Eating History

Latest Episodes:

Season 2 (Episode 6): The Po' boy Takes on the Hoagie and there Can Be Only One Winner Nov 03, 2026

Show notes

This week, Stephen and Adrienne tackle a heavyweight regional sandwich showdown: The New Orleans Po’ boy vs. The Philadelphia Hoagie. From a violent 1929 streetcar strike to a mob of hungry gamblers demanding midnight cold cuts, discover how these two working-class heroes became legends.

In this episode, we explore:

The Po’ boy Origin Story: How the Martin Brothers supposedly named the sandwich while feeding striking streetcar workers in 1929 (and why historians think that’s only half the truth)
The Leidenheimer Innovation: The fascinating German immigrant origins of New Orleans' signature feather-light, crispy French bread, and the invention of the 3-foot loaf
The Debris Po' boy: Why New Orleans took the scraps from the bottom of a roasting pan and turned them into one of the city's most beloved sandwiches
The Hoagie Legends: Three competing (and wildly different) origin stories from Philadelphia, including a shipyard lunch, an insult about farm animals, and a hungry gambler
The Great Sandwich Debate: Stephen and Adrienne judge the po’ boy and the hoagie on bread structure, flavor complexity, portability, and consistency to declare a champion

Season 2 (Episode 5): How Peanut Butter and Jelly Became an American Childhood Ritual Oct 28, 2026

Show notes

In this episode of Eating History, Stephen and Adrienne trace the bizarre and fascinating evolution of the PB&J. They explore how a high-society specialty item transformed into America's ultimate childhood comfort food, driven by the Great Depression, the invention of sliced bread, and the mass commercialization of affordable ingredients.

Inside this episode:

The earliest known PB&J recipe from Julia Davis Chandler, featuring peanut paste and tart currant jelly on thin bread
The strange Battle Creek Sanitarium history, where Dr. John Harvey Kellogg insisted on boiling peanuts to create a flavorless spread
George Washington Carver’s vital role in championing peanut agriculture to make the crop an accessible economic powerhouse
The technological leaps of the 1920s and 1930s, including Welch's commercial grape jelly and the invention of Skippy non-separating peanut butter inside a converted pickle factory
The hosts' fierce nostalgic debate over smooth versus crunchy peanut butter and the perfect jelly ratio

Season 2 (Episode 4): How the Hamburger Became America’s Sandwich Oct 21, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to Episode 4 of Eating History’s sandwich season! This week, Stephen and Adrienne dig into the disputed origins and massive cultural rise of the ultimate American sandwich: the hamburger. From its roots as a 19th-century German meat dish to the 1906 publication that nearly destroyed the public's trust in ground beef, discover how the hamburger overcame the odds to become a 50-billion-a-year global phenomenon.

In this episode, we explore:

The Louis' Lunch Myth: Why New Haven's famous 1900 origin story is contradicted by an 1894 Texas newspaper ad
The 1834 Forgery: How historians uncovered a fake Delmonico's menu designed to push the hamburger's timeline back decades
The 1876 Centennial Exposition: How a massive, 1,200-seat German restaurant introduced millions of Americans to "Hamburg steak" before burning to the ground
Hamburger Charlie: The 15-year-old Wisconsin vendor who (allegedly) flattened meatballs and sold them from an ox-cart to feed hungry fair-goers on the move
The White Castle Revolution: How Walter Anderson and Billy Ingram used white porcelain, clean fingernails, and standardized systems to save the hamburger's shady reputation

Season 2 (Episode 3): The Sandwich Spreads to the People Oct 13, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to Episode 3 of Eating History’s sandwich season! This week, Stephen and Adrienne explore how the Industrial Revolution took the sandwich out of aristocratic parlors and put it into the hands of the working class. Discover how the rise of factories, densely packed cities, and fast-moving railroads forced humanity to eat by the clock, and why the sandwich was the perfect culinary technology for the job.

In this episode, we explore:

The Rise of the Sandwich: The grim reality of 19th-century railway food, and why paying for a terrible, sawdusty sandwich was better than missing your train
The Invention of Lunch: How factory bells and rigid work schedules forced the main meal of the day to shift to the evening, creating the modern midday lunch break
The Original Ham-Sandwich: How a London coffee shop owner capitalized on late-night theater crowds to invent a booming street food market
The Rise of the Torta: How Armando Martínez Centurión dressed in a formal suit to sell Mexican tortas to everyone from factory workers to celebrities in 1890s Mexico City
Ybor City's Cigar Factories: How the famous lectores (professional readers) entertained a melting pot of Cuban, Spanish, Italian, and Jewish workers who were all trading sandwich secrets
Dangerous Recipes: The 1909 Up-to-Date Sandwich Book that documented the first PB&Js, alongside diabolical creations like the sardine-and-popcorn sandwich

Season 2 (Episode 2): The Sandwich Goes Global Oct 07, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to Episode 2 of Eating History’s sandwich season! This week, Stephen and Adrienne track the sandwich as it escapes 18th-century England and begins its journey across the globe. From a brief military ceasefire in France to a bustling railway station in Japan, discover how the sandwich traveled not as a rigid recipe, but as a flexible culinary category that adapted perfectly to every culture it encountered.

