Massacre - The Trial Begins Sep 19, 2022

The trial of George Wagner IV has started. Wagner is one of four people accused of killing eight members of the Rhoden family in 2016.

George Wagner says he is innocent. This episode features the audio from inside the courtroom, opening statements, and testimony with exclusive interviews. Plus, the new stunning details about the murders revealed during week one of the trial.

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

3: Pike Co. Massacre - Murder Trial Delayed Sep 12, 2022

Hours before George Wagner IV's murder trial was set to begin surrounding the Pike County murders, it was delayed.

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

In episode Episode 3, FOX 19 Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt explains the latest developns in the case.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

2: Pike Co. Massacre - Background Part Two Sep 05, 2022

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

In episode two of a three part series, FOX 19 Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the complex case as the trial of one of the accused has started.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

1: Pike Co. Massacre - Background Part One Aug 29, 2022

In April of 2016, generations of a single family were killed in one night. The case has been called The Pike County Massacre, and it's Ohio's largest criminal homicide investigation ever.

In episode one of a three part series, FOX 19 Investigative Reporter and TV News Anchor Jessica Schmidt breaks down the complex case just days before the start of the criminal trial of one of the accused.

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning true crime news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

Pike County Massacre Preview Aug 25, 2022

Cincinnati's Crime Vault is an award-winning news series on FOX 19 Now. This audio podcast will take the stories featured in the news beyond the broadcast.

A team of journalists led by Jessica Schmidt will break down the assignment, the interviews, and the facts discovered as they work on each case.

They begin the podcast series covering Ohio's biggest murder investigation ever, The Pike County Masacre.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Cincinnati’s Crime Vault | Beyond the Broadcast

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected