Bachelor In Retrospect

Latest Episodes:

The Bachelorette Season 3: Jen Schefft, Part 3 Apr 27, 2026

Show notes

We're on Patreon! Come watch, chat with us and enjoy exclusive content: patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

Patreon members can now join us on Discord, where we will be screening episodes as we cover them on the podcast!

Carrie and Annemarie recap the Fantasy Suites and Men Tell All episodes from Bachelorette Season 3! They discuss hetero-pessimism, the surprising narratives revealed at Men Tell All, and as always, what a bad time Jen seems to be having.

For an episode guide and other content, follow us on social media. Instagram: @BachelorinRetrospect, Twitter/X: @BachRetrospect, TikTok: @BachelorinRetrospect

Hosted by Annemarie Navar-Gill and Carrie Rosen

Edited and Mixed by Xavier Rubetzki Noonan

Cover art by Manny Rose

Graphic design by Annemarie Navar-Gill

The Bachelorette Season 3: Jen Schefft, Part 2 Apr 20, 2026

Show notes

We're on Patreon! Come watch, chat with us and enjoy exclusive content: patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

Patreon members can now join us on Discord, where we will be screening episodes as we cover them on the podcast!

Carrie and Annemarie recap Episodes 3-5 of The Bachelorette Season 3! They discuss the anti-France sentiment in America in the early 2000s, the curious behavior of the season's frontrunner, and Jen's continuing quest to just be comfortable.

For an episode guide and other content, follow us on social media. Instagram: @BachelorinRetrospect, Twitter/X: @BachRetrospect, TikTok: @BachelorinRetrospect

Hosted by Annemarie Navar-Gill and Carrie Rosen

Edited and Mixed by Max Quinn

Cover art by Manny Rose

Graphic design by Annemarie Navar-Gill

The Bachelorette Season 3: Jen Schefft, Part 1 Apr 13, 2026

Show notes

We're on Patreon! Come watch, chat with us and enjoy exclusive content: patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

Patreon members can now join us on Discord, where we will be screening episodes as we cover them on the podcast!

Carrie and Annemarie recap the first two episodes of Bachelorette Jen Schefft's season! They discuss the year 2005, Jen's unprecedented celebrity status, and the pitfalls of being allowed to choose the 25 men you date.

For an episode guide and other content, follow us on social media. Instagram: @BachelorinRetrospect, Twitter/X: @BachRetrospect, TikTok: @BachelorinRetrospect

Hosted by Annemarie Navar-Gill and Carrie Rosen

Edited and Mixed by Xavier Rubetzki Noonan

Cover art by Manny Rose

Graphic design by Annemarie Navar-Gill

Christianity on The Bachelor with Kevin Porter! (EPISODE PREVIEW) Mar 30, 2026

Show notes

FULL EPISODE AVAILABLE AT patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

In this bonus episode for Patrons, Carrie and Annemarie are joined by Kevin Porter from the Good Christian Fun podcast to discuss the role of Christianity on The Bachelor! They talk about some notable scenes, the Bachelor's strong Christian subtext, and other pop culture with Christian undertones.

Check out Kevin's podcast, Good Christian Fun, wherever you get your podcasts and at patreon.com/goodchristianfun !

Episode edited and mixed by Xavier Rubetzki Noonan

Bachelor Trivia Gamebook Game! (EPISODE PREVIEW) Feb 23, 2026

Show notes

FULL EPISODE AVAILABLE AT patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

In this bonus episode for Patrons, Carrie and Annemarie face off in a Bachelor trivia contest, hosted by returning guest and Acceptable Man Josh and with questions from another probably-written-by-AI book Carrie found on eBay. Does Carrie or Annemarie know more about The Bachelor?? An incredibly high-stakes, gripping game reveals the answer. (Kind of.)

And don't forget to check out Josh's podcast Writer to Fighter, available February 26th wherever you get your podcasts!

Most Dramatic Bachelor Moments Ever! (EPISODE PREVIEW) Jan 26, 2026

Show notes

FULL EPISODE AVAILABLE AT patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

In this bonus episode for Patrons, Carrie and Annemarie share their picks for the top 10 most dramatic Bachelor moments ever, along with the selections from a "50 Most Dramatic Bachelor Moments Ever" book Carrie found on eBay.

The Bachelor Season 6: Byron Velvick, Part 4 Dec 29, 2025

Show notes

We're on Patreon! Come watch, chat with us and enjoy exclusive content: patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

Patreon members can now join us on Discord, where we will be screening episodes as we cover them on the podcast!

Carrie and Annemarie recap the end of Bachelor Byron Velvick's season! They discuss some bizarre proposal speeches, some excellent work by civilians, and the scariest sink you've ever seen.

For an episode guide and other content, follow us on social media. Instagram: @BachelorinRetrospect, Twitter/X: @BachRetrospect, TikTok: @BachelorinRetrospect

Hosted by Annemarie Navar-Gill and Carrie Rosen

Edited and Mixed by Xavier Rubetzki Noonan

Cover art by Manny Rose

Graphic design by Annemarie Navar-Gill

Carrie and Annemarie's Christmas Lists! (EPISODE PREVIEW) Dec 26, 2025

Show notes

FULL EPISODE AVAILABLE AT patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

In this bonus episode for Patrons, Carrie and Annemarie share their 5 favorite seasons they've covered, their 5 least favorite seasons they've covered, and their choices for 12 Terrible Men of Bachelor Nation. Some of their answers will surprise you! Some won't!

2025 Mailbag Episode! (EPISODE PREVIEW) Dec 23, 2025

Show notes

FULL EPISODE AVAILABLE AT patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

In this bonus episode for patrons, Carrie and Annemarie answers questions from you! They discuss the way men have evolved over The Bachelor seasons they've watched, who they'd like to see on Golden Bachelor, and their time in film school.

The Bachelor Season 6: Byron Velvick, Part 3 Dec 22, 2025

Show notes

We're on Patreon! Come watch, chat with us and enjoy exclusive content: patreon.com/bachelorinretrospect

Patreon members can now join us on Discord, where we will be screening episodes as we cover them on the podcast!

Carrie and Annemarie recap episodes 6-8 of Bachelor Byron Velvick's season! They discuss plastic surgery, creepy male friends, and a dessert that plays a surprisingly large role in the season.

For an episode guide and other content, follow us on social media. Instagram: @BachelorinRetrospect, Twitter/X: @BachRetrospect, TikTok: @BachelorinRetrospect

Hosted by Annemarie Navar-Gill and Carrie Rosen

Edited and Mixed by Max Quinn

Cover art by Manny Rose

Graphic design by Annemarie Navar-Gill

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected