Show notes
Winning the AI race takes more than building the best model. It demands hardened infrastructure, reliable energy, and the public's confidence. As AI accelerates cyberattacks and China establishes footholds inside American pipelines, ports, and power grids, will policymakers and industry leaders act before a crisis forces their hand?
In this inaugural Cyber Focus: Unplugged roundtable, Frank Cilluffo convenes McCrary Institute senior fellows Bill Evanina, Alison King, Cynthia Kaiser, and Rob Joyce. Drawing inspiration from The McLaughlin Group, the panel debates AI's advantage for attackers, Congress's cyber priorities, how to impose costs on China, and whether CISA has the resources to deliver on its new strategy. The discussion closes with blunt predictions on Taiwan, Russian aggression in Europe, and the future of U.S. cyber policy.
Main topics
- Is AI giving attackers the upper hand?
- What does winning the AI race require?
- Can the U.S. build public support for AI?
- What should Congress prioritize on cyber?
- Will Congress renew Section 702?
- How should the U.S. impose costs on China?
- Can CISA deliver on its new strategy?
- What comes next for Taiwan, Russia, and U.S. cyber policy?
Key quotes
"Prepositioning, for all the right reasons, is absolutely a terrorism thing. If you look at what they've done to our critical infrastructure, if that was another country... we would be in a war." — Bill Evanina
"You don't establish that credibility through guidance. You establish that credibility by executing the controls and demonstrating that they work." — Alison King
"We're so worried about having the exact attribution, the exact... technical smoking gun, that China's conducting many, many other attacks that are beyond Volt Typhoon... and we have a fear of calling them out unless we absolutely know with 105% certainty that that's happening. And we have to get better at that because they're using us for our process to be able to give themselves the strategic ambiguity they need to conduct more and more activities." — Cynthia Kaiser
"People often pound on the table and say we should cyber them harder. Cyber doesn't deter cyber. I'm sorry, you're not going to cyber them out of our critical infrastructure. We've got to use these other tools. And unfortunately, the biggest hammer we have is economic, and we're unwilling to use that right now." — Rob Joyce
"When we look at frontier models, I have yet to see so much power reside in the hands of so few…to think that they're not intelligence targets for foreign intelligence services is asinine." — Frank Cilluffo
Links
About the Panelists
The panelists participate in their capacity as McCrary Institute senior fellows, rather than as representatives of their respective employers.
Bill Evanina is founder and CEO of the Evanina Group and former director of the National Counterintelligence and Security Center.
Rob Joyce is founder of Joyce Cyber and former director of cybersecurity at the National Security Agency.
Cynthia Kaiser leads Halcyon's Ransomware Research Center as senior vice president and previously served as deputy assistant director of the FBI's Cyber Division.
Alison King is vice president of government affairs at Forescout Technologies, with previous roles at CISA, the Department of the Navy, and the Cyberspace Solarium Commission.