In this episode, we explore:

The 1802 French Crossover: Why France borrowed the English word "sandwich" during a brief pause in the Napoleonic Wars
Silver Sandwich Cases: Eliza Leslie’s 1837 American cookbook that proved early sandwiches were polite, domestic luxuries, not brown-bag lunches
The Convict Restaurateur: How Stephen Bax, an English convict exiled to Australia in 1813, helped establish the sandwich category in Sydney
Nose-Tingling Mustard: The colonial food writings and sharp condiment philosophies of British Army officer "Wyvern" in India
The Japanese Railway Sandwich: How international trade introduced Western ham to Japan, seamlessly merging the sandwich with the country's existing bento transit-food culture

Season 2 (Episode 1): Who Really Invented the Sandwich? Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to the official kickoff of Eating History Season 2! This week, Adrienne and Stephen tackle one of the most famous origin stories in the culinary world: Did John Montagu, the Fourth Earl of Sandwich, really invent his namesake meal to keep his hands clean during an all-night gambling bender? Join the hosts as they explore how an ancient, practical way of eating evolved into a distinct cultural category, and why one 18th-century English aristocrat still gets all the credit.

In this episode, we explore:

The legendary myth of the gambling Earl and why the story has survived for over 250 years
A 14,500-year-old archaeological discovery in Jordan that proves bread predates agriculture itself
How ancient cultures around the world utilized bread as a plate, spoon, and wrapper
Why the ancient "Hillel sandwich" and the Asian bao were brilliant culinary solutions, but not intentional "sandwiches"
The "iPhone Analogy": How John Montagu didn't invent the meal, but helped create the cultural category that sparked endless culinary innovation

Season 2 Reveal: The World’s Hardest to Define Food!! Sep 23, 2026

Show notes

Welcome back to a brand new season of Eating History! After tracking the evolution of pizza across the globe, Adrienne and Stephen return to tackle an entirely new culinary mystery: What exactly is a sandwich? Join them as they explore how "food inside bread" evolved from a prehistoric practice into a powerful cultural category, and why we are all still furiously debating the hot dog.

In this episode, we explore:

The Sandwich Meter: How we put different “sandwiches” into categories
The Definition Dilemma: Why traditional rules (like "two pieces of bread") accidentally turn burritos and po' boys into existential crises
The Sandwich Shop Test: What our gut reactions reveal about our hidden culinary expectations
The Hot Dog Divide: How the history of the American packed lunch separated everyday routine sandwiches from leisure foods like the hot dog
Season 2 Sneak Peek: A tease for next week's investigation into whether the Earl of Sandwich actually invented anything.

Pizza Bites: The Day Pizza Became American Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to the grand finale of Pizza Bites! After an entire season devoted to the evolution of the slice, Adrienne and Stephen tackle the biggest question of them all: When exactly did pizza stop being an Italian import and become an undeniable American staple? By narrowing down the historical timeline between World War II and the rise of fast-food chains, they pinpoint the exact day pizza officially conquered American pop culture.

In this episode, we explore:

Why returning WWII soldiers sparked the fire, but didn't immediately make the dish mainstream
The incredible six-year window (1947–1953) where the press went from explaining what a pizza was to declaring it a threat to the hot dog and hamburger
Why the founding of Pizza Hut in Wichita, Kansas in 1958 was a symptom of the pizza boom, rather than the cause
August 10, 1953: The release of The Caddy and why the debut of "That's Amore" by Dean Martin is the perfect marker for pizza's American takeover

Pizza Bites: Pizza Hut Used to Be Really Cool Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Welcome to the newest slice of Pizza Bites! This week, Adrienne and Stephen take a nostalgic trip back to the 1980s to explore the cultural phenomenon of Pizza Hut. What started as a humble $600 investment grew into a $2.7 billion empire that defined the modern experiential dining era. Discover how a brand that once represented the futuristic cutting edge of pop culture is now successfully betting on the comforting power of the past.

In this episode, we explore:

The 1958 origins of Pizza Hut and the delayed arrival of its iconic red roof
The brilliant 1984 launch of the BOOK IT! reading program that turned Personal Pan Pizzas into kid currency
How red plastic cups, Tiffany-style lamps, and Pac-Man machines transformed dining out into pure entertainment
The irony of PizzaNet, the chain's pioneering 1994 attempt at internet ordering
The surprising success of "Pizza Hut Classic," a retro-revival movement doubling dine-in sales by recreating the 1980s experience

Eating History Presents: History Daily "The First McDonald’s Opens" Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

What if we told you the story of McDonald’s didn’t start with the Big Mac, drive-thrus, or billions of burgers? In this special episode, Eating History presents one of our favorite episodes of History Daily, exploring the surprising story of how McDonald’s got its start, and the people and ideas that would ultimately change the way the world eats.

Every weekday, host Lindsay Graham (American Scandal, American History Tellers) takes you back in time to explore a momentous event that happened ‘on this day’ in history.

So if you’re stuck in traffic, bored at work—wherever you are, listen to History Daily to remind yourself that something incredible happened to make that day historic.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected